|
A - I n f o s
|
|
a multi-lingual news service by, for, and about anarchists
**
News in all languages
Last 30 posts (Homepage)
Last two
weeks' posts
Our
archives of old posts
The last 100 posts, according
to language
Greek_
中文 Chinese_
Castellano_
Catalan_
Deutsch_
Nederlands_
English_
Francais_
Italiano_
Polski_
Português_
Russkyi_
Suomi_
Svenska_
Türkurkish_
The.Supplement
The First Few Lines of The Last 10 posts in:
Castellano_
Deutsch_
Nederlands_
English_
Français_
Italiano_
Polski_
Português_
Russkyi_
Suomi_
Svenska_
Türkçe_
First few lines of all posts of last 24 hours
Links to indexes of first few lines of all posts
of past 30 days |
of 2002 |
of 2003 |
of 2004 |
of 2005 |
of 2006 |
of 2007 |
of 2008 |
of 2009 |
of 2010 |
of 2011 |
of 2012 |
of 2013 |
of 2014 |
of 2015 |
of 2016 |
of 2017 |
of 2018 |
of 2019 |
of 2020 |
of 2021 |
of 2022 |
of 2023 |
of 2024 |
of 2025
Syndication Of A-Infos - including
RDF - How to Syndicate A-Infos
Subscribe to the a-infos newsgroups
(en) France, OCL CA #351 - Repression in the National Education System: How to Resist? (ca, de, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]
Date
Wed, 16 Jul 2025 07:49:43 +0300
We interviewed members of the "Collective of the Repressed in the
National Education System: Be a Teacher and Shut Up!" Samuel teaches
history, geography, and literature at the Self-Managed High School of
Paris (LAP, now the Innovative High School of Paris[1]), Kai teaches
mathematics, and Hanane is a librarian. ---- Can you explain what
happened to you? ---- Samuel: I received a reprimand because in an
internal email, a list of teachers, I described "a power grab" at the
LAP and invited people to read Castoriadis because "I prefer a republic
of councils to a power grab by certain soviets." It was this email that
was criticized by the hierarchy, as well as another in which I stated
that we are all-teachers, parents, and students-responsible for the
situation we are experiencing at the LAP.
A reprimand is a symbolic punishment, which I am appealing because I am
proud of the charges against me. As a history teacher, I am putting the
situation into historical perspective.
How did this internal email reach the hierarchy?
Samuel: It was forwarded to the Rectorate by some teachers who deemed it
too political.
In a high school whose political project is self-management, we
therefore have teachers who appeal to the hierarchy to resolve their
conflicts!
Samuel: yes, they highlighted their status as civil servants, they did
as in 1940 when civil servants had the duty to denounce Jews. I was
punished with a reprimand and
I note that the "historical channel" members of the LAP were excluded
from the new "LIP" project.
In traditional establishments, for teachers who worked at the LAP, it is
difficult to have to evaluate for the sake of evaluating. It is
complicated to make projects and that is the end of interdisciplinarity,
not to mention the political project.
For my part, it is different, because I teach in a vocational high
school and I support students in their career path (positioning
interviews, CVs, etc.), in pairs with a colleague, therefore in an
educational position.
Hanane: I'm a librarian, having arrived like the rest of the team at
Angela Davis High School in Saint-Denis when it opened in 2017. It
immediately became apparent that the resources were insufficient given
the school's social context. The team thus embarked on a 3-week strike,
which went down badly with the institutional authorities. The library
without books became the emblematic place of the struggle!
This first struggle united a team that would engage in other battles
(the Blanquer baccalaureate reform, classes of 35, neighborhood brawls,
etc.).
We became too noisy and visible in the eyes of the ministry, following
an action by our colleagues who took Blanquer to task during a defense
on the campus next to the high school. Following this, false and racist
articles in the newspaper "l'Express" implicated our school and also
that of Kai Terada. A general inspection mission was sent to these two
establishments suspected of leftism and laxity with regard to
secularism. We are also criticized for having hosted Assa Traoré for two
years in a row around her book "Letter to Adama".
Until today, no one has been able to read the reports of these missions,
but the rectorate concludes that there is poor and diligent management
in my establishment by a headmaster, formerly on the municipal lists of
the Republic on the Move and a CPE[2]acting as deputy, also in the good
books of the hierarchy.
They practice an offensive policy and five colleagues are subject to
reprimands and reminders of the law in 2019.
After the COVID period and two accusations of VSS (sexist and sexual
violence), the team found itself divided in 2022. The professional
elections accentuated the divisions. I don't recognize the high school.
I am part-time therapeutic and so is my colleague. We then have a
"service supplement"[3], affiliated with the very right-wing SNALC
union. She accuses us of harassment, supported by the head of the second
very right-wing and pro-management CFDT list and by an elected official
from outside the SNES high school who acts without a mandate from his
section. It was very brutal and violent. The principal abuses his power,
blocks all our projects, especially "equality", summons me and practices
a form of police interview against me: 5 hours of interview without
eating or drinking. I break down during this period and it was my first
hospitalization. Despite a union letter, the harassment continues. On
March 10, I was preparing to flee the school with my sister and a
friend, with a knot in my stomach and very sad to have to abandon my
post to escape this environment where I felt in danger. I discovered
that my suicidal letter sent in February was being used against me. The
headmaster also came running, not to check on me but to remind me that I
was not allowed to let outsiders in: my family had just come to make
sure I was safe. He made them leave and I was evacuated by the firefighters.
Without hearing from anyone, in April, after I left the hospital for six
weeks, I went to get some things from the library that I had left in a
hurry. It was administrative days, I was within my rights and it was the
holidays: it relieved me to see few students and colleagues. The
headmaster arrived once again, without asking for news and gave me a ban
on access to the school for "threats" and preventing "public order
disturbances". I am with my 4-year-old daughter: I am devastated by so
much relentlessness and I did not think I would experience this, even
though it was obvious that I would not return to high school.
Without news from the team, I contacted the collective "Be a teacher and
shut up". We decided to set up a support committee after their advice:
it is led by my family but also supported by many feminist and
anti-racist organizations, committed to LGBTQIA+ rights. Fortunately,
these people were there.
Disciplinary proceedings are initiated against me, accusing me in
particular of creating a climate of terror and of having called the
firefighters, following a simulated breakdown! Then after the 4-month
suspension, the rectorate triggers a disciplinary council with aberrant
documents such as a speech on my part during a national strike of AESH[4]!
This relentlessness weakens me even more and sends me back to hospital:
6 more weeks. Nothing stops them and my disciplinary council takes place
without me, without my union and legal defense: I am shocked and deeply
hurt. I feel chased away. I am moved from the high school, I lose my
points after nearly 20 years of career. I feel sullied and humiliated.
Since then I have not really been able to return to work. Despite my
desire to find a place within a work and activist collective. The
rectorate does not let me go and has refused for two years in a row to
allow me to do training for emotional and sexual life or lead discussion
groups on LGBTQIA+ issues. I obtained RQTH recognition[5], I am trying
to go south to start from scratch and escape this toxic environment. We
are working on a short film project: Les naufragé.es dans la tempête
which starts from the letter left by Christine Renon. We see it as a
militant tool to address this institutional repression and abuse, which
kills in real life but also psychologically.
Despite all this, the determination is there: thanks to the collective,
meeting other staff members who are struggling like me allows us to
decenter ourselves and maintain a systemic perspective. We are in a
phase of massive repression and suffering at work in national education.
The repressed are just the front line and the tip of the iceberg of an
institution that reflects Macron's society: liberal, authoritarian, and
unequal.
Kai: What is remarkable and extremely shocking about the proceedings
against Hanane is the use of a video showing her speaking at a militant
rally to characterize her as violent, while this rally and this speech
are completely peaceful compared to what can be done!
As for me, a teacher at the Joliot-Curie high school in Nanterre and
co-secretary of Sud Éducation 92, I learned at the start of the 2022
school year that I was suspended for 4 months without any reason being
given. 15 days later, the rectorate of the Versailles Academy notified
me of a "transfer in the interest of the service" to another department.
I was told that I had not committed any professional misconduct and that
this measure was solely intended to restore "serenity" within my
establishment.
When did you first come up with the idea of a collective, and what led
you to set it up?
Kai: In 2019, during the baccalaureate strike, the contacts made with
other academies to organize themselves continued during the battle
against the Blanquer Baccalaureate, which led to more inequalities.
We knew that a wave of repression was beginning to unfold: Noël Bucher,
an industrial equipment maintenance teacher at the Jacques-Duhamel high
school in Dole, had been notified by the Besançon education authority of
his precautionary suspension. "I am liable to punishment because I was
among the students who entered the school," the teacher said.
In March 2021, four teachers at the Desfontaines high school in Melle
were accused of disrupting the continuous assessment of the
baccalaureate, in the midst of the implementation of the reform, which
has since been abandoned. They will be heavily punished with compulsory
transfers and lowered grades.
Press articles had been published at that time, and when I was
sanctioned, and it caused a bit of a stir, colleagues started contacting me.
We then created an email list and when we organized our first video
conference, we realized that it was very good to exchange between
repressed people, we understood that what is first and foremost precious
moral support must continue. That's how the collective was born.
How would you analyze the repression in National Education in terms of
resources, the status of the people who suffer it, open or more
insidious methods? By comparing it with other professional sectors?
Kai: The year 2019 was marked by the implementation of the baccalaureate
reform, the high school reform, and the Law on the School of Trust, led
by Minister Blanquer.
These reforms were the subject of strong mobilizations. Following the
mobilization against the high school reform, four teachers (the "Melle
4") were suspended for several months and then summoned to a
disciplinary council where they received heavy sanctions[6]. The reasons
for their suspension are vague, such as "breach of the duty of
confidentiality" or "manipulation of students," but no specific act is
attributed to them.
The 2018 Civil Service Transformation Law allows for "transfers in the
interest of the service" and facilitates union repression, because it
removes the obligation to present the measure before the joint
committees. The administration has full powers, without having to
justify its decisions. The pretext is always to "bring calm" to an
establishment, and the targeted staff are almost always union members or
activists for alternative teaching methods. This is the pretext used in
my case or at the République middle school in Bobigny, where two
teachers were forcibly transferred and two others were reprimanded. The
middle school regularly mobilized against the lack of resources and
staff, and for better working conditions.
Furthermore, contract workers or educational assistants are completely
at the mercy of management, which can decide not to renew their
fixed-term contracts at any time, which makes them particularly vulnerable.
Starting in 2020, sanctions will be imposed in the National Education
system across France: Dole will be followed by Amiens, then Clermont,
Bordeaux, Montargis, Bobigny, Rennes, St Denis, and Nanterre, affecting
both primary and secondary schools.
The administration will use all the weapons at its disposal:
precautionary suspensions, exclusions, salary reductions, compulsory
transfers, and even disciplinary proceedings against colleagues
exercising their right to strike and demonstrate, as in Clermont.
At the Mimard high school in Saint-Étienne, the Thuiller high school in
Amiens, and the Victor Hugo high school in Marseille, the management
deployed authoritarian practices denounced by the staff. Through
struggle, the principals ended up being moved, but the administration
made someone pay for it, summoning them in return.
In St Étienne, Patrice Chapat and Sylvain Therrat were summoned before
disciplinary councils, and Patrice was automatically transferred after
the council.
In Amiens, Aude Marécaille, Claire Quaglia, Justine de Reynies, and
Emilio Sciarrino were also summoned to disciplinary councils. The
administrative court of Amiens overturned the sanctions imposed on the
"Thuiller 4" (in particular that of Aude, who had been
sanctioned by an automatic transfer), but the administration, in an
unprecedented display of relentlessness, summoned Aude again to bring
her back before a disciplinary board and to move her again!
In Marseille, the conflict with the principal accused of racism and
sexism lasted for several months and a school year and a half, with a
total of 2 dismissals and 8 non-renewals pronounced against 10
educational assistants. But in return, not only were the 10 educational
assistants not rehabilitated and some were even subjected to criminal
prosecution, but two members of staff, Christine Gorce and Frédéric
Salvy, were transferred "in the interest of the service" for having
supported the school life team!
In Hanane's case, we see the Rectorate start searching the networks and
unearth this video in which we see her speaking, even though it's a
strike day and the speech is "average"!
On June 13, 2024, the administration puts Laëtitia Salini on compulsory
leave for medical reasons. This is the use of medical and health devices
for personnel management purposes. It's about removing people considered
to be a nuisance for spurious medical reasons, supposedly for their own
good.
Do you think that Blanquer and the "school of trust" mark a turning point?
Kai: Article 1 of the School of Trust[7]establishes a "duty of
exemplarity" of teachers towards the institution and insists on "respect
for the school institution, in its principles as well as in its
functioning", in addition the elimination of any structure independent
of power to evaluate the effectiveness of the reforms in progress, a
mission until then assured by the National Council for the Evaluation of
the School System makes it possible to block the possibilities of
contestation.
Hanane: In parallel with this legal blockage, an ideological framework
has been established around the "values of the Republic" and secularism.
This is how we saw Blanquer file a complaint against the Sud Education
93 union for defamation against the term "state racism" and an
accusation of "discrimination". Another complaint was filed by LR
parliamentarians following the organization of racially non-mixed
workshops during a training course (the complaints resulted in dismissals).
There is also a desire to put an end to alternative teaching methods as
seen at the LAP but also at the Pasteur school in Bobigny where,
following a conflict between the headmistress and the very involved
teaching team, the administration launched an investigation which
concluded: "The system[...]of self-management[...]which was established
gradually led the Pasteur school to no longer be a school of the Republic."
It was also the Freinet school project which led the hierarchy to
transfer Hélène Careil[8].
Minister Attal continued this policy around a caricatured definition of
secularism when he decreed the ban on abayas for the start of the 2023
school year.
With this ban, the State intends to further stigmatize a population and
single out those who would prevent the Republic from functioning,
feeding into the themes of the far right. It seeks to transform the
institution and its staff into zealous auxiliaries of a sort of
"clothing police."
These stigmatizations distract from the deliberate destruction of the
public education service (shortage of teachers and staff who help
students with disabilities, job cuts and class closures, incessant
budget cuts, unattractiveness of underpaid professions, difficult
working conditions, overcrowded classes) in favor of the private sector.
And indeed, secularism is subject to double standards... Concerning the
private Stanislas school, the General Inspectorate of National Education
was contacted in February 2022 following press articles highlighting
homophobic, sexist, and authoritarian excesses within the high school.
Catechists "expressing personal beliefs on voluntary termination of
pregnancy or homosexuality" were reported. The report mentions "violent"
and "humiliating" teaching methods. But above all, the investigation
notes that "attendance at religious classes is compulsory" from the
moment of registration.
Even the Court of Auditors has singled out private schools, noting a
"lack of financial control," "minimal" pedagogical control, and
administrative control mobilized "occasionally" only when "there is a
problem."
Is there a shift in hierarchies?
Kai: In primary education, the Rilhac law created the position of
director and granted them functional authority. This is a historic break
that runs counter to the collegial functioning of the teachers' council.
It's not strictly speaking a hierarchical power, but the director
becomes a transmission belt for the academic director of national
education services (DASEN), so the risks of managerial slippage
potentially exist.
What course of action should we have and what strategy should we adopt?
Kai: We must not internalize or hide the attacks we may be victims of,
but rather be aware that repression is an important and essential
political and social problem that must be fought collectively. Victories
have been possible thanks to the struggle. The Administrative Court thus
forced the administration to reinstate me in my position and imposed a
fine. The strongest and most intense mobilization is necessary to
establish a favorable balance of power: strikes, demonstrations,
actions, forums, support committees...
Is repression a global problem that everyone is taking on?
Kai: Repression aims to create a climate of fear. This can work with
colleagues, but a successful collective struggle reenergizes everyone to
resume the path of social offensive. In education, it can also affect
students: we must be vigilant and united. Students and parents have even
been able to show solidarity with repressed teachers. In other sectors,
repression has been intensifying enormously for years. Just think of the
fight against the labor law and the large pools at Sainte Soline, the
yellow vests. The problem is general; the response can and must be done
together.
Breaking News
We learned via a press release from Sud éducation 93 a new victory
against repression!
On May 15, the Montreuil administrative court delivered its verdict:
"immediate cancellation of the sanctions
against Hanane Ameqrane for abuse of power and procedural defect."
Interview by Gaëtan and Zelda
Notes
1. See "Depoliticization killed the self-managed high school in Paris,"
Courant Alternatif No. 347, February 2025
2. Principal Education Advisor.
3. Colleague who works for a few hours in the establishment to complete
an incomplete service of teaching hours
4. Accompanying person for a student with a disability
5. Recognition of the status of disabled worker
6. The administrative court of appeal has since annulled the sanctions
taken by the rectorate against two of them.
7. See "Repression in education, something new?", Courant Alternatif No.
325, December 2022
8. Since reinstated by decision of the administrative court
http://oclibertaire.lautre.net/spip.php?article4464
_________________________________________
A - I N F O S N E W S S E R V I C E
By, For, and About Anarchists
Send news reports to A-infos-en mailing list
A-infos-en@ainfos.ca
Subscribe/Unsubscribe https://ainfos.ca/mailman/listinfo/a-infos-en
Archive: http://ainfos.ca/en
- Prev by Date:
(en) Italy, FAI, Umanita Nova #18-25 - The centrality of opposition to war. General strike June 20 (ca, de, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]
- Next by Date:
(en) Italy, Sicilia Libertaria #460: Castration - Against the obscenity of power: notes on a barbaric law I know. (ca, de, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]
A-Infos Information Center