A - I n f o s

a multi-lingual news service by, for, and about anarchists **
News in all languages
Last 30 posts (Homepage) Last two weeks' posts Our archives of old posts

The last 100 posts, according to language
Greek_ 中文 Chinese_ Castellano_ Catalan_ Deutsch_ Nederlands_ English_ Francais_ Italiano_ Polski_ Português_ Russkyi_ Suomi_ Svenska_ Türkurkish_ The.Supplement

The First Few Lines of The Last 10 posts in:
Castellano_ Deutsch_ Nederlands_ English_ Français_ Italiano_ Polski_ Português_ Russkyi_ Suomi_ Svenska_ Türkçe_
First few lines of all posts of last 24 hours

Links to indexes of first few lines of all posts of past 30 days | of 2002 | of 2003 | of 2004 | of 2005 | of 2006 | of 2007 | of 2008 | of 2009 | of 2010 | of 2011 | of 2012 | of 2013 | of 2014 | of 2015 | of 2016 | of 2017 | of 2018 | of 2019 | of 2020 | of 2021 | of 2022 | of 2023 | of 2024

Syndication Of A-Infos - including RDF - How to Syndicate A-Infos
Subscribe to the a-infos newsgroups

(en) Czech, Ostrava, OAFed: Waiting for the second wave (ca, de, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]

Date Thu, 4 Jul 2024 07:22:51 +0300


We bring an apt contribution to the theoretical section. It could help root out the current unhappy state of our movement. ---- The article by the well-known Prague anarchist Petr Wohlmuth was published on his now-defunct blog 11 years ago, but he still manages to name some trends that we have not dealt with even after thirty years. At the time, however, the article - mainly because of its offensiveness and the considerable unpopularity of its author - did not provoke any reflection in the movement. Over time, Wohlmuth himself worked his way up to the position of those he criticized in his articles, mainly through careful self-censorship of his anarchist past. The following text is, among other things, a critical look at the controversial figure of our movement

Jakub Polák.

During the last twenty years, most of us Czech anarchists have become experts in focusing on legitimate but secondary issues - and pushing aside the crucial ones. Most of us have never made a political "coming out" and subscribed to anarchism as it is - or is nothing - that is, an anarchism firmly rooted in the radical promises of European modernity - one of the last worldviews that carried the message of a consistent, revolutionary transformation of society, and therefore the combative, social plane was completely inseparable from it.

But the unthinkable has been a fact in our parts for a long time now, and many of us show only a polite peripheral interest in anarchism and from time to time nostalgically move our hearts and march under the black and red banners. At least for one afternoon a year, on May Day. The majority of the so-called movement consists of "notorious sympathizers", people who are "inspired by anarchism", but it is not the core of its worldview. Our movement is mostly made up of people who subscribe to anarchism only when it suits them, preferably during big anniversaries or meetings with foreign visitors.

There were constantly a thousand reasons to deal with trifles and leave the essential matters aside - after all, the trifles are also "legitimate". Surely it should have been legitimate to play a punk concert for a dog shelter - than to drive nags off the streets, surely it should have been "legitimate" to organize street parties and other events for fun - than to build some class project and social movement.

Trapped in a foreign language

This situation is visible at first glance in the language with which anarchists talk about themselves. The profiling of meaningless stickers, which also includes the adjective "libertine", is traditional in our country. In the same way, labels such as "independent", "informal", "from below", "alternative", or "anti-capitalist" were overused. Most of us spoke of ourselves in timid language, reflecting the anxiety of being full-blown anarchists. Read its statement "Who we are" on the website of the North Bohemian Association Alerta, written in a language that carefully avoids the word "anarchism".

In the north of Bohemia, an infoshop called "Ateneo" was also recently established, whose name represents another personification of this alienated language. What kind of university is this? Athenaeum originally meant a public educational institution in ancient Rome, and as a general term adopted later, it does not attach itself to any idea. This infoshop presents itself in an encrypted form for every connoisseur of anarchist history. It refers to a kind of "atenea" in Spain in the 1930s, and few people know that in the truly mass anarchist movement of the time there was no such thing as an ateneo, it was always either ateneo anarquista or ateneo libertario, which in the context of the time were one and the same - an anarchist cultural center, usually associated with a workers' evening school. Even Alerta, which describes itself as "the voice of creativity and defiance", only knows "ateneo". The anarchist ateneo does not.

A Czech anarchist, willing to use this term in public at all, is becoming an endangered species. People who don't hide behind meaningless labels, behind a comforting weekend subculture, focused on local mutual help and resigned to a revolutionary project - no matter what form it takes - such people that one should search not with Google, but directly with a magnifying glass.

In the mid-1990s, the first generation of anarchists appeared, who overcame the phase of doublespeak and made a political coming-out with great effort and under very adverse conditions. These were mainly people associated with the Federation of Social Anarchists, later the Federation of Anarchist Groups - or the Organization of Revolutionary Anarchists - Solidarity, later the Anarcho-Communist Alternative. However, their wave has already subsided and at the moment no one is following it.

Anarchists are no longer revolutionaries, they are somewhat more vocal civic activists of sorts. For a long time it has been a subculture of mostly peaceful, quiet and decent people who get together in the evenings and exchange old sweaters and books without using money, watch human rights documentaries or travelogues, cook herbal teas and vegan meals, and occasionally get lectures from of their friends, university humanities students, grateful for the fact that someone will listen to their postmodern thought constructions, which they embodied in their diploma theses.

But where are the roots of such a state?

The legacy of Jakub Polák

Last year, a personality who, for some reason, was perceived by many as a kind of founding father of modern Czech anarchism - Jakub Polák, died. He was the main protagonist of the first phase of the movement in the years 1990-1993, which, unfortunately, rooted in the anarchist movement most of the semantic and thought problems we are talking about - which later left a deep impression on the practice of our movement.

The key to thinking about the current situation is to look at the past. Jakub Polák is not a personal culprit, nor a symbol of the given state. But it is an example that can be used to understand some of the causes.

Jakub Polák himself was different, much more open, he did not hide behind any doublespeak. He came from the ranks of the democratic left (he was the founder of the Radical-democratic group Left Alternative) and often bluntly wrote that for him anarchism meant a somewhat more consistent liberalism with a left-wing ethos. The end, nothing more. This was his boundary, which he consistently defended throughout his life.

I think the reason was simple. Jakub Polák did everything his own way. He remained his personality in the concept of "anarchism" from 1990, when the movement was completely unprofiled and still dominated by two important elements from the period before 1989 - the emphasis on the cultural underground and the emphasis on the defense of human rights originating from political dissent, which in principle rejects confrontational and militant efforts and anti-systemicism.

This is a very important point.

In the key years 1990-1991, the ideology of dissent was transferred to the environment of the Czech anarchist movement with everything that goes with it. Indeed, the ideology of dissent represents the opposite of anarchism as a modernist revolutionary worldview. Dissent is essentially focused on an "internal" critique of power and an effort to cultivate and democratize it, at most some transformation into a "fairer" form. Anarchism is focused on an "external" attack on social power and an effort to remove it and replace it with a positive, revolutionary social project.

Polák and A-Kontra magazine

The first and for a long time the only Czech anarchist magazine - Polák's magazine A-Kontra - inherited its name precisely from the underground. The newsletter "Kontra" was a continuation of the underground Voknovin, a newsletter that emerged from the environment of the VOKNO magazine and was supposed to fill the gaps between the irregular publication of issues. In August 1990, the last issue, the 25th, was published, which was already marked as the first issue of "Kontry". A few months later, Polák appears around the Kontra editorial office and revives an almost dead project with his tireless activity.

Kontra becomes "A-Kontra", which is taken over by the Czechoslovak Anarchist Association, which disbands almost immediately in the same year. The Pole takes advantage of the situation and, after the punk Karolína Zarzycka, gets the (unelected) position of editor-in-chief. Space and background will be provided by the former dissident and activist of the Jazz Section, Karel Srb, in the exclusive premises of Artfór in Valdshtejnská Street in Prague, in the well-known Pálffy Palace in Malá Strana.

Polák did not come from a dissident-underground background. During the previous regime, he went against the grain, but in a different way than his apologists believe today - he was a quirky private entrepreneur without state approval, and at one point he found himself in prison on charges of large-scale theft of "socialist-owned" building materials and attempted murder in connection with by this activity. If his political involvement in dissent and the underground before 1989 is discussed today in connection with how his younger colleagues create his hagiographic myth, then this is at best a historical inaccuracy, at worst a deliberate lie.

In my personal opinion, Poplák always felt a certain inferiority complex towards the underground and dissent and tried to compensate for these circles with diligent activity after 1989. The fact that he liked to be proud of the Award of the Charter 77 Foundation, which he received for eminently democratic, human rights and pro-regime activity, she is very eloquent.

Dissident-underground circles, however, became an environment whose ethos Polák absorbed very quickly in 1990 and gained many contacts there. But at the same time, they became his horizon, a border that he never crossed. That's why there were so many references to VOKNO and the cultural underground in A-Kontra, that's why it contained interviews with VOKNO editors SM Blumfeld and even Frantishek Starek, who at the time was already working for the new "democratic" secret Federal Security Information Service - albeit for anarchists these conversations were basically about nothing. It was prestigious for the Pole. That's why several A-Kontra covers were designed by the underground artist and leading Czech surrealist Joska Skalník. In the same way, Polák achieved that Petr Cibulka produced a number of issues of the magazine in his printer.

A unique fusion of pre-November dissidence and the cultural underground, to which Polák added a little liberalism - that was "anarchism" for him. Polák tried very hard to ensure that A-Kontra and the anarchists around him were perceived as a kind of continuation of the pre-November dissident traditions. His contacts and constant references to VOKNO were used precisely to legitimize this relationship.

Polák did not know his own anarchist tradition and deliberately ignored it. He didn't care. He was not a reader, he was not a theoretician, he could not elaborate or support his views in the overwhelming majority of discussions about anarchism. His "anarchism" was his individual, autonomous, intuitive matter, which had nothing to do with "anarchism" as such, with the tradition of a revolutionary social movement. Polák did not even feel the need to continue the legacy of the old Czech anarchism of the "first wave" from the 1880s to the 1920s. He did not consider this tradition important, knew nothing about it, did not read its authors, did not know its historical experience or lessons.

Polák could not support his concept in any way other than with general phrases about the necessity of a pluralistic, alternative view of the matter. In several discussions, he used the inexplicable term "alterity", which was essentially postmodern relativism. According to him, there were two currents in anarchism - intuitive and analytical. He subscribed to the first, the second was just the proper anarchism in itself, with a project and program of a revolutionary nature. The other Pole naturally refused.

Polák's legitimacy as an anarchist thus came from several specific sources: personal contacts with the generation and group around the VOKNO magazine, from the "legal" heritage of the (A)Kontra magazine brand, and from his great activist commitment. The Pole could simply be seen and heard everywhere. He was at a considerable advantage over others who studied or went to work every day. His disability pension (he suffered a serious work accident in the boiler room of a Prague hotel in the 1980s) allowed him to be a "freelance anarchist", a super-activist who is capable of an order of magnitude more commitment than most other people and has time for everything.

This is where bread broke:

The Pole actually adopted the pre-November, dissident concept, painted in black and red, not of resistance or even resistance against the regime, but an emphasis on legalistic defense of human rights and "justice". Just as the generation of Charter 77 basically rejected the resistance against the Bolshevik system and only wanted to point out its most obvious absurdities, contradictions and errors, so too Polák did not see anarchism as something that should confront the "system" - which was then a novelty for the state and capitalism. Anarchism in his conception was a combination of human rights activities and investigative journalism, nothing more, nothing less.

The Pole did not think and act in the spirit of concepts and social movements like revolution or resistance - terms like "dialogue" and "tolerance" were much more prominent in his vocabulary. If we were to use the contrast often shaken in politics and the media - Pole versus revolutionary anarchists - it was something like Václav Havel versus the Mashín brothers.

A fighter for Roma rights?

Jakub Polák as a fighter for Roma rights is another part of his legend. Polák's emphasis on the pre-November, dissident conception of the defense of human rights and "justice" meant that his policies and actions never posed any challenge to the system. They were just a dogged, honest, but utterly futile effort to force the system to act, investigate and judge fairly. To force the justice machinery to be fair. Squaring the circle.

With the full force of his headstrong personality who always did everything his way, he ignored any serious discussion about anything. He remained ideologically in the 1990s, in the beginnings of modern Czech anarchism, and continuously involved contradictory and senseless initiatives and elements, such as Václav Belohradský, into the anarchist environment and debate. God judge what significance this thoroughly liberal philosopher and left-wing democrat has for anarchists. In my humble opinion, none.

We now circle back to our initial consideration of anarchists behaving as a minority of sorts, afraid to make a social coming-out.

It is Jakub Polák and the tradition founded by him, which is still very visible, that is one of the historical sources of why the Czech movement never carried out its majority political coming-out, why it did not start speaking and acting openly - why it never matured. The underground turned into subcultures, the dissident timid emphasis on human rights was translated by Polák's contribution into a very specific concept of "anarchism" as radical human rights activism, connected with something like a general investigative-journalistic critical approach.

Czech anarchism, which remained mostly trapped in this situation, was not an anti-system, revolutionary force in its majority and for most of its career. The generation of young Polák's successors in A-Kontra provides continuity to this chaos of inconsistent but very radical-looking social criticism to this day.

Non-independent and non-autonomous anarchists

The result of the transfer of the ideology of dissent and the underground was, among other things, that as anarchists we mostly did not promote any unique project of our own, but on the contrary - very naively constantly supported someone - and did not think about ourselves. It's hard to look back like this - but since the beginning of the 90s, Czech anarchists were constantly reaching out to someone and constantly playing tricks on someone - first and then constantly the autonomous and squatter subculture, then ecologists - for some time they made kanonenfutr tied to the Temelín Nuclear Power Plant - then to various non-governmental organizations - then to Marxists and finally also to anti-fascists.

Anarchists, in an effort to get out of the ghetto, constantly focused on some broader contexts that should bring anarchism to a more socially relevant level - but they did not understand that in doing so they were retreating from their basic starting points - non-negotiable opposition to the state and capitalism, to unnatural authority in any form . For so long, anarchists have tried to broaden their horizons until they finally find that they are playing a completely different game - democratic, environmental, human rights, anti-fascist or left-liberal - on a completely different playing field. And then it was too late. In the meantime, the elite anarchist activists have worked their way into the good places in the media, NGOs and academia - and found that they are content there and want no more, and with their newly acquired cultural capital they can easily ideologically control a movement that has come to see them as experts of sorts, superiors to others. As if the truest anarchist was the one who gets a doctorate on a related topic.

The anarchist movement has become illegitimate and illegitimate. He began to be driven by interests other than his own. For the most part, we have never understood that left-wing democrats, NGO workers, or Marxists and liberal environmentalists have never been, are not, and will never be colleagues and partners who respect anarchism. For them, anarchists represent only mostly youthful, enthusiastic useful idiots who will help with a few things and sometimes willingly take banners in their hands. They don't trust us and have little interest in seeing our goals accomplished - but over the years they've learned to be credible pretenders, and the young anarchists come in handy at times.

A clash of two worlds

Perhaps the best illustration of what originally represented Polák's dissident-underground legacy was the large text that sparked the wide-ranging polemic "Defense of Revolutionary Anti-Fascism" in 2003-2005. It represented probably the deepest and most serious debate on the topic of the starting points of a revolutionary, anarchist approach not only to anti-fascism. Two profiled worlds that did not understand each other had already met.

Polák and his younger followers from A-Kontra presented themselves as convinced liberals and left-wing democrats in three long texts of this polemic. They rejected revolutionaryism, rejected opposition to the state as an undeniable and inalienable element of anarchist identity, and recycled the dissident-human rights spirit of the 1990s. They postulated that groups of politically skilled activists could navigate the gray area of the law, use state power for the common good, and achieve some results " here and now". But hey, those results basically only strengthened the existing status quo. If the authors did not cloak themselves in anarchist-sounding rhetoric, their articles could very well be used, for example, in the presentation of the Green Party.

After the deplorable failure of anarchist revolutionary activities in the years 1995-2010, when all anarchist revolutionary groups and organizations gradually disappeared from the scene, or withdrew into practical seclusion, on the vacant stage through their modern-day youthful epigones, the old legacy of anarchism as a dissident-underground human rights activities. A huge semantic shift also occurred with it.

It is more than symbolic that the Anti-Fascist Action was the first to be "cleansed" of revolutionary symbolism and vocabulary, i.e. primarily its website and all external outputs. Anti-fascists were no longer revolutionary, but "radical" and so on and so forth. Where are the times when in March 2004 the magazine Akce published the first part of the aforementioned Defense of Revolutionary Anti-Fascism as a program text. Today, things are different and there is open talk of postmodernism or postanarchism.

Today, we no longer talk about the classic anarchist modernist perspectives of social revolution and classless society, but for example about "social development of the locality", about "strengthening dialogue". All this is, of course, sincerely meant, but old familiar social-democratic vocabulary.

When we are unable to be anarchists in our language or in our culture and its symbols, when we do not want to be public anarchists - how can we hope to achieve anything? If the majority of anarchists talk and think about themselves in a language full of expressions like social development, dialogue, democracy or citizenship, then they themselves resign from their revolutionary project.

Czech anarchism is still waiting for its political coming-out, for its second wave. I'm sure it will come again after some time.

https://oafed.noblogs.org/post/2024/06/11/cekani-na-druhou-vlnu/#more-1222
_________________________________________
A - I N F O S N E W S S E R V I C E
By, For, and About Anarchists
Send news reports to A-infos-en mailing list
A-infos-en@ainfos.ca
Subscribe/Unsubscribe https://ainfos.ca/mailman/listinfo/a-infos-en
Archive: http://ainfos.ca/en
A-Infos Information Center