A - I n f o s

a multi-lingual news service by, for, and about anarchists **
News in all languages
Last 30 posts (Homepage) Last two weeks' posts Our archives of old posts

The last 100 posts, according to language
Greek_ 中文 Chinese_ Castellano_ Catalan_ Deutsch_ Nederlands_ English_ Francais_ Italiano_ Polski_ Português_ Russkyi_ Suomi_ Svenska_ Türkurkish_ The.Supplement

The First Few Lines of The Last 10 posts in:
Castellano_ Deutsch_ Nederlands_ English_ Français_ Italiano_ Polski_ Português_ Russkyi_ Suomi_ Svenska_ Türkçe_
First few lines of all posts of last 24 hours

Links to indexes of first few lines of all posts of past 30 days | of 2002 | of 2003 | of 2004 | of 2005 | of 2006 | of 2007 | of 2008 | of 2009 | of 2010 | of 2011 | of 2012 | of 2013 | of 2014 | of 2015 | of 2016 | of 2017 | of 2018 | of 2019 | of 2020 | of 2021 | of 2022 | of 2023 | of 2024

Syndication Of A-Infos - including RDF - How to Syndicate A-Infos
Subscribe to the a-infos newsgroups

(en) Russia, Avtonom: Individual, universal and class: "Trends of order and chaos", episode 160 (ca, de, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]

Date Sun, 23 Jun 2024 07:30:15 +0300


Is a protracted war a chance for revolution? ---- As everyone is tired of repeating, "no change on the Western Front." Another episode of the apparatus struggle has recently ended in the Russian army. The group of conditional Sechin, Chemezov and Zolotov finally achieved the removal of Shoigu from the post of Minister of Defense. They appointed the vague "conservative economist" Belousov instead. Now the Russian army is controlled either by the FSB, or by someone else.
In any case, this fight of bulldogs under the carpet has not changed much yet. The front is not moving, with the exception of Russia's rather ostentatious "offensive" of 10 kilometers in the Kharkov region. The war turns into a routine.

But against the background of this routine, some interesting processes also occur. Somehow, very calmly and without noise, this and last week the rhetoric of Western politicians changed quite radically on two points. Firstly, almost all of Europe and the United States have given Ukraine permission to use Western weapons to attack Russia within the 2014 borders. It seems like the highmars already arrived in Belgorod on Saturday. Secondly, they talk about the participation of instructors and even NATO soldiers in the war right on the territory of Ukraine as an already decided and completely ordinary fact.

It is not yet very clear whether this still means a purposeful escalation and bringing us closer to the Third World War or, on the contrary, it means that Western governments are convinced that all Putin's "red lines" are bullshit, and they don't have to bother observing them, but just help Ukraine.

But it seems that in any case, this is additional confirmation that the war in Ukraine will, unfortunately, last for a long time. Well, most of the previous unsuccessful aggressive imperialist wars in the history of Russia ended in one way or another with the fall of the regime within the country (remember the First World War and Afghanistan). It seems that now it is important to find ways of political propaganda within the Russian troops in order to increase the scale of both simple desertion and outright rebellion. People usually don't like to fight for a long time on foreign soil. Will veterans of the so-called "SVO" be one of the drivers of Russia's transformation in the direction opposite to dictatorship? It seems crazy for now, but we'll see.

Superman Ruslan Sidiki
Meanwhile, even now there are still people inside Russia who directly and radically oppose Putin's military machine. Now there is a collection to pay for a lawyer for the anarchist Ruslan Sidiki. Let us remind you that he is accused of attacking the Dyaghilevo military airfield with quadcopters and blowing up railway tracks in the Ryazan region. These routes were used to transport military equipment and supply fuel to the Russian army in Ukraine. The FSB eventually captured Ruslan, but in general he is just a superhero, and one day they will definitely make an exciting movie about him. There are quadcopters, and self-exploding video cameras around the rails to control that it is freight trains that are being blown up, and not passenger ones, and much more. Help Ruslan!

But nevertheless, what will happen after the war, what will replace the Putin regime?

Triple Anarchy
It is important to think now about what is a real alternative. And what is the place of anarchism in this alternative. We are not the only ones playing on this field. For example, there is such a structure "Civil Council" - this is a kind of association of Russian citizens who fight on the side of Ukraine in the Siberian Battalion, the RDK and the Freedom of Russia Legion. In general, it's like "foreign legions" within the Armed Forces of Ukraine. Plus, of course, those who do not fight themselves, but support.

The "Civil Council" is, as it were, an attempt to give some kind of unified political face to the rather heterogeneous units consisting of all these battalions and corps. We know that these units are really heterogeneous - from outright Nazis with swastikas and Celtic crosses in the RDK to completely normal people in the Siberian battalion, for example. And recently, the "Civil Council" released a statement saying that they are "moving from recruiting for the Siberian Battalion of the Armed Forces of Ukraine to creating a political and military alternative to Putinism on the territory of the Russian Federation." And there, among other things, some desirable properties of this "alternative to Putinism" are listed.

Just in case, I am not going to criticize the "Civil Council" as a whole now (this is a separate topic). Everyone has the right to have any political views, and those who fight against the occupiers with arms in their hands are generally given enormous respect. But still, in this "alternative" from the "Civil Council" there is one point with which it is difficult for an anarchist to agree. It seems to be about "self-government of society", but on the other hand it is constantly repeated that "only professionals can create a successful future, it is professionals who should become the new political class." Moreover, these "professionals" clearly have a strong military bias.

That is, in essence, meritocracy is proposed - the power of "experts", those who, as it were, are more professional and understand better than others how to steer certain aspects of society.

Naturally, the question immediately arises of who defines "professionalism" and what kind of caste system this is. And it must be said right away that we, anarchists, offer another alternative, a truly democratic one. Democratic - in the sense that decision-making is distributed evenly throughout the population, and is not concentrated in a narrow stratum of "professionals". There are many ways to turn everyone's individual preferences into group decisions, but the idea remains the same: all people have the right to participate in decision making, we exclude no one.

This is the essence of self-government, this is the essence of the society to which we strive. But we should not be helpless kittens on this path, like this cat in the drawing of anarcho-partisan Sergei Romanov from the cover of today's episode of Trends. You need to think, and also rely on what the anarchists of the past discussed, so as not to reinvent the wheel.

For example, if you are interested in the topic of an anarchist alternative (both to Putin's Russia and to capitalism), then I highly recommend reading the text that was almost a century old. This is the so-called "Response of several Russian anarchists to the Platform." It was written, as you might guess, by a group of Russian anarchists in exile in 1927. It definitely included Vsevolod Volin, and some others. In this text they criticize the project of the "Organizational Platform", which was then put forward by other anarchists in exile, including Nestor Makhno. It will be too long to list all the arguments, read for yourself, I will focus on the interesting thoughts of the authors.

This is what they say:

"Anarchism is a synthesis of class, universal and individual elements. The class element in anarchism is closely connected with the question of the method of liberation struggle, the universal element is connected with the foundations of general principles and the moral foundation of the libertarian concept, the ideological sublimity of the libertarian struggle and with the problem of the material and organizational basis a new emerging society, and the individualistic element is associated with the philosophical basis and the most developed ultimate aspirations of libertarian thought."

Here, in fact, we see a very clear concept of a three-level structure of libertarian political activity and goal setting. Here there is 1) the method of achieving the goal, 2) the goal itself, and 3) the philosophical basis for this goal.

It is essential that all three layers or levels are equally important. Individualism is the philosophical basis and meaning of the whole idea, because ultimately we proceed from the highest value of each person and his or her freedom. All for the sake of this one way or another. Therefore, any punk counterculturalist is also an anarchist, even if he does not seem to engage in any political activity. Next comes "universal." It's about what kind of society we think will best provide this most individual human freedom. This is libertarian communism, a stateless and classless society of self-government and self-organization. This is what we want, what we strive for. And finally, the method of transition from a modern capitalist society to a libertarian-communist one is class struggle, syndicalism in the broad sense of the word. That is, the unification of people along the lines of contradictions that objectively exist in capitalism, in order to overcome these contradictions and move towards libertarian communism, gaining the experience of collective direct action and unalienated labor.

At the same time, class struggle is not a goal in itself, it is only the most effective tool for achieving our universal goals. Maybe other, more effective tools will appear later, who knows. But even libertarian communism is not a kingdom of heaven for us, desired just like that, because Kropotkin said. It's just that such a structure of society will best contribute to the self-realization and freedom of each individual person, and we believe that, in principle, nothing is more important than this.

In general, donating to the fight against the regime and organizing solidarity campaigns is super important. But at the same time, we must not forget about the political reasons for what we are doing, and take them into account when we are asked, "what is the alternative to Putin." Because otherwise others will offer an alternative, and it's not a fact that we will like it.

Fake Alternatives
By the way, I would like to finally talk about another alternative, as it were, which is often heard from the mouths of, so to speak, "liberal" anti-Putin oppositionists. Since the Putin regime has recently taken up the fashion of squeezing large businesses from private owners and, like, "nationalizing" them, the oppositionists with great indignation oppose "a fair and honest free market" and "corrupt nationalization, a new scoop" and that's all. It is assumed that we need to stop nationalization, return factories, newspapers and ships from the state to private owners, and then we will live.

Of course, this opposition is false. Firstly, the market and the state are inseparable from each other, and are two sides of the same coin. Moreover, they often appeared together. Here's what, for example, the anarchist anthropologist David Graeber says in his excellent book Debt: The First 5,000 Years of History:

"In fact, markets developed not as a way of convenient exchange between acquaintances or random passers-by, but as the only possible way for the state to feed and support its troops. The state could collect taxes in any form convenient for it: livestock, slaves, precious stones. By collecting taxes in coins (on one side of which a portrait of a statesman was usually printed, as a symbol of power, and on the other - value), while simultaneously paying for military service in money, the state created an effective mechanism in which residents were forced to support the army."

That is, the transfer of so-called "assets" back and forth from the next billionaire oligarch to the next ministry and back does not change anything. Actually, even liberal oppositionists are beginning to understand this - in this sense, the new series "Traitors" from FBK is in some sense iconic. It also shows that there would be no "free market" without close interaction with government agencies. You can call it "corruption", or you can simply say that the state and the capitalist "free market" are such a two-faced Janus where it is difficult to separate one from the other.

Well, it's even more strange to think that "private companies", on average, are somehow more fair and beneficial to society than state-owned ones. Private business exists in the interests of owners and shareholders, its strategy is "to minimize costs and increase dividends so that shareholders buy a new yacht." The owners of Alfa Bank or Lukoil do not care about the poor people called "citizens", they have their own tasks. Like in the song of the group "Pornofilms" "Kill the Beggars."

Naturally, the state of affairs in the so-called "democratic countries" is not very different from Russia. Yes, the political regime there is not so cannibalistic, but the shareholders of Boeing or British Petroleum don't give a damn about the poor people called "citizens". So it would be relevant to play a song by the Dead Kennedys, whose cover is the song "Kill Beggars." Kill the poor!

So the means of production (the same factories, newspapers and ships, as well as social networks, Internet search engines, data centers and 3D printers) should not be in the hands of private businessmen, and not in the hands of government officials. Moreover, in fact these are the same hands.

No, instead we propose collective and decentralized management of production - both tangible and intangible. Only this will make it possible to create a society of true equality - both in Russia and throughout the world. And, in turn, only this will help us move towards true freedom for each individual and society as a whole. And this movement is unlikely to ever end.

Well that's all for today! We remind you that in Trends in Order and Chaos, members of Autonomous Action and other authors give anarchist assessments of current events. Listen to us on YouTube, SoundCloud and other platforms, visit our website avtonom.org, subscribe to our social networks and e-mail newsletter.

Issue prepared by Mani

https://avtonom.org/news/individualnoe-obshchechelovecheskoe-i-klassovoe-trendy-poryadka-i-haosa-epizod-160
_________________________________________
A - I N F O S N E W S S E R V I C E
By, For, and About Anarchists
Send news reports to A-infos-en mailing list
A-infos-en@ainfos.ca
Subscribe/Unsubscribe https://ainfos.ca/mailman/listinfo/a-infos-en
Archive: http://ainfos.ca/en
A-Infos Information Center