A - I n f o s

a multi-lingual news service by, for, and about anarchists **
News in all languages
Last 30 posts (Homepage) Last two weeks' posts Our archives of old posts

The last 100 posts, according to language
Greek_ 中文 Chinese_ Castellano_ Catalan_ Deutsch_ Nederlands_ English_ Francais_ Italiano_ Polski_ Português_ Russkyi_ Suomi_ Svenska_ Türkurkish_ The.Supplement

The First Few Lines of The Last 10 posts in:
Castellano_ Deutsch_ Nederlands_ English_ Français_ Italiano_ Polski_ Português_ Russkyi_ Suomi_ Svenska_ Türkçe_
First few lines of all posts of last 24 hours

Links to indexes of first few lines of all posts of past 30 days | of 2002 | of 2003 | of 2004 | of 2005 | of 2006 | of 2007 | of 2008 | of 2009 | of 2010 | of 2011 | of 2012 | of 2013 | of 2014 | of 2015 | of 2016 | of 2017 | of 2018 | of 2019 | of 2020 | of 2021 | of 2022 | of 2023 | of 2024 | of 2025

Syndication Of A-Infos - including RDF - How to Syndicate A-Infos
Subscribe to the a-infos newsgroups

(en) Spaine, Regeneracion: Against All Defeat, Revolutionary Organization - An Organic Model for 21st-Century Anarchism. Part 1 By LIZA (ca, de, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]

Date Mon, 14 Jul 2025 09:54:53 +0300


Organization has been one of the most persistent and complex debates within anarchism. Far from a homogeneous position, the movement has oscillated between proposals for rigorous structuring and defenses of spontaneity or informality. As Felipe Corrêa points out in Bandeira Negra[1], anarchism cannot dispense with a theory of organization if it aims to intervene effectively in social conflicts and build a sustained revolutionary project. However, this organization must be consistent with libertarian principles, and not a simple replica of authoritarian models.

Index

Organizational models within and outside anarchism
Anarchist Organizing Principles
Types of organizational structures
Informal structures
Horizontal structures
Federative structures
Strategic centralization
Mixed structures within and outside anarchism: contributions, lessons learned, and tensions for revolutionary organization
Hybrid structures from libertarian practice
Holacracy and the role-based organization
Sociocracy: consent, linked circles, and feedback
Teal Organizations and the Myth of Apolitical Self-Management
Flexible structures and autonomous cells
Organizational dynamics and processes at different scales: libertarian structures from the international to the local
International scale: militant solidarity, global accumulation and coordination of struggles
National scale: political cohesion, common strategy and federative organization
Local scale: territorial roots, concrete autonomy and libertarian prefiguration

To address this issue, we distinguish four dimensions that make up any organizational model: principles (the political horizon), structures (the formal form of organization), dynamics (the internal relations of power and cooperation), and processes (the mechanisms of action and decision-making). This differentiation allows us to critically analyze how freedom and efficiency, autonomy and coordination, are combined, without losing sight of the political nature of any organizational form.

Organizational models within and outside anarchism
The problem of organization is not unique to anarchism, although it has generated some of the most intense debates within it. Outside of libertarianism, in spheres as diverse as political parties, social movements, cooperatives, and even businesses, multiple forms of collectively organizing power, work, and decision-making have developed. Vertical, participatory, hybrid, or even experimental models such as Holacracy or so-called Teal organizations -presented as innovations in the world of business and management-address similar questions: how to distribute authority, how to sustain collective action, and how to adapt to changing contexts.

In anarchism, these questions are posed from a radically different perspective: the goal is not to optimize performance or preserve the institutional order, but rather to build organizational forms that prefigure a society without domination. However, this intention does not exempt libertarian organizations from the same challenges faced by other collective experiences: the informal concentration of power, the lack of continuity, the tension between autonomy and coordination, or the difficulty of sustaining long-term processes. Therefore, rather than clinging to a single form, what defines an anarchist organizational model is not only its formal structure, but its ability to articulate principles, dynamics, and processes in a manner consistent with an emancipatory ethic.

With this in mind, it is essential to examine the foundations that have guided, within the libertarian field, reflection and practice on how to build organizational forms that do not reproduce domination. Far from a single recipe, anarchism has developed multiple strategies to confront this challenge from a revolutionary ethic.

Anarchist Organizing Principles
Since its origins, anarchism has not only been an ideology of rejection of the State or capital, but also a comprehensive proposal for organizing social life on new foundations[2]. In this sense, the organizational question has been central. Far from being a secondary or technical concern, how a libertarian collective organizes itself reflects and conditions its worldview. The different anarchist currents-from Proudhonian mutualism to libertarian communism, from revolutionary syndicalism to especifism-have taken up this challenge with different approaches, but with one constant: the attempt to build organizational forms that prefigure a society free of hierarchies, oppressions and dominations.

Unlike the vertical, centralized, and authoritarian models typical of Marxism-Leninism or traditional party apparatuses, anarchism has opted for decentralization, self-organization, and grassroots federation as its fundamental mechanisms. However, the history of the libertarian movement reveals that this approach is not free from internal tensions. The risk of falling into permanent spontaneity, paralyzing informality, or sterile fragmentation has been widely recognized by different generations of activists. As Jo Freeman pointed out in her famous critique of the "lack of structures"[3], the absence of formal organization does not equate to equality: it simply conceals hidden power relations.

In response to these dilemmas, anarchism has developed increasingly sophisticated organizational models that attempt to combine horizontality with collective responsibility, autonomy with coordination, and diversity with political cohesion. The platformist proposal of Makhno and Arshinov in 1926 was one of the first systematic attempts to overcome the organizational deficiencies of classical anarchism through a structure based on theoretical unity, tactical unity, collective responsibility, and federalism. Decades later, in Latin America, these ideas found a fertile reworking in especifismo, promoted by the Uruguayan Anarchist Federation (FAU)[4][5], which raises the need for a specific anarchist organization, with insertion in popular struggles and the capacity for long-term strategic construction.

This debate is not merely historical or doctrinal. Today, faced with a world marked by systemic crises-ecological, economic, social, and political-the question of how we organize ourselves takes on renewed urgency. The accumulated experience of anarchist collectives, both in the Global North and the Global South, shows that without clear structures, without democratic yet effective decision-making processes, without organic links to the struggles of the people, anarchism runs the risk of being reduced to an ethic of individual resistance or a marginal aesthetic. Therefore, critically rethinking organizational models does not imply abandoning libertarian principles, but, on the contrary, making them viable in the daily practice of social transformation.

Types of organizational structures
Informal structures
The informal structure has often been one of the predominant forms in certain sectors of anarchism, especially those that prioritize spontaneity, immediate affinity, or punctual action. Often associated with small collectives, affinity groups, or decentralized networks, this organizational form operates without explicit rules, a formal division of labor, or established decision-making mechanisms. Its appeal lies in its flexibility, operational speed, and apparent equality among its members. However, this apparent horizontality often conceals diffuse power relations that are difficult to challenge.

Jo Freeman, in her critique of the feminist movements of the 1970s, already warned about the tyranny of structurelessness: the absence of clear rules does not eliminate hierarchy, it simply hides it under informal forms, where those with greater charisma, experience or symbolic capital end up concentrating influence without control or accountability. From an anarchist perspective, an informal structure can function in a limited and temporary way, but it lacks the minimum conditions to sustain a revolutionary organization in the long term. Its weakness in terms of strategic accumulation, transmission of knowledge, rotation of responsibilities and responsiveness makes it more of a starting point than a model to consolidate.

Horizontal structures
Horizontal structures are defined by the equitable distribution of power and the explicit rejection of any form of fixed hierarchy. In these structures, decisions are made collectively, ideally by consensus, and there are no permanent positions or chains of command. In theory, this guarantees equal participation, individual autonomy, and the rotation of roles. Many anarchist organizations have adopted this model, especially in contexts where the daily experience of libertarian values is prioritized.

However, in practice, absolute horizontality faces significant challenges. The absence of clear coordination mechanisms can lead to organizational paralysis, excessive assembly-based processes, or fragmentation that weakens collective action. Furthermore, when effective forms of rotation, delegation, and training are not implemented, the same people tend to concentrate tasks and decisions, reproducing de facto hierarchies. Horizontality, without structure, can become an immobilizing ideal.

This problem has been forcefully pointed out by activists within the anarchist camp itself. In his text The Trap of Horizontality , Regue[6]warns that a good part of contemporary anarchism-especially in contexts of the global North-has fallen into a form of horizontalist fetishism that, far from empowering transformative action, locks it into self-referential and micro-group dynamics. The absence of solid organization, he maintains, is not a guarantee of freedom, but rather often the symptom of a strategic retreat from the complexity of social struggle. Faced with this, he proposes recovering a vision of anarchism as a collective and militant project, capable of building popular power and not just resisting on the margins.

As especifist anarchism has also pointed out, it is necessary to distinguish between horizontality as an ethical principle-one that cannot be renounced-and horizontality as an organizational technique, which on its own is insufficient. Without structure, clear delegation, and organizational commitment, horizontality can lead to a mild form of political ineffectiveness.

Federative structures
Facing the limits of absolute horizontalism, anarchist federalism has been one of the movement's most consistent and enduring structural forms. Inspired by Bakunin's proposals and systematized by Malatesta, federalism is based on the articulation of autonomous collectives through mutual agreements, forming cooperative networks that allow for the coordination of actions without centralizing power. Each group or nucleus maintains its organizational sovereignty but connects with others based on shared principles, common programs, and collective decisions made at federal levels.

This type of structure allows for scaling the organization without sacrificing grassroots autonomy, and has proven effective at key historical moments. The Iberian Anarchist Federation (FAI), in close ties with the CNT, managed to maintain solid coordination among ideologically committed local groups for years. The Uruguayan Anarchist Federation (FAU) has for decades maintained a federative structure that combines social integration with political strategy, through territorial militant groups organized into work fronts and a general coordination with specific functions.

Federalism, however, also entails tensions. Internal diversity can lead to political dispersion if there is no strong programmatic basis; collective decision-making can be slowed by the need for broad consultation; and local autonomy can conflict with the need for unified action. Therefore, federative structures require not only formal agreements, but also a shared organizational culture, accountability mechanisms, and a clear delineation of functions and decision-making levels.

Strategic centralization
Although anarchism rejects all forms of coercive authority, this has not prevented the development of limited and temporary forms of functional centralization, especially in contexts of intense struggle, repression, or emergency. This centralization is not equivalent to hierarchy: it is not based on command, but on delegation, and must always be revocable, with accountability to the rank and file. Its function is operational, not ideological; it seeks to facilitate coordinated action without sacrificing collective control.

An eloquent historical example is the CNT's Defense Committees during the Spanish Revolution, which assumed military, logistical, and organizational coordination functions in the face of the fascist offensive. Although they operated with a certain degree of centralization, they did so under assembly mandates, with clear accountability to their militant base and without structural bureaucratization. Similarly, some anarchist guerrilla movements, such as the Anarchist Communist Federation of Bulgaria (FACB), established clandestine operational commands without abandoning their federative principles.

The key in these experiences is to distinguish between functional authority and structural hierarchy. The former may be necessary for effective action; the latter contradicts anarchist principles. Therefore, any strategic centralization in a libertarian organization must be limited by context, controlled from below, subject to rotation, and based on collective criteria, not on the permanent concentration of power.

Mixed structures within and outside anarchism: contributions, lessons learned, and tensions for revolutionary organization
Hybrid structures from libertarian practice
In various contexts, especially in Latin America, anarchism has experimented with hybrid structures that combine classic organizational principles-such as horizontality, self-management, and federalization-with more flexible and defined operating mechanisms. In specificist organizations such as the FAU or the FARJ, for example, grassroots spaces are articulated with political coordination bodies, assemblies with working committees, and rotating spokespersons with collective responsibility. These forms do not seek to mimic external structures, but rather to solve practical problems such as organizational sustainability, effective intervention, or the training of militant cadres. The hybrid here is not concession or eclecticism, but the result of a praxis that takes seriously the limits of pure spontaneity.

Holacracy and the role-based organization
One of the most debated contemporary business models is Holacracy[7]. Developed as an alternative to the traditional corporate hierarchy, it is based on the clear definition of functional roles, interdependent organizational circles and distributed decision-making mechanisms. Instead of a fixed pyramidal structure, it is organized through autonomous teams that relate to each other through explicit rules, under the principle of "distributed authority".

From an anarchist perspective, this structure has useful elements: functional delegation without hierarchical authority, the autonomy of work groups, and the idea of roles that can be modified according to needs. However, in its original version, Holacracy does not question the capitalist framework or exploitative relationships; rather, it seeks to increase the efficiency and adaptability of the company. To be useful in a libertarian project, its technical logic would have to be re-appropriated, disassociating it from the ideology of a "business without bosses," which often merely camouflages new forms of control.

Sociocracy: consent, linked circles, and feedback
Sociocracy , initially developed by Gerard Endenburg, has also been adopted by social collectives, free schools , and cooperatives. Its key principle is not consensus, but consent: a decision can be made as long as there are no well-founded objections. Furthermore, it proposes a "circle" structure-autonomous but interconnected teams-with clear roles, no candidates for election, and formal mechanisms for constant feedback.

Some of these tools are easily compatible with libertarian principles: role rotation, process transparency, and decentralized decision-making are pillars of anarchism. But their uncritical implementation can also generate a depoliticized technical culture, where efficiency replaces political deliberation. Sociocracy can be a useful resource if subordinated to an emancipatory strategy and combined with ideological training and militant participation.

Teal Organizations and the Myth of Apolitical Self-Management
The Teal organizational model , formulated by Frederic Laloux, proposes structures based on radical self-management, personal fulfillment at work, and alignment with an "evolutionary purpose." These organizations eschew formal hierarchy, promote open internal processes, and seek to have decisions originate from all corners of the organization.

Despite its emancipatory discourse, this model carries a dangerous ideological burden: depoliticization. By centering conflict on personal development and abstract "purpose," material power relations are obscured and collective struggle is replaced by individual well-being. From an anarchist perspective, it is possible to revive certain practices from Teal organizations-such as the rotation of facilitators, team autonomy, or a non-punitive approach-but integrate them into a critical political culture rooted in class struggle, anti-patriarchy, and genuine autonomy.

Flexible structures and autonomous cells
In some social movements-and also in more recent libertarian organizations-the use of cellular structures or networks of coordinated autonomous nuclei has been explored . This form adapts well to contexts of repression, allows for the multiplication of initiatives, and avoids dependence on single coordination centers. Its flexibility, however, can become fragile if there are no mechanisms for strategic coordination, accumulation of experience, or ideological coordination. The key here is to provide "flexibility" with a political horizon, which prevents it from falling into dispersion or complacency.

Organizational dynamics and processes at different scales: libertarian structures from the international to the local
International scale: militant solidarity, global accumulation and coordination of struggles
From its origins, anarchism has conceived the international dimension not as a symbolic gesture, but as a strategic necessity. Bakunin's participation in the First International (IWA) and his creation of the Alliance of Socialist Democracy reflect an early effort to articulate a revolutionary anti-authoritarian proposal on a global level. This aspiration has been taken up at various times by networks seeking to build a common strategy among libertarian organizations on various continents.

Among the most relevant experiences are the International of Anarchist Federations (IFA), which brings together federations from Europe, Latin America and North Africa; Anarkismo.net , as a political and communications platform for specificist, platformist and anarcho-communist organizations; and the extinct but influential International Platform of Revolutionary Anarchism (PIAR)[8], created in 2011, whose strategic proposal is still valid in many of the organizations that promoted it.

The PIAR not only formulated a program based on theoretical unity, tactical unity, collective responsibility, and federalism, but also proposed the need to promote an International Anarchist Network of libertarian ideological organizations and a Classist and Internationalist Tendency within the mass movement. This dual structure aimed to combine specific organization with grassroots intervention articulated on a global scale, through joint positions, shared campaigns, and joint political development.

Regarding organizational processes at this scale, size and geographic dispersion impose specific conditions. Decision-making requires controlled delegation mechanisms, preparatory documents, translations, virtual or in-person plenary sessions, and agreements based on common but flexible principles. The management of campaigns or collective interventions must be coordinated through international committees, with internal consultation and accountability mechanisms adapted to the pace and reality of each member organization.

At this level, more than speed or immediate execution, what matters is the sustainability of political ties , shared strategic clarity , and the capacity to generate cumulative processes . For revolutionary anarchism, effective international coordination does not mean imposing homogeneity, but rather building a collective intelligence and a global militant practice based on mutual respect and shared commitment.

National scale: political cohesion, common strategy and federative organization
At the national level, the challenges intensify as the organization grows. Here, it's no longer just a matter of local affinities or direct relationships, but rather of articulating multiple territorial nuclei, with diverse trajectories and distinct social realities, around a common political line. Organizations such as the Uruguayan Anarchist Federation (FAU), the Brazilian Anarchist Coordination (CAB), and the Union Communiste Libertaire (UCL) in France have demonstrated that this is possible without renouncing libertarian principles.

The type of organizational processes required at this scale is determined by size and structural complexity. Deliberation must be supported by tiered mechanisms: local assemblies that mandate regional or national delegations, periodic general plenary sessions, intermediate meetings by sector or commission, and executive coordination bodies with clear but limited functions. Decisions require time and structured mechanisms to ensure participation and tactical coherence, without falling into bureaucracy or dispersion.

Political implementation is organized by area (training, propaganda, integration, finance, external relations), with rotating and collective roles, while evaluation is carried out through periodic reviews, activist reports, and congresses that review both practice and theory. Accountability is an operating principle: every executive or technical body must answer to the deliberative bodies, with the possibility of revocation in case of deviation.

As the organization grows, internal management becomes a strategic dimension in itself: militant enthusiasm is not enough; planning, record-keeping, organizational memory, operating protocols, ongoing training, and a shared political culture are required. A national organization cannot operate solely on the basis of spontaneity; it requires systematized processes that, without sacrificing horizontality, guarantee continuity, effectiveness, and the capacity for sustained intervention in social conflicts.

Local scale: territorial roots, concrete autonomy and libertarian prefiguration
It is at the local level that anarchism finds its most direct and tangible expression. Here, relationships are face-to-face, decisions can be made immediately, and building trust is the main organizational capital. The neighborhood, the territory, the community space, or the work group are the terrain where libertarian ideas materialize in everyday practices: solidarity, self-management, mutual support, direct action, and popular pedagogy.

In small or territorially based organizations, organizational processes can be more agile: open meetings, decision-making by consensus or consent, frequent deliberative assemblies, informal task rotation, coordination based on affinity or tacit commitment. However, this apparent flexibility can become inefficient or unfair if clear mechanisms for participation, memory, and continuity are not developed. Even in small groups, role rotation, record-keeping of decisions, action planning, and collective evaluation are necessary practices to avoid the concentration of informal power, task overload, or the reproduction of hidden inequalities.

As local groups grow or become more deeply involved in larger-scale struggles, processes must become more complex: committees, facilitation roles, work schedules, and monitoring and evaluation mechanisms are incorporated, without losing direct participation or autonomy. Size should not be an excuse for hierarchical structures, but rather a factor in better organization. Political effectiveness, in a libertarian sense, is not a sacrifice of principles: it is their concrete implementation.

The local is the starting point of every revolutionary organization, but it must also be its sustained base: the place where militancy is forged, popular power is built from below, and the possibility of another world is proven in every collective gesture.

Don Diego de la Vega, Liza militant

[1]Corrêa, F. (2018). Black Band: Rediscussing or Anarchism . Faísca Publicações Libertárias.

[2]Schmidt, M., & van der Walt, L. (2009). Black Flame: The Revolutionary Class Politics of Anarchism and Syndicalism . AK Press.

[3]Freeman, J. (1972). The tyranny of structurallessness . Berkeley Journal of Sociology, 17, 151-164.

[4]FAU - Uruguayan Anarchist Federation. (2009). Popular power. The capacity of the people to organize their own society. https://federacionanarquistauruguaya.uy/poder-popular-desde-lo-libertario-fau/

[5]FAU - Uruguayan Anarchist Federation. (n.d.). FAU Fundamentals Document . https://www.nodo50.org/fau/documentos/docum_historicos/docum_fau.htm

[6]Regue. (2024). The Horizontal Trap . Libertarian Regeneration. https://www.regeneracionlibertaria.org/2024/02/13/la-trampa-de-la-horizontalidad/

[7]Robertson, B. (2015). Holacracy: The New Management System for a Rapidly Changing World . Henry Holt and Co.

[8]PIAR - International Platform of Revolutionary Anarchism. (n.d.). PIAR Political Program . https://barcelona.indymedia.org/usermedia/application/7/PAR-ESP.pdf

https://www.regeneracionlibertaria.org/2025/06/05/contra-toda-derrota-organizacion-revolucionaria/
_________________________________________
A - I N F O S N E W S S E R V I C E
By, For, and About Anarchists
Send news reports to A-infos-en mailing list
A-infos-en@ainfos.ca
Subscribe/Unsubscribe https://ainfos.ca/mailman/listinfo/a-infos-en
Archive: http://ainfos.ca/en
A-Infos Information Center