A - I n f o s

a multi-lingual news service by, for, and about anarchists **
News in all languages
Last 30 posts (Homepage) Last two weeks' posts Our archives of old posts

The last 100 posts, according to language
Greek_ 中文 Chinese_ Castellano_ Catalan_ Deutsch_ Nederlands_ English_ Francais_ Italiano_ Polski_ Português_ Russkyi_ Suomi_ Svenska_ Türkurkish_ The.Supplement

The First Few Lines of The Last 10 posts in:
Castellano_ Deutsch_ Nederlands_ English_ Français_ Italiano_ Polski_ Português_ Russkyi_ Suomi_ Svenska_ Türkçe_
First few lines of all posts of last 24 hours

Links to indexes of first few lines of all posts of past 30 days | of 2002 | of 2003 | of 2004 | of 2005 | of 2006 | of 2007 | of 2008 | of 2009 | of 2010 | of 2011 | of 2012 | of 2013 | of 2014 | of 2015 | of 2016 | of 2017 | of 2018 | of 2019 | of 2020 | of 2021 | of 2022 | of 2023 | of 2024 | of 2025

Syndication Of A-Infos - including RDF - How to Syndicate A-Infos
Subscribe to the a-infos newsgroups

(en) Italy, FAI, Umanita Nova #17-25 - The families of the future are (not) here. Parenting and repression (ca, de, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]

Date Mon, 14 Jul 2025 09:54:47 +0300


THE STARTING SITUATION ---- In January 2023, the Ministry of the Interior issued a circular to prefects that had the effect of ordering civil status officers not to transcribe new birth certificates drawn up abroad with two parents of the same sex and to prosecutors to challenge existing certificates (let's not forget that prosecutors still have a hand in these matters, and also in divorce proceedings). Before this circular, many registry offices regularly transcribed birth certificates drawn up abroad with two mothers, because even if PMA for two women is not legal in Italy, the orientation was that an act legal abroad could still have effects in Italy. The aforementioned circular aimed to stop this practice based on the infamous ruling of the Court of Cassation no. 38162/2022, which among other things stated that the practice of gestation for others (GPA) "offends women's dignity in an intolerable way and profoundly undermines human relationships". In fact, however, this circular also affected *born* with medically assisted procreation techniques other than GPA.

This circular created a wave of chaos because it affected not only newly formed families, but also families who had had a consolidated status for years, who saw their birth certificates modified automatically: there is no deadline for appeal by the prosecutors, so this can happen even years after the act was formed, placing families in a perpetual state of bureaucratic precariousness. Furthermore, the behavior of the offices was very heterogeneous from city to city.

This led to different situations between sisters / brothers and cast uncertainty on many family issues dependent on these situations. Even if this circular is part of the crusade to protect "traditional" families, it is clear that it cannot have had any effect on improving their living conditions, but it was a very convenient way to carry out a direct and wide-ranging attack on many "rainbow" families, generating a symbolic media effect useful for the government.

Faced with the removal of the "intentional" parents (i.e. the biological parent's partner) from the birth certificate of their children, some families decided to oppose it legally (the only possible plan of struggle in this case, even if at the time there were also street protests), managing to reach the Constitutional Court.

THE COURT'S JUDGMENT

The contested provisions are articles 8 and 9 of Law 19 February 2004, no. 40 (Provisions on medically assisted procreation, a law already the subject of a referendum characterized by an intense clerical propaganda campaign), art. 250 of the Civil Code, in reference to Articles 2, 3, 30, 31 and 117, first paragraph of the Constitution, and to some provisions of international treaties, "to the extent that they prevent, to the child born in the context of a heterologous medically assisted procreation (PMA) project practiced by a couple of women, the attribution of the status of child recognized also by the so-called intentional mother who, together with the biological mother (by which must be understood the woman who gave birth), has given consent to the fertilization practice and, in any case, where they require the cancellation from the birth certificate of the recognition made by the intentional mother." (judgment cited) Clearly, we are only talking about PMA practiced legally in foreign states that provide for it for homosexual couples, while the ban in force in Italy remains intact.

The Court ruled that the current situation is discriminatory against those born in homosexual relationships, "as were in the past against adulterous children and incestuous children", because it deprives them of the right to have two parents who assume responsibility for providing for their maintenance from birth and on an equal footing. The Court also highlighted the framework of uncertainty and discrimination between those born abroad and those born in Italy, given that the latter are children of the woman giving birth alone. In reaching its decision, the Court traced the case back to a question of responsibility: the obligations linked to the will of the parents to conceive, expressed through the "consent" given to the use of PMA techniques by the intending mother, derive "from the common commitment voluntarily undertaken" (judgment cited). On the other hand, sexual orientation does not in itself affect the suitability to assume parental responsibility, and in any case homoparental couples are subject, like all other couples, to controls that can also lead to the revocation of such responsibility in the event of mistreatment.

It remains to be seen how this ruling will affect male couples who have resorted to GPA, recently declared a "universal crime", even if - with an extensive reading - the principles applied in this ruling could also embrace such cases.

The main counter-argument of the intervening State Attorney was that the intentional mother can resort to adoption, and therefore * children* would not be left without guardianship; the court rejected this argument because adoption is not "native" guardianship, that is, immediate and automatic, but must be requested by the prospective adoptive parent and is expensive, lengthy and the outcome is not guaranteed.

It is interesting to note how other conservative jurists who have intervened on the issue have dwelt a lot on the obstinacy of adults in realizing their selfish desire to become parents even at the cost of irremediably compromising the interest of the child in growing up with two complementary figures, considered a disturbing attitude that even leads adults to commit an illicit act such as resorting to PMA abroad. Such an "instrumental attitude towards the newborns" would make the intentional parent functionally unfit to assume parental responsibility, a suitability that may need to be ascertained through the demanding adoption procedure.

COMMENT

The ruling, which can be immediately applied to other cases of the same type, essentially recognizes the superior interest of the newborn in homosexual couples to have their status recognized from birth, which corresponds to a set of responsibilities that the intentional mother assumes for the sole fact of having given her consent to the procedure. And this is an aspect that often remains in the background in the debate: it seems that we are fighting against the denial of a subjective right as if it were a privilege, but the recognition of children is also and above all a responsibility that in this case the state denies because it considers LGBT people as "defective", and therefore incapable of carrying out valid acts or in any case as a danger to children. LGBT families are not real families because LGBT people are not real people, but anomalies to be contained. And this even at the cost of orphaning those children who fall through the cracks of the system, who cannot be adopted, or who have precarious recognitions: a beautiful hypocrisy for a fanatically familist majority that regularly uses children for political propaganda purposes.

This ruling is good news because it interrupts the bureaucratic violence and the chaos intentionally created on the matter, and especially if it can be used to obtain more and more and to dismantle other pieces of the patriarchal order. (Although it should be noted that with the same filing of this ruling another was issued, n.69, which confirms the rules that do not allow single women access to medically assisted procreation.)

However, a deeper reservation remains: this type of recognition forces families into the canons of a society based on the current order, endorsing institutions that in reality should be torn down. If it is true that minority subjects need recognition from society in order to be able to follow it openly, it is also true that as long as we continue to base our demands on inadequate tools, we will continue to create short circuits, paradoxically strengthening patriarchal institutions and dependence on the state, as was the case with civil unions. Family, kinship, filiation, arise from the desire and encounter of the subject with the other, but they seek confirmation in the social sphere. As long as this confirmation is mediated and sanctioned by institutions, we cannot speak of true liberation, and this applies to all subjectivities: all subjects of power will always be subjects pitted against each other to divide and control. LGBT people and their families are just one of the scapegoats that serve to distract from the fact that governments are only guarantors of capital and that they prepare internal and external war by sacrificing everyone to this program. Proof of this is that even "traditional" families are not doing well: having children, educating them and supporting them is increasingly economically inaccessible.

Faced with this state of affairs, it is difficult to imagine what the lives - and families - of those born in 2025 will be like...

Julissa

https://umanitanova.org/le-famiglie-del-futuro-non-sono-qui-genitorialita-e-repressione/
_________________________________________
A - I N F O S N E W S S E R V I C E
By, For, and About Anarchists
Send news reports to A-infos-en mailing list
A-infos-en@ainfos.ca
Subscribe/Unsubscribe https://ainfos.ca/mailman/listinfo/a-infos-en
Archive: http://ainfos.ca/en
A-Infos Information Center