A - I n f o s

a multi-lingual news service by, for, and about anarchists **
News in all languages
Last 30 posts (Homepage) Last two weeks' posts Our archives of old posts

The last 100 posts, according to language
Greek_ 中文 Chinese_ Castellano_ Catalan_ Deutsch_ Nederlands_ English_ Francais_ Italiano_ Polski_ Português_ Russkyi_ Suomi_ Svenska_ Türkurkish_ The.Supplement

The First Few Lines of The Last 10 posts in:
Castellano_ Deutsch_ Nederlands_ English_ Français_ Italiano_ Polski_ Português_ Russkyi_ Suomi_ Svenska_ Türkçe_
First few lines of all posts of last 24 hours

Links to indexes of first few lines of all posts of past 30 days | of 2002 | of 2003 | of 2004 | of 2005 | of 2006 | of 2007 | of 2008 | of 2009 | of 2010 | of 2011 | of 2012 | of 2013 | of 2014 | of 2015 | of 2016 | of 2017 | of 2018 | of 2019 | of 2020 | of 2021 | of 2022 | of 2023 | of 2024 | of 2025

Syndication Of A-Infos - including RDF - How to Syndicate A-Infos
Subscribe to the a-infos newsgroups

(en) Spaine, Regeneracion: The May Events and the Libertarian Youths By Batzac - Libertarian Youths (ca, de, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]

Date Sat, 12 Jul 2025 09:08:25 +0300


We anarchists do not come out of nowhere. Our statements, tactics, strategies, speeches, our political articulation in general arise from the revolutionary generations that preceded us. We are inserted in a political tradition about which we have the conviction that it is the seed of the revolution and that, throughout its victories and failures, has fought for the Social Revolution. As they were, so we are. ---- Inserted in this red-and-black thread of combat, we have the historical duty to move forward. We must find the tools that another generation had already buried and raise a revolutionary anarchist position capable of being equal to the historical moment in which we find ourselves. As we are, so we will be.

From the first battles with the rising bourgeoisie to the most recent political cycle, anarchists have organized themselves with the tools they had at their disposal and acted with the knowledge they had obtained and retained. We have been inserted into revolutionary movements to the best of our abilities and have given our strength to overcoming the capitalist system. To successfully carry out our revolutionary task, anarchists equip themselves with the historical balance, the tool to avoid mistakes, overcome the past and continue on the right path.

Anarchists are inserted in a specific revolutionary political movement. The adherents of anarchism have been specific militants, who have had a specific practice, specific mistakes and successes, within the revolutionary history of the working class. Anarchists cannot allow themselves to claim in the same speech, for example, people as opposed as Puig-Antich and Miquel Badia, or, in another example, the POUM, militants of the CNT and the PSUC of the Transition at the same time. We have our references, our dead, our historical thread to continue weaving.

Within this historical thread we have an episode of the international class struggle on which relatively little light has been shed. Although rivers of ink have been written about the Civil War, it has always been written hegemonically from the perspective of only two sides: the Republic and fascism. When the CNT or anarchism has been addressed during the Spanish Revolution, it has usually been discussed within the Popular Front side, although there were disagreements within it. The May Events are the culmination, the high point of the disagreements in the story, a more or less unfortunate confrontation, or a Civil War within the Civil War.

In bourgeois historiography and opinion, these clashes are a disgrace, a bloodshed of Catalans against Catalans due to uncontrolled anarchists. This is the concealment of the facts. To combat bourgeois historiography, it is necessary to present the revolutionary potential of the rebels in the May Events, but also their limitations. It is necessary to frame the Civil War as what it was, a crushed social revolution, and represent its profoundly classist character, prefigured by previous labor and social conflicts. Only in this way will we be able to make a historical assessment worthy of its name and its necessity. It is necessary to unearth the past, combat its characterization and recover the lessons that we can extract from it.

Therefore, this article has three objectives.

First, combat bourgeois historiography, which distorts the facts and places itself on one side of the trench through its appearance of neutrality. Also combat other historical visions that dishonestly seek to hide their errors and their role in the defeat.
Second, to outline a vision of history for the Libertarian Youth, enhancing its role and becoming an agent in the fight for history.
Third, defend the need to open and participate in historical debates about the Civil War, as they form part of the historical balance of the working class.
Context towards the May Events

The working class defeated the coup d'état in the streets of Barcelona on July 18, 1936. The key factor in this victory was the clandestine and organized combat tool of anarchism: the Defense Committees of the CNT, made up of CNT, FAI and Libertarian Youth militants, a tool attached and subordinate to the CNT. It should be mentioned that the structure and formalization of this clandestine organization was reformulated in the report of the National Committee of Defense Committees of October 1934, in the midst of the defeat of the proletarian rebellion in Asturias. In other words, this tool emerged from the militant assessment that organized anarchism made of its own activity.

As foreseen in the structure of the Defense Committees, they multiplied, giving rise to a constellation of Coverage, Neighborhood, Control Committees, etc. that were responsible for a multitude of revolutionary tasks, such as supplying and recruiting the popular militias, feeding the population, public control tasks and the suppression of bourgeois forces.

With the defeat of the army, the libertarian movement spread throughout the territory to make the Revolution effective, collectivizing land and industries, persecuting the bourgeoisie and crossing the Principality towards Zaragoza, to combat reaction.

However, with the army defeated, President Companys summoned the political organizations to the Palau de la Generalitat on July 20. The CNT made a decision that would shape its course: it accepted collaboration within a broad front with the other anti-fascist forces, in the Central Committee of Anti-Fascist Militias (CCMA).

The CCMA will not be a government nor will it allow it to govern. It will try to play dual power with the Government, until the latter absorbs it two months later. However, this will have two important repercussions on anarchist militancy.

First, it will place anarchism, in superior strength in Catalonia, in a situation of equal power with the rest of the organizations. That is, it will give political character to minority organizations that act (in theory and in practice) against the ongoing revolution, giving them the tools to grow and to oppose the revolutionary conquests, organizations that had no other credentials to be there than the quality of anti-fascists and the ability to mobilize armed forces.

Second, it will equate anarchist organizations with political parties in character. The representatives of the CNT will be required to impose the discipline of the CCMA and, later, of the government, on their militancy. A substantial part of the grassroots militancy of the anarchist organizations opposes the entry of the CNT and the FAI into the CCMA and, later, will oppose many of the measures taken in these spaces. This militancy opposes the militarization of militias, government inspectors in factories or the reactivation of the forces of order because these are the measures of the enemy against whom they had been forged by fighting: the State.

From then on, the anarchist militants would carry out their activity under two opposing pressures: the exercise of the functions conquered on July 18 and the tendency towards centralization under a single anti-fascist government.

The CNT and the FAI will create a "Committee of Committees[1]" responsible for making quick decisions and convincing the militancy of the need for the CNT and the FAI to enter the CCMA. They will believe in the strength and ability to negotiate in an advantageous position in the CCMA and the Generalitat, but they will mold themselves in the esprit de corps of the parties with which they shared space. In the name of the revolution they will embark on the construction of a strong state and will appease all resistance to it.

The revolutionaries who transformed social relations in the July days would see their conquests sabotaged and annulled: the hibernation of the Confederal Defense Committees, the dissolution of the Control Patrols, the intervention of the Generalitat in collectivized industries and the militarization of the militias, while the PSUC and the PCE formed an internal repression body directed against the POUM and the CNT, which would end up crystallizing in the Military Information Service.

The Libertarian Youth of Catalonia will form part of this militant base that opposes the destruction of revolutionary conquests. Having bled in the July days and actively participated in the controls and assaults of those days, the libertarian youth opposed the entry of anarchism into the government. In their multiple local dissemination organs and in the Ruta, the libertarian youth expressed the contradiction of "state anarchism" and the renunciation of principles in the direction of the defeat of fascism.

In this climate, on April 26, 1937, Antonio Martín Escudero was assassinated in Bellver de Cerdanya. Antonio Martín was a long-time CNT militant who had been wounded in the Tragic Week. The local Committee of Puigcerdà, chaired by himself, controlled the border crossing in Cerdanya, preventing the escape of bourgeois and clerical elements and, more importantly, it pursued and controlled the smuggling of food by speculators allied to Estat Català and the PSUC[2]who crossed the border to sell their products in Barcelona at stratospheric prices, outside the control of the CNT Supply Committees. This assassination would provoke a government crisis that would prelude the May Events.

The Libertarian Youth in Catalonia during the Revolution

The Joventuts Llibertarias[3], formed in 1932, suffered from little organic development when July 1936 arrived. This did not prevent them from being an active part of the armed reaction against the coup d'état. We will list some examples. In the days before the coup d'état they held night watches in their neighbourhoods and towns, ready to act. In the July days they took action. The militancy of the JJLL of Santa Coloma de Gramenet and Sant Adrià del Besòs participated in the siege of the Sant Andreu barracks, and the latter also set up a barricade on the bridge over the Besòs river. The JJLL of Barceloneta were present at the barricades on Avinguda Icària. The JJLL of La Torrassa assaulted the Pedralbes barracks. The JJLL of Maresme took weapons from the Mataró barracks.

During this first phase of the Civil War, the JJLL of Catalonia were integrated into the joint actions of anarchism: they participated in the Control Patrols, in the Columns of militiamen, in collectivizations... This can be understood by the widespread practice of dual CNT-FIJL militancy.

The Libertarian Youths founded, with the related Student Federation of Free Consciences, the Popular University, in the building of the Seminary Conciliar of Barcelona. This was considered a preliminary step for the training of workers and their access to official universities, which would allow them to overcome the economic barrier of entry and teach with methodologies that had a social vision. In addition, under the leadership of their Regional Committee, they seized premises and filled them with cultural, propaganda, educational and community activities, seeking progress in the people that would lead them to Libertarian Communism.

In 1937, the Joventuts Llibertarias de Catalunya had around 34,000 members and 214 groups. They were part of the militias at the front, and opposed the militarization of the militias and the retreat in revolutionary conquests. They found in the reactivation of the CNT Defense Committees[4]the place to strengthen themselves to defend these positions, together with their fellow CNT and FA members, and the recently created Agrupación de Los Amigos de Durruti. They also proclaimed in the Ruta that it was necessary to be alert to counter-revolutionary maneuvers.

The events of the May Events

By decree of 4 March (approved by the councillors of the Generalitat, including the anarchists) the Defence Committees were to be dissolved, which went underground. The Control Patrols[5]were also threatened with dissolution, and de facto neutralized until their effective dissolution and persecution in June, which led to the exile of a large number of their members[6].

In the second half of March 1937, the Confederal Defense Committee of Barcelona prepared a "Plan for the Structure of the Defense Cadres and Committees", under the following reason:

"With the universal collapse of parties and systems, only the Revolutionary Proletariat remains standing, with its program of reorganization of labor and economic and social equality."

The JJLL of Catalonia maintained a position of watchfulness and public defense of revolutionary conquests, opposed to the unity government to which the libertarian organizations were to be subordinated and to the retreat in collectivizations and popular militias. In Ruta of April 1, 1937 they wrote:

"Before we renounce the fight against fascism, we will die in the trenches! Before we renounce the revolution, we will die on the barricades! (...) Never turn back! Stop the counterrevolution!"

On April 12, 1937, the Plenary of the Barcelona Local Federation of Anarchist Groups (the Barcelona city organ of the FAI), to which the Libertarian Youth and the Defense Committees had been invited, demanded the withdrawal of the CNT members from the government and created an Insurrectionary Committee. On April 15, the formation of a new Government was agreed upon to overcome the crisis, with Aurelio Fernández as an anarchist councilor. On April 27, as we have said before, Antonio Martín was assassinated, and the government was dissolved[7]. It is worth highlighting the searches and disarmaments of JJLL militants by the Civil Guard and Assault during the nights during these weeks, when they resolved to patrol together with the Anarchist Groups to avoid confrontations.

Prior to the May Events, incidents also occurred in the town of Vinalesa, where an attempt was made to shoot 150 anarchists from the collectivized textile and tile factories. A "captain with a little humanity" managed to avoid execution[8]. In Barcelona, there was also a "bread war" between Joan Comorera of the PSUC and the Supply Committees due to public opinion in the face of the state of hunger and high food prices suffered by the population, where the former called for the restoration of the free market prior to the Revolution as a solution[9]. In the town of Cistella, militants of the minority nationalist party "Estat Català" arrested the JJLL militant Josep Planells for wanting to form a local Libertarian Youth. Militants of the same party shot a young libertarian on May 2 at a meeting of the Front de la Joventut Revolucionària[10].

Finally, it is necessary to mention the struggle for the militarization of the militias, which led to the creation of the group Los Amigos de Durruti from the Fourth Group of the Durruti Column.

On May 3, 1937, around noon, three trucks full of Assault Guards led by Rodríguez Salas, of the UGT, positioned themselves in front of the Telefónica building, controlled by the CNT. The Stalinist militant, with the signature of the Minister of Internal Security Aiguader (an ERC and Estat Català activist) sought to reestablish state ownership of the communications center, which was the responsibility of the Republic. He stormed the building, and the CNT militants defended themselves. The CNT Defense Committees were warned of this movement by Manuel Escorza del Val, of the CNT Information Service, and supporter of the April 15 government pact.[11]

In immediate response and following the orders of the CNT Defense Committees, barricades were erected throughout the city. The Local Federation of Anarchist Groups took responsibility and led the fight, lifting the siege of the building, taking the artillery batteries of Montjuïc and creating a CNT Revolutionary Committee on May 4th.

The Group of Friends of Durruti established its headquarters at the intersection of La Rambla and Carrer Hospital, linking up with the barricades of the Defense Committees and about forty militiamen who had descended on Barcelona in the previous days.[12]

On the 4th and 5th, the Sants Defense Committee stormed the Guard of Assault barracks in Plaça d'Espanya and the Guard of the National Guard in Casarramona.[13]President Companys appealed to the central government to use aviation to bomb Barcelona, but his plea was rejected. At the meetings of Los Amigos de Durruti on 4 May, the JJLL encouraged them to continue the fight .[14]In Tarragona, the JJLL fired on the building occupied by the UGT, and on the 6th, the forces of Public Order, together with members of ERC, UGT and PSUC, stormed the JJLL headquarters. Similar events occurred in Tortosa, Figueres and Maresme, and members of the JJLL also traveled to Barcelona to take part in the fight.

Having won in the streets, the anarchist militancy lays down its arms when the CNT Higher Committees appeal for anti-fascist unity on the radio. García Oliver's speech[15]lowers the spirits of the rebelling militants, and a group of the CNT Regional Commissions, the FAI and a JJLL commission approach the barricades to negotiate. On Friday the 7th, some workers, discouraged by the surrender of the CNT and POUM leadership, return to the barricades, but the lack of strength of Los Amigos de Durruti and the promises of the CNT and FAI leadership make the latter abandon the barricades. The CNT leadership declares that the CNT and FAI continue to collaborate faithfully with the Government[16].

In García Oliver's speech, it is argued that it was necessary to disarm the resistance so that it would not give rise to the bloody and brutal elimination of organized anarchism. Reality showed that the end of the resistance meant the beginning of the bloodiest phase of the physical and bloody elimination of anarchism by the PSUC, the PCE and the nationalist parties. We will make a brief report, by no means exhaustive given the magnitude of the counterrevolutionary repression, trying to focus on the murders immediately following the May Events to refute García Oliver's claim.

On May 4, five young libertarians from the JJLL of l'Harmonia (currently the Sant Andreu del Palomar neighborhood) were traveling by car through Barcelona. After crossing Gran Via de la URSS (currently Avinguda Meridiana), on Passeig Pujades, they were stopped by gunfire. Days later, the same car would appear with shrapnel holes inside the Carlos Marx barracks of the PSUC. On May 8, a Red Cross ambulance unloaded 12 brutally mutilated corpses next to a vineyard near Cerdanyola, and on May 9, a photographer, called by the Defense Minister of Cerdanyola, photographed the 12 corpses, one of them with the initials CNT embroidered on his blue overalls.

On May 5, Camilo Berneri and Francesco Barberi (the former, publicly critical of the CNT's collaboration with other political forces) were shot dead in the street after being kidnapped from their home. The two Italian anarchists had the misfortune of living right in front of a UGT headquarters, where the PSUC erected a barricade to protect the confederal advance towards the Generalitat from Via Durruti (now Via Laietana). UGT militants claimed that they had permission to search the house due to the suspicion of the presence of "armed Italian anarchists" and "counter-revolutionaries". An ambulance collected their bodies from the street for an autopsy. The former, a long-time anarchist militant, was buried discreetly and without honors under the orders of the CNT's higher committees "so as not to inflame spirits"[17].

On 7 May, "communist assassins" kidnapped Alfredo Martínez Hungría, of the JJLL and the FAI, and murdered him. His body was never found, and it is believed that it is one of the corpses that was later found in Cerdanyola del Vallès[18]. On the morning of 7 May, around fifty anarchists were arrested in Tarragona and 12 were shot, including Juan Rua, of the Joventuts Llibertarias.

After the May Events, there was a general repression of the POUM, which also participated in the days, and of the libertarian movement. The first was outlawed and persecuted, its leader Andreu Nin disappeared and its militants dispersed or shot. The complete disarticulation of the revolutionary order conquered in the July days goes beyond this article, but it includes Líster's advance towards Aragon to dissolve the collectivizations, the militarization of the militias and of labor, the censorship of the media and the freedom of the SIM and the agents of the USSR to arrest, torture, execute and send to labor camps[19]anyone at will. With the revolutionary power defeated, the counterrevolution advances without stopping, and, consequently, the reaction.

The significance of the May Events

We anarchists do not believe in the triumph of the will over social and material realities, but rather in the unity of means and ends, in the determination of the latter by the former. We have a program, libertarian communism, which is based on an objective, the defeat of the State. We believe that these ends require specific means, specific forms of practice, which we do not believe were discovered at a specific moment in history but are determined by the historical balance.

As outlined earlier, early 20th century anarchism had a strong trajectory of struggle. This was deployed on many fronts (labor, housing, military, cultural, etc.), and we can say that it tended, or had the will to tend, towards framing all the aspects in which the reality of the working class is presented. This struggle was developed in an anti-state sense, in the discrediting of bourgeois institutions, in developing the strength of the working class, in conquering advances, building referentiality and heading towards a horizon of victory over the bourgeoisie and its army that seemed possible and feasible.

Collaboration with the government of the Generalitat, ministerial portfolios in the regional and central governments, anti-fascist unity as a weapon to disavowal revolutionary conquests, the belief in a strong state to subdue the enemy, the creation of Higher Committees with decision-making power over the militancy... in short, "renouncing everything but victory"[20], implies a change in the means that had been used until July 18, 1936, and, therefore, prefigures a different end. The May Events of 1937, as a turning point in the advance of the counterrevolution, imply the rubric of this disconnection between means and ends.

The adherence to the strong state program by the representative committees of the CNT, FAI and FIJL represents a betrayal. The same cannot be said of the PSUC, ERC, PCE and Estat Català, which carried it as their banner from the beginning of the confrontation, and therefore, one cannot speak of betrayal of principles. Counterrevolutionary propaganda argues for the infiltration of fascist elements into the POUM and the CNT, an alleged betrayal or a lack of loyalty that represents a de facto alliance with Franco. However, just as in the past we have argued for a continuity between the ERC gunmen and the Francoist repressive apparatus[21], we can also argue for an equality between the repressive apparatus of the counterrevolution and the Francoist repressive apparatus. Ensconced in state power and with revolutionary power disarticulated from May 1937, the Military Information Service, the High Treason and Espionage Court, the NKVD[22]and the militancy of the PSUC first and the PCE later applied their program of strong state and iron discipline. They defeated the other parties in the struggle for control of the state, and used the same means on the working class to achieve anti-fascist unity as those used by the Francoist side to achieve national and ideological unity on their side of the trenches: arrest, imprisonment, torture, execution, labor camp, military tribunal, exile. With equal means, equal ends are reached: the defeat of the working class.

The revolutionary defeat during the May Events highlights the importance of defending, as an organization, the unity between means and ends, a guiding principle of anarchism.

On the need for strategic organization and the empowerment of the working masses

There is also a legend about the May Events that the insurrection and the raising of the barricades were the work of the spontaneous action of the working masses. This legend must be refuted: the Defense Committees coordinated the insurrection on May 3, 1937 in the same way that they coordinated the defense against the coup d'état on July 18, 1936. The Defense Committees, together with the Neighborhood and Area Committees, formed an organized militant network that was in close contact with the suffering of the working class of Barcelona during the bread war, supported by militants of the specific anarchist organizations, the anarcho-syndical and the grouping of Los Amigos de Durruti. Together they were able to give strategic instructions to the working class and generate their own leadership, in (temporary) opposition to the high echelons of the CNT.

The rebels were defeated by word, by the trust and loyalty they had in the CNT, but they would not have had much recourse to military means either. The uprising of Los Amigos de Durruti is the highest point of revolutionary clarity of the working class in Catalonia, but also the expression of defeat in the face of an offensive that had begun in the last days of July 1936. The Amigos de Durruti "were barricade people, they were not good organizers, and even worse theorists, although they had good journalists"[23], and "only" included 5000 militants. Even so, they were able to generate enough referentiality, have enough double militancy in the organs of the CNT and enough influence within the working class to take the city of Barcelona for four days.

No other specific organization in Catalonia could have taken on this role. On the one hand, the FAI had "disappeared", had been inserted into the CNT in its revolutionary conquests, in collectivizations, militias, positions of responsibility... and had largely ceased its activity at the beginning of the Civil War[24]. However, it was the local anarchist groups in Barcelona that formed a Revolutionary Committee. On the other hand, the Joventuts Llibertarias were a very young organization, with little organic history, a quality with which we can also describe Mujeres Libres. Nevertheless, they were faithful to their principles and put their bodies on the streets in May 1937.

We specifists claim the need for an anarchist strategic organization for the defense of class independence. Like the Amigos de Durruti and the FAI, an anarchist organization is necessary that is capable of transforming the suffering and exploitation of the working class into a strategy capable of overcoming the state of affairs, side by side with the organization of the working class.

The defense of class independence also implies the defense of workers' democracy within the grassroots organizations. It is clear that with the formation of the "Committee of Committees", its irrevocability and its leading role over the libertarian movement, the principle of revocability of positions typical of the libertarian movement was broken. There was no situation of control over one's own representation within the CNT, which was the organization of the working class in Spain, nor in the specific anarchist organizations. The framing within the program of the strong state also broke with the confederal pact on the program of Libertarian Communism, approved at the CNT Congress of 1936. These two breaches represent a break with the principles of collective responsibility and strategic unity that we demand as especifists.[25]

We repeat: to overcome ourselves as a class, the next struggles we wage must necessarily develop towards the horizon of libertarian communism. In this direction, the strengthening of the anarchist strategy and the construction of referentiality before the broad masses of the working class are indispensable. However much strategic role Los Amigos de Durruti or the specific organizations may have had, it was the working masses of Barcelona, framed in the Defense Committees, in popular militias or in other political organizations, who took to the streets on May 3, 1937.

Finally, we want to establish that we see a qualitative difference between the sides of counterrevolution and reaction. We believe that the current of opinion that advocates that fascism and authoritarian communism are the same distorts history. Although the SIM agent and the Francoist policeman share means, they do so from a completely different relationship towards the revolutionary movement, just as the PSUC militant who participates in a check on Vilamajor Street and the Falangist who makes left-wing militants disappear act extrajudicially and legally at the same time, but from different institutionalities.

This distinction between counterrevolution and reaction also allows us to separate counterrevolution from revolution, and to argue that the Higher Committees of the specific anarchist organizations and the government positions of the CNT and FAI formed part of the counterrevolution by submitting to the esprit de corps of the CCMA, the Catalan Government and the central Government.

Revolution, counter-revolution and reaction are the three sides of the Spanish Revolution. With this article we hope to have positioned ourselves on the first of the sides, to claim ourselves as an alternative to avoid the second as the best way to eliminate the third. We also hope to have opened another trench in the fight to recover the history of the Revolution and to give it the balance it deserves.

Batzac-Libertarian Youth

https://www.regeneracionlibertaria.org/2025/05/03/els-fets-de-maig-i-les-joventuts-llibertaries/
_________________________________________
A - I N F O S N E W S S E R V I C E
By, For, and About Anarchists
Send news reports to A-infos-en mailing list
A-infos-en@ainfos.ca
Subscribe/Unsubscribe https://ainfos.ca/mailman/listinfo/a-infos-en
Archive: http://ainfos.ca/en
A-Infos Information Center