A - I n f o s

a multi-lingual news service by, for, and about anarchists **
News in all languages
Last 30 posts (Homepage) Last two weeks' posts Our archives of old posts

The last 100 posts, according to language
Greek_ 中文 Chinese_ Castellano_ Catalan_ Deutsch_ Nederlands_ English_ Francais_ Italiano_ Polski_ Português_ Russkyi_ Suomi_ Svenska_ Türkurkish_ The.Supplement

The First Few Lines of The Last 10 posts in:
Castellano_ Deutsch_ Nederlands_ English_ Français_ Italiano_ Polski_ Português_ Russkyi_ Suomi_ Svenska_ Türkçe_
First few lines of all posts of last 24 hours

Links to indexes of first few lines of all posts of past 30 days | of 2002 | of 2003 | of 2004 | of 2005 | of 2006 | of 2007 | of 2008 | of 2009 | of 2010 | of 2011 | of 2012 | of 2013 | of 2014 | of 2015 | of 2016 | of 2017 | of 2018 | of 2019 | of 2020 | of 2021 | of 2022 | of 2023 | of 2024

Syndication Of A-Infos - including RDF - How to Syndicate A-Infos
Subscribe to the a-infos newsgroups

(en) Russia, Avtonom: Debt of integration as (auto)migrantophobia (ca, de, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]

Date Fri, 5 Jul 2024 09:28:59 +0300


We are publishing an article by the Belarusian group Pramen. ---- Recently, action artist Vladislav Bokhan released an article on his channel entitled "Simulacrum of the Idea of Equality." Since Vladislav positions himself as an anarchist, we consider it necessary to respond to some theses from his text, some of which are at odds with our understanding of anarchism. Having noted the rude and chauvinistic tone of the narrative in this article, let us focus first of all on the arguments presented there.
The first of them is that in Western countries political correctness has replaced the concept of equality, where certain categories of citizens received a special protected status, becoming, as it were, "first among equals." As an example, Vladislav cites the situation with attacks by migrants on religious grounds, which are allegedly ignored by the left-liberal public.

To begin with, it is worth noting the part of the thesis with which we rather agree: pluralism and dialogue are possible where their value is recognized by all parties. If a Nazi, religious fanatic or other reactionary force declares an attack on human lives, freedoms, dignity, then any means are acceptable as a defense against them. Although the value of human life is still taken into account, and dialogue is preferable to violence, the situation of protection allows one to take extreme measures. When an interlocutor denies your right to speak, he ceases to be an interlocutor, and the situation ceases to be a dialogue. Attempts to return the conflict to the level of conversation are commendable, but should not reach the point of absurdity, when any action is paralyzed if conversation is impossible. That's why on the street you can fight off a hooligan with your fists, that's why negotiations with Lukashenko are impossible, that's why anarchists are fighting on the side of Ukraine.

Let us emphasize this principle once again. Freedom of speech and pluralism extend only to those who accept and practice them. This is not about comparing groups based on the number of their members. If tomorrow fascists or cannibal fanatics remain in the minority, this will not mean that they should be given equal rights to express and implement their plans simply because their voices are weaker. The essence of the fascists' statements are prohibitions for others or threats to other people's lives, and therefore they themselves deny equal dialogue. If you allow others to speak, follow the principles of pluralism and respect the freedom of others, and you are silenced, then this is already a reason to speak out in defense of democracy (though not a sufficient reason to use violence!) In the face of an attack on freedom of speech, it is logical to support the voices that are trying to break through censorship, but these should not be the voices of a new dictatorship.

The author's mention of some concern of the European establishment about migrants completely ignores reality and only relays the same racist narrative that is spread by the right-wingers who have filled parliaments throughout Europe. Any non-white migrant at least knows. what is "Fortress Europe" with all its hatred, violence and discrimination. Any state legitimizes its violence, justifying it in all possible, even absurd, ways. It is this violence that initiates and is always much more widespread.

The inability to obtain visas and apply for asylum, being pushed out of the border, being kept in closed prisons, bureaucratic hell and a lot of restrictions on the possibility of legalization - isn't this what Vlad calls the very same concern and "dancing with tambourines around the rights of certain groups of the population"?

The next thesis is the religious component of the problem indicated by Vladislav. Let us leave detailed criticism of religion as such for a separate text, noting that there is no consensus among anarchists on this matter. One of the common opinions is the defense of religious freedom and criticism of religious institutions. Supporters of this approach note the close interaction between the church and the state, the support of clergy for the practice of domestic violence, all sorts of restrictions for adherents, and the condoning of interreligious strife. In this light, anarchist criticism of religious practices appears convincing, but it is important to separate it from criticism of migrants.

And here we move on to the most controversial theses - migrant phobia and cultural integration. Let's look at a few myths on which migrant phobia is based.

The first myth is that all migrants from the Middle East = radical Muslims. Despite the overwhelming majority of Muslims, these countries are also home to Yazidis, Christians, Zoroastrians and representatives of other religious movements, as well as atheists. Moreover, these groups decide to migrate much more often than their Islamic relatives due to persecution in their countries. In Europe there are also regions from the Balkans to the Baltic, where Muslims have lived for several centuries, as well as countries to which the migration of Muslims began in the middle of the 20th century. Generalizing entire groups of people based on external characteristics, blaming them for ideas that some of them may profess, should be shameful for a person who calls himself an anti-fascist. Judgments about what would happen to LGBTQ+ activists in Palestine sound at least strange, considering that there are such people there, too. The identification of supporters of a free Palestine with members of Hamas looks as strange as the identification of Vlad Bokhan with the Belarusian riot police. Belonging to an ethnic group does not determine one's political position.

It is also obvious that migration is a grassroots process, which for the most part is not regulated by religious organizations. The main motive for moving is the search for security and income, and not cultural expansion. The vast majority of migrants do not leave for the purpose of causing religious conflicts, and the popularity of radical Islamism among them should be sought in marginal living conditions. Often attacks are carried out by young people who were already born in Europe, and did not move with the intention of committing an attack. The impossibility of cultural integration and poverty are often not the migrant's choice, but the reality of the capitalist world. Let us not forget the counter-violence from the police and the right. To understand which side the state takes in this conflict, just look at how the Polish media spread the news about the death of a border guard at the hands of a migrant while simultaneously covering up dozens of confirmed deaths of refugees at the border.

The second myth is that Western society = a stronghold of democracy. In Western countries there is a Renaissance of right-wing populism and separatism. The far right is gaining more and more seats in parliaments, and in some countries they are already heading governments. Christian traditionalists have enormous influence on society and politics in many countries. Totalitarian sects of non-Islamic origins number in the hundreds, and Christian-inspired right-wing organizations operate in many countries (and are often government sponsored). Traditionalism also has European origins, but what is characteristic is that the emphasis in the media is on Islamic migrants.

A historian by training, Vladislav, cannot help but know these facts, but he becomes hostage to the logic that he himself criticizes at the beginning of his article: instead of defending democracy and criticizing all right-wing tendencies, he takes the side of the right-wing European migrant-phobes "first among equals" on " your land." In his "selective tolerance" he does not notice the imperialist reasons for migration and the growing popularity of Islam. In addition, the author even blames the growth of right-wing populism on the migrants themselves, who allegedly do not want to integrate.

The thesis about "barbarians bringing the Middle Ages to civilized Europe" is an example of classic colonial racism, in which white Europe is presented as an elitist force dictating the rules and norms of cultural, social and political development - a kind of messiah, bringing light to the dark corners of the planet, and enlightening barbarians, imposing their dominance and control on them. Rome can come to the Barbarians, but the Barbarians can only come to Rome in slave shackles.

Vladislav ends the text with a statement about the necessity of cultural integration. Firstly, Vlad cites his personal experience, which in a number of ways is very different from the experience of non-white migrants. The conditions for integration into Polish society for a Belarusian and a Palestinian will be very different, starting with the language barrier and ending with the similarity or difference in everyday habits. Secondly, we believe that a person has the right to move and change his place of residence, regardless of not only state borders, but also cultural differences. The desire to communicate with people in their language is useful and laudable, but should not become a condition for coexistence. Without dictating to the majority how to live, a person has the right to achieve comfortable conditions for himself. Again, those that will not interfere with the lives of everyone around.

Freedom of cultural choice is one of the basic values of anarchists. We believe that it is possible to have a society of cultural pluralism without significant restrictions on speakers of unpopular languages or other distinctive cultural elements. Therefore, we support those who are fighting against Russian imperialism and reserve the right to write articles in Russian. The degree and speed of adaptation to surrounding cultural conditions should remain a personal choice of the individual. This may create objective difficulties for him in communication, but should not limit his rights as an "alien element."

The land where a person found a home becomes his land, regardless of where his ancestors lived. And at home, every person should have the right to vote. The "we are guests here" approach is openly conservative and leaves no chance for building equal grassroots communities, since we no longer perceive ourselves as subjects of political and social life. If we consider ourselves proponents of pluralism, we must stop sorting people based on origin or language of communication.

No god, no master, no nations, no borders.

P.S. Vladislav Bokhan published a response to criticism of the Pramen group on his channel.

https://avtonom.org/news/dolg-integracii-kak-avtomigrantofobiya
_________________________________________
A - I N F O S N E W S S E R V I C E
By, For, and About Anarchists
Send news reports to A-infos-en mailing list
A-infos-en@ainfos.ca
Subscribe/Unsubscribe https://ainfos.ca/mailman/listinfo/a-infos-en
Archive: http://ainfos.ca/en
A-Infos Information Center