A - I n f o s

a multi-lingual news service by, for, and about anarchists **
News in all languages
Last 30 posts (Homepage) Last two weeks' posts Our archives of old posts

The last 100 posts, according to language
Greek_ 中文 Chinese_ Castellano_ Catalan_ Deutsch_ Nederlands_ English_ Francais_ Italiano_ Polski_ Português_ Russkyi_ Suomi_ Svenska_ Türkurkish_ The.Supplement

The First Few Lines of The Last 10 posts in:
Castellano_ Deutsch_ Nederlands_ English_ Français_ Italiano_ Polski_ Português_ Russkyi_ Suomi_ Svenska_ Türkçe_
First few lines of all posts of last 24 hours

Links to indexes of first few lines of all posts of past 30 days | of 2002 | of 2003 | of 2004 | of 2005 | of 2006 | of 2007 | of 2008 | of 2009 | of 2010 | of 2011 | of 2012 | of 2013 | of 2014 | of 2015 | of 2016 | of 2017 | of 2018 | of 2019 | of 2020 | of 2021 | of 2022 | of 2023 | of 2024 | of 2025

Syndication Of A-Infos - including RDF - How to Syndicate A-Infos
Subscribe to the a-infos newsgroups

(en) Spaine, Regeneracion: Interview on Especifist Anarchism for a Veteran Basque Magazine Ekintza Zuzena By EMBAT (ca, de, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]

Date Tue, 8 Jul 2025 07:14:36 +0300


Interview conducted by the veteran Basque magazine Ekintza Zuzena with Embat's comrade @BlackSpartak for its 2025 issue. By EMBAT, CATALONIA LIBERTY ORGANIZATION ---- From Regeneración, we are publishing the interview conducted by the magazine Ekintza Zuzena with a comrade for its 2025 issue (https://www.nodo50.org/ekintza/2025/numero-51-de-la-revista-ekintza-zuzena/), as it reviews the fundamental threads of our movement. ---- A preliminary question: How would you define and situate what has historically been called platformist anarchism? And especifist anarchism?

I'll start with some historical notes. First, the Platform emerged in France in the 1920s among anarchist militants who had come from Russia. Finally at peace, after a long revolutionary war they couldn't win, they were able to take stock of their journey as a movement during the Russian Revolution. The Dielo Truda group (one of those exile groups made up of prominent figures such as Nestor Makhno, Pyotr Arshinov, Ida Mett, Gregori Maksimov, and so on) concluded that the cause of the defeat by the Bolsheviks had been the lack of organization, program, and discipline of the Russian anarchist movement. They acted differently in each place. There were never any overall strategic plans or forums to discuss them. The Bolsheviks were able to defeat them city by city, region by region, without putting up a fight on any level except in Ukraine.

Dielo Truda proposed a new organizational model: the General Union of Anarchists. This model sought to unify the most active elements of anarchism into a single organization under the program outlined in The Platform. I should emphasize that it was not a complete program, but rather a partial one, as they recognized. The full program would have to be debated within this General Union once it was established.

This new platformism was highly critical of the "anarchist synthesis," an organizational model that blended anarchists from all currents of anarchism into a single organization. According to the platformists, the lack of homogeneity of approaches "would inevitably lead to disintegration when confronted with reality." That is, it would render the organization ineffective in the face of the major challenges facing any movement. They were extremely critical of anarchist individualism and nihilism ("chaotic anarchism," they called it). They were also unconvinced by anarcho-syndicalism, since in Russia it had been oriented almost exclusively toward industrial workers, neglecting the peasantry, which was the majority social component in Russia.

So, which anarchist militants were they addressing?

We base our hope on other militants: on those who remain faithful to anarchism, having experienced and suffered the tragedy of the anarchist movement, and painfully seek a solution.[1]

Therefore, they proposed an organization with tactical and strategic unity and discipline. Militants shouldn't join an organization to do whatever they wanted, but to fulfill its program. Dyelo Truda intended the Platform to be the revolutionary backbone and rallying point of Russian anarchism, given that at the time they were speaking to exiles, although it would soon be extended to all territories.

These approaches were the reason why the Platform fell out of favor with many activists in other countries at the time, and its development was thus slowed. However, its ideas were the driving force behind the Bulgarian Anarchist Communist Federation, which was prominent in the resistance to the 1934 coup d'état, the partisan resistance of World War II, and the postwar period against Soviet domination, until it was finally dissolved in 1948. These ideas also took root in France, among a sector of anarchism that maintained them from its beginnings until the postwar period. They were later promoted again by the Libertarian Communist Federation, with Georges Fontenis as its leading exponent. This FCL greatly influenced European anarchism in the 1950s and 1960s, with the French movement being one of the benchmark movements for anarcho-communism today.

For their part, specificism arose directly from the Uruguayan FAU in 1956. Paradoxically, they didn't discover La Plafaforma until many years later. Their starting point was Errico Malatesta, whose emphasis on specific organization and his refutation of individualism caught their attention. Another of their role models was Mikhail Bakunin, who was enormously important in our movement, promoting specific organizations like the International Alliance for Socialist Democracy. Their other role model was the previous specific organizations in Uruguay, organic constructions of the 1920s and 1930s. Thanks to those veteran activists, who had been active for years, it became clear that the task of political organization wasn't philosophizing and holding meetings, but rather the key was how to approach the tasks of the different fronts of work: union, student, neighborhood, and internal.

Their first task was to create the Organic Charter, in which they situated their organization in the Latin American context of the 1950s and outlined short-, medium-, and long-term plans. The younger militants were concerned about not automatically adopting other schemes and formulas that had been used in other historical situations. Their anarchism would have to be rooted in the country and its specific reality.

This specificism (of "specific" organization) was put into practice alone for years by the FAU until it was also taken up by Argentine groups in the 1970s. It must be said that they never considered the anarchist synthesis because no one took this possibility of organization into consideration.[2]The FAU had different stages and also strategic bets that brought it closer to the Latin American popular national movement of the 1970s, precisely at its stage of greatest visibility and size, with quite numerous social fronts and even its own armed organization, the OPR-33.

In the 1990s, Especifismo moved away from these perspectives and began to spread to other countries such as Brazil and Chile. From there, in the 2000s, it began to converge with the anarcho-communist movement typical of Europe and the Anglo-Saxon world, and today it has become part of the same international movement.

In Latin America, these organizations do not publicly call themselves "specificist," but rather "organized anarchism," which is also the name given to the International Coordinator of organizations of our current.

Although we like these models of anarchism, which we understand as the most capable of influencing reality through anarchism, we must clarify that we are neither a Russian, French, nor Latin American organization, so we will have to create a local anarchism, with the elements of local anarchism, to operate in the 21st century.

What is your assessment of the current situation of the Iberian libertarian movement, and what challenges and needs do you see in your field?

A movement is a set of actions, ideas, and efforts organized by a group of people who share common goals to influence society. Starting here, you'll agree that there is no single, homogeneous libertarian movement, given that there are no common goals across this amalgam of individuals, collectives, initiatives, scenes, spaces, organizations, or unions that claim to be anarchists.

Based on this premise, we could first identify a libertarian movement that seeks to achieve libertarian communism. This movement would be composed of anarcho-syndicalism and some anarchist collectives and organizations, as well as their related social or cultural projects that serve to reach a wider audience.

There are also other paradigms similar to libertarian communism but with different characteristics. I'm talking about communalism, democratic confederalism, the anti-capitalist branch of cooperativism, a part of autonomy (whether Marxist or indigenous) and similar proposals, or the radical environmental and anti-development movement. These people tend to be fellow travelers of anarchism and, to some extent, even come from its ranks or have passed through its collectives or organizations, but, for whatever reason, they have disassociated themselves from the libertarian movement as we understand it. Therefore, these initiatives cannot be considered part of our movement; rather, they build and participate in others.

Therefore, speaking of the libertarian movement itself, we have a considerable union space-not reaching the strength of yesteryear, of course-composed of the CGT and CNT and all their offshoots (Solidaridad Obrera, CNT-AIT, SAS Madrid, STS-C, and other smaller union groups). This movement has a considerable presence throughout Spain. It's true that it's a divided union space, often at odds with one another, which diminishes its potential and contributes to its discredit. It's also true that for some unions, libertarian communism is such a far-reaching aspiration that it's not even considered in their current strategy.

If anarcho-syndicalism is the spearhead, there are also organizations or organic initiatives behind it that were founded to contribute to the goal I mentioned earlier. These would be the anarchist synthesis organizations and collectives (this includes what was once called "neighborhood anarchism"), the anarcho-communist ones (currently called "specific," which seems to be the most popular word at the moment), and the insurrectionist ones. Their strength is limited to their own militants, and their influence extends to the broader spaces in which they operate. We're talking about some very specific neighborhoods in which they operate. Their presence influences the anti-capitalist scene in the places where they operate, and they are generally based in the urban areas and cities of their metropolitan areas (Madrid, Barcelona, Seville, Valencia, Zaragoza, Granada, A Coruña, etc.). And their real impact comes from their militant capacity and commitment. That's why they have influence.

Next, we had what we can understand as informal anarchism, autonomism, or, as Murray Bookchin would say, "anarchism as a way of life." We could almost consider it a subcultural scene rather than a political movement, but I don't deny the interest of many of the people who participate in it in transforming society at its roots. It inherited part of that subcultural component from the Iberian Peninsula punk scene, which so influenced the anarchism of the 1990s and 2000s.

This informal anarchism or autonomism organizes events that can occasionally become massive, such as protests, protest camps, or anarchist book fairs, but they generally remain spaces for socializing and networking rather than for social intervention. As a criticism, they run the risk of falling into inbreeding by living quite apart from the social mainstream. In this sector, we can find both people whose goal is libertarian communism and those who aren't interested and seek to live as freely as possible in today's society.

However, from the informal organization, various networks and coordinators of squatted social centers, libertarian athenaeums, media outlets, and counter-information organizations were launched, and other social movements such as anti-militarism, environmentalism, and the fight against the globalization of capital were also involved.

In Spain during the 1990s and 2000s, a dualism prevailed: anarcho-syndicalism, understood as a political organization, and informal anarchism, generally anti-organization. This was almost hegemonic, and there was little room for organizational attempts that lasted rather short (the second Autonomous Struggle, Libertarian Alternative, Galician Anarchist Federation, local and regional libertarian assemblies, networks of libertarian athenaeums and CSOs, etc.). During those years, no peninsular libertarian space was ever articulated, beyond the FIJL, linked to insurrectionism, or the FAI, which by 2000 already seemed focused exclusively on libertarian culture.

However, the movement gained momentum later on. The youth movement built organizations: FIJA and the first FEL, as well as some local libertarian youth organizations. The anarcho-independence movement was strengthened with Negres Tempestes in Catalonia, which generated its own momentum. This was a time of heightened anti-development struggles, attracting hundreds of people. Anarchist book fairs proliferated. Anarchist websites like Alasbarricadas and Klinamen, and more diverse ones like Indymedia, LaHaine, and Kaosenlared, received thousands of visitors; there were still various publications in the form of fanzines, magazines, and newspapers...

From 2010-12, anarchism emerged, developing in neighborhood or municipal and regional assemblies. This coincided with the period following the 15M movement. In some cases, such as in Catalonia, federations were formed between these groups. But all this lasted only a short time, lasting two, three, or five years, with the exception of a few groups that achieved generational change, such as Heura Negra in Vallcarca (Barcelona). Those local libertarian assemblies were the political school for many activists of our time, because they were truly many groups.

The lack of consolidation of these groups paralleled the crisis of insurrectionism following the repressive measures it suffered between 2011 and 2016. But it wasn't just a repressive issue, it was also a political one. Whatever happened, all of this paralyzed the political project of the Coordinated Anarchist Groups. This crisis demobilized part of its membership or caused it to drift toward other, more practical projects, and also prevented it from renewing itself generationally.

The most political anarchism, so to speak, was also articulated during that time. For example, Embat in Catalonia, Apoyo Mutuo in Madrid, Aragon, and Seville, Aunar in Aragon, and the Libertarian Student Federation. We're not going to lie to anyone: we're talking about a very small scene that didn't even manage to become a proper movement, despite our intentions.

Regarding Embat, our analysis of the post-15M era was that many essentially libertarian ideas and practices had been seen, but they were barely articulated by the libertarian movement. Proposals were brought to the squares individually and embraced by a politically diverse audience. We were aware-we saw them-that in those same squares there were Marxist or social democratic political organizations that aimed to do their part. So we understood the need for our own organization to channel that spontaneous libertarian spirit toward a revolutionary perspective. That's why Embat was born.

During this time, we were able to garner some sympathy, but we failed to attract those libertarian people embedded in the social and popular movements. Most of them preferred to continue without a specific organization. This proved fatal when Podemos emerged in 2014. Many people who should have been previously organized as anarchists ended up joining the circles and candidacies of Podemos, Ganemos, Sí Se Puede, Más Madrid, or the CUP in Catalonia. Without a strategic line of their own, they adopted social democratic lines until they burned out and went home, or until they completely converted to those positions.

Meanwhile, people from libertarian assemblies, insurrectionist movements, and informal anarchism gradually entered anarcho-syndicalism. This time not to turn it into a political organization as in the 1990s, but rather for labor-related issues or to help develop some social and cultural area within the unions. They also entered the housing struggle, this time without the intention of "radicalizing the struggle," but rather to become just one more. Something similar must have happened in the 1980s with people who emerged from the libertarian athenaeums.

During those years, 2015-2020, we should highlight the influence of the Federation of Anarchists of Gran Canaria in the libertarian field. Their approach combined elements of social and insurrectionary anarchism under an identitarian anarchist discourse that championed "neighborhood anarchism." They were also the driving force behind the first Tenants' Union in the entire state and, at the time, advocated for a rent strike. They managed to bring anarchism to the most disadvantaged neighborhoods of Gran Canaria, reaching a range of people who hadn't been reached in decades. The FAGC attempted to replicate their neighborhood anarchism elsewhere in the state, giving dozens of talks and writing numerous texts. However, they failed, and no one on the Iberian Peninsula copied their model, which was a shame, since we have always appreciated this anarchism with such strong social roots.

Following the 2020 pandemic, we witnessed the rise of the GKS/Socialist Movement and its significant impact among the youth of the revolutionary left. Anarchism was literally out of the picture at that time, as we have seen. The ambiguous discourse-half Leninist, half autonomous-libertarian-that this socialist movement had in its early days attracted groups of young militants to those areas. This included people who had previously been active in social or insurrectionist anarchism, which put a good part of our movement on guard.

Consequently, the need to offer an anarchist organizational alternative became clear. Thus, Alternativa Libertaria and Liza were born in Madrid in 2023 (the former later joined the latter), now Hedra in Alicante, Impulso in Granada, the Seminario de Estudios Libertarios Galegos (Galician Libertarian Studies Seminar), and, within synthetic anarchism, the Horizontal network at the state level (although this did not have much traction) and some new groups. There was even the incorporation of Acción Libertaria of Zaragoza into the FAI, a group well established in its neighborhood. Currently, some anarchist assemblies are being re-established in various cities, such as Seville, with that plural or synthetic character that we previously saw in other similar ones. All of this occurs in a context of true growth of anarcho-syndicalism, which has also opened new study centers and cultural entities.

In short, it has been necessary to offer strong organizations in response to the need of working-class youth to organize. Right now, our entire political space is under construction. Even so, many territories remain with virtually no libertarian organization beyond anarcho-syndicalism, a few distri, CSO, or music bands.

We are concerned that no assessment has been made of the 2010-2020 decade and that groups are emerging that uncritically copy the same models that entered into crisis in those years. Because there are not many spaces for interaction between currents, no collective learning is being transmitted-a starting point that comrades starting out now can draw upon. This could be the role of Ekintza Zuzena.

The First Meeting of Specific Anarchism was held in Catalonia in the summer of 2024. What need did this initiative address, and what is your assessment of it?

The meeting is a response to previous contacts between the various organizations and groups that exist in Spain and claim to be part of the specificist movement. We intended to draw the attention of this unorganized, but still pro-organizational, libertarian milieu within the state. That is, those people who now feel the need to have someone behind them to work politically as anarchists without fearing other currents of the socialist left.

At that time, about 80 people gathered at the Calafou factory (Vallbona d'Anoia), exceeding our expectations. Many people came who didn't belong to the organizing organizations (Batzac Embat, FEL, Liza, and Regeneración Libertaria), and we had some very fruitful discussions with like-minded people from Granada, Galicia, and elsewhere.

During the meeting, a greeting was recorded for the sister organization in the United States, Black Rose, on the occasion of its Convention (something like the annual congress they have there).

A strong point was the quality of the debate, with very solid arguments. It was also clear that everyone was pulling in the same direction: the need for political organization and social integration-which is to be expected at a meeting of this tendency, but which is not common in contemporary anarchism, and that's why it pleasantly surprised us.

And as a weak point, we note the limited communicative capacity our movement still possesses, typically allergic to audiovisual media, with no desire for prominence or desire to make a spectacle of its own everyday life. Admittedly, this demonstrates a modicum of common sense, but I think it's also positive to make a little noise, to be known and seen.

What groups or initiatives are currently driving this movement, and what are their goals?

The initiatives that are currently driving this trend in the state are the following in order of creation:

Libertarian Student Federation. Emerging in 2008 from several student assemblies in Madrid, Catalonia, and Aragon, it was rebuilt in 2014 after a, let's say, generational hiatus, and has lasted until this year. Its tendency was toward "social and organized anarchism" until recently, when it began to define itself as specificist. As student groups come and go quite quickly, it hasn't managed to consolidate in recent years and now only existed in Catalonia. At the end of last year, it joined Batzac, forming its student front.
Libertarian Regeneration . A website founded in 2012 as a space for current analysis, theoretical articles, social studies, and libertarian culture within social and organized anarchism. Last year, given that its current members adhere to the Especifista movement, they decided to put the platform at the service of a shared project. Today, it is the official website of the Especifista movement, or organized anarchism, in Spain. It serves as a link between the organizations that promote it and as a point of debate and exchange of ideas.
Embat, Libertarian Organisation of Catalonia . Born in 2013 as Procés Embat[3](like the previous ones, under the paradigm of "social and organised anarchism") and since 2015 under its current name. It is an organisation that has gone through different stages: one of consolidation, acting as a network of militants (2013-15), another of social insertion as an organisation (2015-19), another very active during the Procés Independenceista (2017-18), the 2020 break in which we took advantage to create our Political Line[4], and the current era. At the moment we are active in the fields of housing, education, feminism, eco-social and labour.
Batzac, Joventuts Llibertàries . Founded in 2017, it organizes young people who, in most cases, have not previously participated in activism. Until now, it had not declared itself a specificist movement, but rather a social anarchist movement. This stems from its interest in achieving specific social integration, such as those developed in housing, in the student sphere, and in the workplace. It has recently incorporated the FEL movement in Catalonia.
Liza, Madrid's Organizing Platform . Founded in 2023, it brought together a group of people in need of organization who shared a strategic and tactical vision somewhere between platformism and specificism. Its emergence was combined with strong online communication and intense activity, which enlivened the Iberian scene, resulting in the current semblance of coordination. Its presence is particularly prominent in housing and neighborhoods. Its interest in debating with the rest of the anarchist movement, confronting autonomist and anti-organization tendencies, is also worth highlighting. Liza absorbed an organizing project called Alternativa Libertaria, which emerged from FEL Madrid.
Impulso - Granada defines itself as a space for reflection on organized anarchism . Created at the end of 2024, for now, it's precisely what defines it: a space for debate and training around the ideas of organized anarchism in Granada. Its intention is to move forward gradually, without skipping a step, until it culminates in a political organization.
Hedra, a Especifista Organization from Alicante . It's a recent arrival, having been established in January 2025. It's the first to be created under the Especifista umbrella, as its theoretical foundations draw directly from the fundamental texts of this movement. Its presence is in housing and in the neighborhood through a center.
I'd also like to mention Teima Publishing . They're currently working on a book by Felipe Correa, called Bandera Negra . The publishing house will publish texts from our movement in Spanish. However, there are some publishing houses that publish books in our vein, such as Descontrol in Barcelona or Ardora y Bastiana in Galicia.

In addition to these organizations, which are public, there are other initiatives in other parts of the state that have not yet come to light, and which I won't mention so as not to jinx them. Some of them come from anarchist synthesis collectives or assemblies that are drifting toward our style of anarchism. By the way, none of them come from the Basque Country, so let's see if anyone is interested!

Regarding the stated objectives, the priority is to create a broader anarchist movement with a greater impact on society, bringing anarchism back to the forefront of social struggle.

It's worth mentioning that we're also coordinating with other European organizations of our current movement and with those from around the world. The current international coordination includes more than twenty organizations, and several more are in the process of joining. The best-known are the Union Communiste Libertaire (French-speaking European countries), Die Plattform (Germany), Anarchist Communist Group (UK), Black Rose Federation (USA), the Uruguayan Anarchist Federation, the Anarchist Federation of Rosario (Argentina), the Anarchist Coordinator of Brazil, and Tekoshina Anarsist (Rojava). We're also in contact with other new initiatives currently being formed. In some ways, it seems to be a parallel process to that in Spain, which indicates that the anarchist movement is seeking to become better organized.

The concept of popular power has been most widely disseminated in Latin America, where it has generated significant debate. What is your interpretation or definition of popular power? How would you differentiate it from left-wing populism?

It was in the 1970s that the FAU opted to borrow this concept from the Chilean MIR (Revolutionary Movement of the Revolution), the Tupamaros, and other movements of the time that combined various forms of Marxism (primarily Leninism and Guevarism), Liberation Theology, national liberation, and Latin Americanism (which maintains that Latin America is a single country). It should be added that anarchism also influenced this amalgamation, something that is often overlooked. In the 1960s, people's power replaced Leninism's concept of "dual power."

Latin American anarchists of the time understood this as logical, since this dual power (those soviets that coexist with the bourgeois state in an advanced phase of the class struggle, once the revolutionary stage has been reached) in turn drew on Bakunin's ideas.

In the FAU of the 1950s and 1960s, there was a lively debate about the historical subjects who should carry out the revolution. Given the configuration of Uruguayan society at the time, it was necessary to create a subject that would unite all the oppressed sectors of society. The idea of "the people" was used. But the people were understood as "those from below." They had nothing to do with the bourgeoisie. It was somewhat like when the historical CNT-FAI spoke of "the working people" in its newspapers and manifestos. They didn't refer solely to the proletariat, since at that time, to ordinary people, it sounded like talk of factories and little else.

In this relationship between ideology and the production of historical subjects-a relationship that, if it did not exist, would mean neither ideology nor subject-the moments of ideological validity are formed. Historical subjects/agents expand and lead to the hegemony of social bodies, based on the validity of ideologies.[5]

As the class struggle unfolded in Latin America, alliances came into play between the organized labor movement, the student movement, the first feminist associations, the peasantry, and grassroots collectives centered on identity, such as Afro-Colombian, mestizo, and indigenous peoples. Furthermore, in the 1970s, the social war received support from the self-employed and small business owners expelled from industrial manufacturing. The class struggle often moved to neighborhoods or communities far from the city, and elements of counterpower were generated from below in the midst of the struggle. This was popular power: the people in motion, diffuse, anonymous, contradictory, creative, festive, and combative. Land seizures, industrial cordons, armed groups, occupation of universities-this was popular power in the eyes of ordinary people. In no way should it be confused with interclassism, with its conscious "from below" nature.

In the 2000s, criticism began. Especifist or organized anarchist organizations used popular power in their political language. But Marxist organizations did too. In Cuba and Venezuela, all ministries carried the tagline "popular power." So the term was also linked to the socialist state. Those critical of the concept of popular power also pointed out that there had also been a shift away from anarchism within the Especifist ranks toward Marxism or national populism. Some anarchists even went further, denying our entire movement's adherence to anarchism, viewing it as a crypto-Marxism as a whole. This is the origin of the conflict.

With Embat, it was even comical to see that, during the first few years, certain people would always come to all our talks and say that popular power couldn't be anarchist in any way. Ironically, we had the opinion that, in reality, everyone understood us perfectly, except for the "most anarchist." No one seemed to have the slightest problem with the Black Power of the Black Panthers in the United States, a concept roughly equivalent to popular power.

In any case, the passing of the years has greatly mitigated those debates. If some organizations or individuals have shifted toward other ideological positions, the vast majority have not, contributing to the libertarian movement as a whole, not just to our current in particular. Today, in Spain, this concept has been largely accepted, even by people who come from other currents, such as anarcho-syndicalism, or by libertarians who are active in neighborhoods or housing without ever having been on our wavelength.

Regarding left-wing populism, we must say that it engages in interclassism, combining working-class demands with more bourgeois middle-class ones. This would be the main difference. Especifismo defends a "strong people" constructed as a front for the classes oppressed by capitalism and the state. Although both currents speak of popular power, there are substantial differences. Let's see what Especifismo thinks:

We proclaim the most complete socialization of all spheres of social activity. The socialization of the means of production exercised by the organs of real representation of society and not by the State; the socialization of education, the administration of justice, defense organizations, the sources of knowledge and information, and most especially the socialization of political power. In this last aspect, we advocate the abolition of the State and governmental forms of power as the only guarantee for the elimination of all forms of domination.

[...]

We are fully convinced that this is indeed possible through direct democracy, exercised by grassroots organizations organized in a self-managed manner and linked within a federalist framework, where these same grassroots organizations express themselves in new institutional forms. Today we know more firmly than ever that the model of society we propose is not only possible but is practically, and in accordance with the historical and revolutionary experience of different peoples of the world, the only valid path for truly building socialism.[6]

It would be bold to say that this is not anarchism.

To what extent can the desire not to remain confined to the ghetto and to participate (with a non-dogmatic discourse) in current social struggles or processes lead to political contradictions with anarchist or basic principles of the society for which you fight? Do you recall any occasions when you experienced this dilemma?

Social processes are inherently complex. There are many forces at play and many vested interests. The challenge is to build transformative collective interests in a democratic, transparent, and fraternal environment.

For Embat, the real test was 2017. We had to position ourselves in a tremendously complex scenario. The Spanish state was in crisis, and Catalan society demanded a response. This was the referendum. In just a few months, we experienced a large-scale process of collective empowerment. In just a few weeks, I'd say. The movement was already underway, but the events encouraged many more people to join the process. Counter-power structures were created, the committees for the defense of the Republic. They operated as assemblies, calling for actions and demonstrations. But they also had the opportunity to be spaces of territorial counter-power. Another initiative worth considering was the Constituent Process, which proposed a constituent assembly for an independent Catalonia that would accommodate the most advanced social aspects. Social and union movements also joined the process in their own way. They joined and were responsible for the famous general strike of October 3, one of the most widely followed in Catalan history. The slogan of blocking transportation-trains, highways, and, in 2019, the airport-naturally emerged. Something that had only been theorized about in some anti-capitalist debate years before and was dismissed due to a lack of momentum was put into practice.

Although we were perfectly aware that the leadership of this entire process was in the hands of the long-standing Catalanist political class, we also saw what was happening below. Our response was that we had to be there. We always felt that much more could have been done if all the social and union movements had acted unitedly and as a bloc. But this would have required a much more organized anarchism, which is what we were trying to build.

Another complex and conflictive moment in which we had to take a stand was during the pandemic. Embat's position denounced the police state and the state's militarization of public spaces, while workers in "essential services" were forced to go to work without sufficient protective measures. We also highlighted the devastating effects of the privatization of healthcare and the management of nursing homes and clinics by private entities. At the same time, we welcomed the self-organized mutual support groups that emerged in many places, as well as grassroots initiatives in which we participated, such as the Social Shock Plan or the attempted rent strike that was proposed during those months. I would add that we took advantage of the lockdown internally to develop our political line, which required much debate. And during that time, the International Coordination Committee, in which we participated, was also strengthened.

The contradictions were clear within our libertarian movement. Some focused on denouncing the police state and the infantilization of people, while others preferred to focus on denouncing privatization and self-organization. We didn't see a unified approach, and each person waged a bit of their own war. Perhaps what united us most were those proposals for a shock plan and similar ones.

[1]This fragment can be found in the Introduction of The Platform https://www.nestormakhno.info/spanish/platform/introduccion.htm

[2]For more information see The Strategy of Specifism . Interview by Felipe Correa to Juan Carlos Mechoso: http://federacionanarquistauruguaya.uy/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/La-Estrategia-del-Especifismo.pdf

[3]Embat in Catalan refers to the crash of a wave against a rock. It sounded powerful and poetic to us, and it seemed a better name than the typical acronyms of other libertarian organizations of our time.

[4]This was when specificity was adopted as one of the guiding principles. The Political Line can be consulted at: https://embat.info/programa-i-linia-politica/

[5]Popular Power from a libertarian perspective. https://federacionanarquistauruguaya.uy/poder-popular-desde-lo-libertario-fau/

[6]idem

https://www.regeneracionlibertaria.org/2025/06/03/entrevista-sobre-el-anarquismo-especifista-para-ekintza-zuzena/
_________________________________________
A - I N F O S N E W S S E R V I C E
By, For, and About Anarchists
Send news reports to A-infos-en mailing list
A-infos-en@ainfos.ca
Subscribe/Unsubscribe https://ainfos.ca/mailman/listinfo/a-infos-en
Archive: http://ainfos.ca/en
A-Infos Information Center