|
A - I n f o s
|
|
a multi-lingual news service by, for, and about anarchists
**
News in all languages
Last 30 posts (Homepage)
Last two
weeks' posts
Our
archives of old posts
The last 100 posts, according
to language
Greek_
中文 Chinese_
Castellano_
Catalan_
Deutsch_
Nederlands_
English_
Francais_
Italiano_
Polski_
Português_
Russkyi_
Suomi_
Svenska_
Türkurkish_
The.Supplement
The First Few Lines of The Last 10 posts in:
Castellano_
Deutsch_
Nederlands_
English_
Français_
Italiano_
Polski_
Português_
Russkyi_
Suomi_
Svenska_
Türkçe_
First few lines of all posts of last 24 hours
Links to indexes of first few lines of all posts
of past 30 days |
of 2002 |
of 2003 |
of 2004 |
of 2005 |
of 2006 |
of 2007 |
of 2008 |
of 2009 |
of 2010 |
of 2011 |
of 2012 |
of 2013 |
of 2014 |
of 2015 |
of 2016 |
of 2017 |
of 2018 |
of 2019 |
of 2020 |
of 2021 |
of 2022 |
of 2023 |
of 2024 |
of 2025
Syndication Of A-Infos - including
RDF - How to Syndicate A-Infos
Subscribe to the a-infos newsgroups
(en) France, UCL AL #360 - Ecology - Political Theory: Was Marx an Ecologist? (ca, de, fr, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]
Date
Mon, 14 Jul 2025 09:54:41 +0300
Several publications by researchers in recent years have revisited
Marx's work to explore his position on ecology. In his known and
published writings, he does not describe himself as an ecologist or a
degrowth advocate, even though his work remains interesting for thinking
about and analyzing the subject. Ultimately, for a true ecology, the
challenge is to rethink our modes of production in order to radically
transform them. For several years, academics have been trying to answer
this question, which seems to preoccupy them greatly: Was Marx an
ecologist? It's a strange question, as it is whenever we transpose a
thinker and his ideas into the conditions and context of a different
era. But indeed, this work can shed light on certain points.
Evasive Traces
It all began with the North American economist Paul Burkett, who wrote
Marx and Nature: A Red and Green Perspective in 1999, and then the
sociologist John Bellamy Foster, who followed in his footsteps in 2000
with Marx's Ecology: Materialism and Nature[1]. Their work refutes the
previously accepted idea that Marx, a victim of the illusions of his
time, reasoned only in terms of increasing productive forces and the
domination of nature, "thus preventing any awareness of ecology in the
subsequent communist movement"[2].
As analyzed by Jean-Marie Harribey in an article entitled "The
Ecological Scope of Marx's Work," Foster develops three sets of
arguments to oppose this vision of a productivist Marx indifferent to
nature: first, Marx's concept of metabolism; second, the presence in his
work of the modern concept of sustainability; and third, the idea of
co-evolution, both human and natural.
Wikimedia/Schlurcher CC BY-SA 4.0
Marx indeed adopted the concept of metabolism from the German chemist J.
Von Liebig, which defined the relationship that humans have with nature.
Marx was concerned with this, speaking of the "metabolic rupture"
brought about by the development of productive forces. But he did not go
any further, because, ultimately, it was the capitalist mode of
production and the fate of the proletariat that fundamentally interested
him, not ecology[3](a word that was then little used).
On the concept of sustainability, we are left wanting, as no citation
from Marx's writings supports this concern beyond a few generalities
about the conditions of existence and social reproduction. As for the
rest, Foster states that "the analysis of Marx and Engels therefore
suggested the idea of co-evolution," and that "one can find in Marx the
intuition of the inscription of human action in the biosphere."
Unfortunately, no citation supports these suggestions.
However, among those who absolutely insist on answering yes to the
question "Was Marx an ecologist?", there is one who is even more
evasive: Kohei Saito. In his latest essay, Less! Degrowth Is a
Philosophy, he goes so far as to claim that Marx called himself an
ecologist, then, after a few self-fulfilling hypotheses, claims that
Marx called himself a degrowth activist! Again, without any citation
from the person concerned. This bias is all the more troubling given
that K. Saito participated in the MEGA project, which publishes the
complete works of Marx and Engels, including drafts, notebooks, and
letters. So, he apparently found no excerpts in Marx's last writings to
support his claims? Too bad. We can't cite them all, but Paul
Guillibert, with Earth and Capital, published in 2021, also attempted
this thesis, without being more convincing.
In fact, all these authors do nothing more than endlessly repeat the
same excerpt from Volume 1 of Capital: "In modern agriculture, as in
urban industry, increased productivity and higher labor output are
purchased at the price of the destruction and exhaustion of labor power.
And every progress in capitalist agriculture is progress not only in the
art of exploiting the worker, but also in the art of despoiling the
soil; Any progress in increasing its fertility over a given period of
time is at the same time progress in destroying the sustainable sources
of this fertility.[...]Capitalist production therefore develops the
technology and the combination of the social production process only by
simultaneously exhausting the two sources from which all wealth springs:
the land and the worker."
Wikimedia/Jim Osley CC BY-SA 4.0
That's pretty much all Marx said about ecology. He returns to it
elsewhere with the example of agricultural fertilizers, which, at the
end of the 19th century, increased productivity but ultimately
impoverished the soil and increased pollution of natural environments.
He thus echoed the ideas expressed by von Liebig.
So no, it would be a stretch to say that Marx was an environmentalist,
but there are more interesting things to remember from his ideas. It is
clear that Marx imprinted a productivist rhetoric on the labor movement,
based on the necessary increase in productive forces, dialectically
developing a proletariat that, by organizing itself, would overthrow the
capitalist class: this is his deterministic vision of history. The
experience of the USSR, with Stalinism, maintained this dogma for
decades, associating productivism with social progress for the working
class.
Against Productivist Capitalism
But planetary boundaries are today a stark reminder that infinite growth
is not possible. So do we need Marx's validation, 150 years later, to
adopt a different approach and develop a theoretical approach to solving
the problems we face today? No.
Marx's contribution lies in his materialism and therefore in his
materialist conception of nature. In The Critique of the Gotha and
Erfurt Program, he criticizes the program of the German Social
Democratic Party, which seeks to attack the distribution of wealth
without seeking its causes at the heart of production. Challenging the
mode of production is still today a path out of the ecological crisis
and capitalism.
His contribution lies in the critique of commodities and this exchange
economy. Conversely, what an economy of use would be is indeed a path
for the coming social and ecological revolution. And his main lesson is,
in fact, a quote that can truly be found in Marx's writings:
"philosophers have only interpreted the world; what matters is to
transform it."[4]Yann (UCL Nantes)
Validate
[1]Four articles by J.B. Foster were published in French in 2011, under
the title Marx écologiste.
[2]Jean-Marie Haribey, "The Ecological Scope of Marx's Work," Actuel
Marx, 2012.
[3]Word coined by the German biologist Ernst Haeckel in 1866. Marx died
in 1883.
[4]Karl Marx, Theses on Feuerbach, 1845.
https://www.unioncommunistelibertaire.org/?Theorie-politique-Marx-etait-il-ecolo
_________________________________________
A - I N F O S N E W S S E R V I C E
By, For, and About Anarchists
Send news reports to A-infos-en mailing list
A-infos-en@ainfos.ca
Subscribe/Unsubscribe https://ainfos.ca/mailman/listinfo/a-infos-en
Archive: http://ainfos.ca/en
- Prev by Date:
(en) Italy, FAI, Umanita Nova - Without the world, Gaza dies. (ca, de, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]
- Next by Date:
(tr) Italy, FAI, Umanita Nova #17-25 - Napoli savaşı ve işkencecilerini reddediyor: liberteryen bakış açıları (ca, de, en, it, pt)[makine çevirisi]
A-Infos Information Center