A - I n f o s

a multi-lingual news service by, for, and about anarchists **
News in all languages
Last 30 posts (Homepage) Last two weeks' posts Our archives of old posts

The last 100 posts, according to language
Greek_ 中文 Chinese_ Castellano_ Catalan_ Deutsch_ Nederlands_ English_ Francais_ Italiano_ Polski_ Português_ Russkyi_ Suomi_ Svenska_ Türkurkish_ The.Supplement

The First Few Lines of The Last 10 posts in:
Castellano_ Deutsch_ Nederlands_ English_ Français_ Italiano_ Polski_ Português_ Russkyi_ Suomi_ Svenska_ Türkçe_
First few lines of all posts of last 24 hours

Links to indexes of first few lines of all posts of past 30 days | of 2002 | of 2003 | of 2004 | of 2005 | of 2006 | of 2007 | of 2008 | of 2009 | of 2010 | of 2011 | of 2012 | of 2013 | of 2014 | of 2015 | of 2016 | of 2017 | of 2018 | of 2019 | of 2020 | of 2021 | of 2022 | of 2023 | of 2024

Syndication Of A-Infos - including RDF - How to Syndicate A-Infos
Subscribe to the a-infos newsgroups

(en) Russia, AIT: 100 years ago, French "communists" killed anarchists (ca, de, fr, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]

Date Sat, 27 Jan 2024 07:42:43 +0200


On January 11, 1924, a tragic event occurred that became a landmark for the French labor movement - the cold-blooded murder of two anarcho-syndicalist labor activists by the "communists", right in the middle of the House of Trade Unions. This article is intended to remind you of the facts and the strategy of the "communist" party to seize hegemony in the labor movement, even including the physical elimination of those who challenge its methods. This is a story that does not belong only to the past...
At the beginning of the twentieth century, the House of Trade Unions was located at number 33 on Rue Grange-aux-Belles. In fact, this building has been the center of activity of the General Confederation of Labor (CGT) since June 1907. The hall on the ground floor could accommodate up to 3 thousand people, and it was very popular among labor activists. There was also a dispensary and a printing house there.

Although the CGT at its creation in 1895 had a revolutionary orientation influenced by anarchism, this became a thing of the past after the Congress of Amiens, which adopted a Charter containing compromises between reformists and revolutionaries (Marxists and anarchists). In 1914, the CGT, like the rest of the left (and even libertarians), fell into nationalism, joining the "holy alliance" during the First World War. However, a minority remained in revolutionary and pacifist positions. It was at Grange aux Belles that its participants met, maintaining contact with each other in the face of adversity and turning this room into a forum where all revolutionary tendencies could find expression, without the desire to predominate one over the other.

But after the war and especially after the Russian Revolution, everything changed. The French "Communist" Party, created in 1921, adopted the Leninist theses of centralization and a single party. For her there could be no other revolutionary option other than her "communism". Voices from within and without that contradicted the party line were suppressed. The task of the "communists" then was to ensure their control over the Unitarian CGT (UVKT), which was created only in 1922 after splitting from the reformist CGT.

Indeed, after the end of the 1914-1918 war, revolutionary ideas quickly spread among members of the CGT trade unions. To avoid the risk of losing control of the union, the reformist Social Democrats, through a series of maneuvers, caused a split to exclude the revolutionary minority that formed the UVKT. It included anarchists, "communists" and revolutionary syndicalists (or "pure" syndicalists). But this tactical alliance, the sole basis of which was the formation of a common front against the reformists within the CGT, no longer had any meaning in the new CGT. It quickly became clear that the "communists" intend to remain the sole masters of the UVKT leadership, that the "U" in its name means: "everyone united around the communists"...

The "communists" could count on the strong support of the revolutionary syndicalists ("pure" syndicalists) from the La Vie Ouvrière group (Monatt and the future organizers of the magazine "La Révolution Prolétarienne"), with whom they agreed to purge the UVKT of its anarchist elements. Ironically, the "communists" will get rid of the revolutionary syndicalists as soon as these "useful idiots" (as Lenin put it) are no longer useful to them. In the October 1925 issue of their magazine La Révolution Prolétarienne, revolutionary syndicalists Monatte and company complained that the "communists" whom they had helped expel the anarchists from the UVCT had in turn expelled them... The revolutionary syndicalists had always been the "useful idiots" of the "communists" ...

The "House of Trade Unions" was legally the property of the Union of Syndicates of the Seine, which was part of the UVKT. In order to assert their hegemony within the UVKT, the "communists" needed to take control of the building and "squeeze the anarchists out of it."

This scenario unfolded in several episodes throughout 1922-1923:

First of all, the "communists" were increasingly gaining a foothold in the "House of Trade Unions", turning it into a political, if not political, meeting place. Thus, it was at the address "Grange-aux-Belles, 33" in May 1921 that the first national congress of the "Communist" Party decided to call itself the "French Section of the Communist International" from January 1, 1922 and adopted the first charters. organizations. In June 1922, the first congress of the UVCT took place in Saint-Etienne. Bolshevik Alexander Lozovsky, sent by Moscow, coined the term "anarcho-syndicalism", which he identified with "anarcho-reformism", to ridicule those who refused to unconditionally adhere to the "communist" line and join the Red International of Trade Unions (Profintern), which had just been created in Moscow.

Libertarians felt they were facing political exploitation of the trade union movement. Tension grew, but remained in "verbal" forms, despite the harshness of statements and denial from the "communists." These latter increasingly multiplied unsubstantiated allegations and insinuations, and libertarians increasingly questioned the need to remain in the UVCT.

On October 15, 1922, in order to "stake out" the territory, the "Communist" Party held its second congress in the building at 33 Grange-aux-Belles, in the presence of another delegate from Moscow, Dmitry Manuilsky, sent by the Comintern. The "House of Trade Unions" gradually turned into the "House of the Party," which increasingly irritated anarchists committed to the idea of trade union autonomy in relation to political parties.

Moreover, the "communists" were less and less hiding their desire to Bolshevize the UVKT and use it as a "drive belt" of the party: since 1923 and the moment of the occupation of the Ruhr by the French army, the opportunity arose to implement the directives of the Profintern on the subordination of the trade union to the party, modestly renamed into "cooperation between the Communist Party and the trade union on a national scale." Then the UVKT signed the first agreement with the Communist Party on joint actions within the framework of the "Central Committee for Action against Imperialism and War." In January, the UVKT was the only trade union center to take part in the Essen Conference in Germany, convened by the Communist International, and signed, together with seven other "communist" parties in Europe, a manifesto "against the predatory Treaty of Versailles and for the struggle against the occupation of the Ruhr."

Internationally, anarchists who had at one time supported the Russian Revolution eventually responded to information about the real situation coming from Russia. They met in Berlin in 1921 and decided to convene a major international congress to which all non-Bolshevik revolutionaries were invited. This congress met at the end of December 1922 - beginning of January 1923, still in Berlin. The Russian anarchists in attendance, some of whom held important positions in the Russian Revolution (like Alexander Shapiro), painted a depressing picture of the situation in the young Soviet Union and the terror by which the "Communist" Party ruled. Congress decided to publish a pamphlet containing evidence, "The Suppression of Anarchism in Soviet Russia," a veritable little black book of "communism." Using these examples, they sought to demonstrate to the working public the danger of Bolshevism.

The International Congress, which united, among others, the Spanish CNT, the Argentine FORA of Argentina, the German FAUD, the Italian USI, Russian anarcho-syndicalists, as well as envoys from Asia, decided to revive the International Labor Association (I.A.T.) as a revolutionary alternative to the Profintern. A message of sympathy was sent to the French anarcho-syndicalists who attended the congress as guests, with an invitation to officially join the M.A.T. But the French anarcho-syndicalists hesitated; they want to fight within the UVKT, hoping for victory at the emergency congress to be held in Bourges in the summer of 1923.

Throughout 1923, conflicts between anarchists and "communists" around the "Russian question" grew in the UVKT. Anarchists spoke increasingly loudly about the disappearances and murders of activists in the Soviet Union, repressions against workers in Petrograd, sailors in Kronstadt, or also against Ukrainian peasants and the Makhnovshchina. On the eve of the extraordinary congress of the CGT, they translated and distributed the M.A.T. pamphlet. "The Suppression of Anarchism in Soviet Russia".

But the extraordinary Congress of Bourges in 1923 was marked by the victory of the "communist" majority, which, when voting on draft resolutions, gained three-quarters of the votes, over the finally defeated anarcho-syndicalist minority. Now the way was open for the "Communist" Party to increasingly assert its influence on the UVKT, especially since the Bolshevization of the "Communist" universe began in 1924.

From now on, the "Communist" Party could no longer be shy and - in order to clearly demonstrate its influence - decided to convene an election meeting in the "House of Trade Unions" on January 11, 1924. For the anarchists this was too much; they considered that the "communists" had crossed the "red line." Le Libertaire, the newspaper of the Anarchist Federation at the time, then called for this controversy to be brought to a rally of "communists" to voice a point of view different from that of the pro-Moscow election supporters.

The public meeting began on the evening of January 11. About 3 thousand people were present in the hall. Three hundred libertarians came. On the podium, one after another, the leaders of the Communist Party and the International Red Aid replaced each other. Marta Bigo, one of the leaders of the party and UVKT, speaks. A libertarian activist interrupts her: "Syndicalism is none of your business." First skirmishes. One of the leaders of the PCF and manager of L'Humanité, Marcel Cachin, is trying to restore calm.

Nothing helps. On the contrary, shouts and applause are heard, and hand-to-hand fighting increases. Julien Le Pen, secretary of the electrical fitters' union, cuts off the electricity. Henri Reynaud, one of the secretaries of the UVCT and a member of the Communist Party, turns it on again, thereby making it possible for the clashes to continue. Albert Trent, the newly minted party secretary, steps up to the podium and launches into a series of insults at the anarchists gathered in the left corner of the room, trying to occupy the podium. Trent, who served as a captain during the First World War, was criticized for his military background, martinet behavior and the daily abuse he poured out in L'Humanité.

For the first time, Communist Party security intervened to repel the attackers who tried to occupy the podium. Trent orders the security force, led by former military man Georges Beaugrand, to respond more vigorously. After this they open fire. Jules Boudou, real name Sellene, secretary of the carpenters' union and one of the main leaders of the trade union minority, is shot in the throat, but miraculously survives. However, Nicolas Clos, a minority member of the unitary metalworkers' union, and Adrien Ponce, a member of the organizing committee of the Anarchist Union and an activist of the unitary builders' union, who May Pickeray recalls as a rebel who lived under pseudonyms, are fatally wounded and die while being transported to hospital.

The next day, the newspapers Le Libertaire and L'Humanité come out with mutual accusations. But there is plenty of evidence: the libertarians were grouped in the left corner of the hall, and the bullet holes were on that side. The anarchist newspaper and the organ of the CGT, Le Peuple, publishes a growing body of evidence. Some of the activists present were able to give an accurate description of one of the shooters. However, the libertarians themselves removed evidence that could have identified the shooter. On January 15, during Ponce's funeral, three thousand people followed the funeral procession, and the Communist Party prompted Clo's lifelong friend to declare that he was allegedly a member of the party, although this contradicted all evidence. The Communist Party managed to attract only a few people to his funeral.

The UVKT authorities, at the urgent request of the anarchists, formed a commission of inquiry, which, on the advice of the communist majority, never published the results. By chance, one of the perpetrators of the shooting was clearly identified as Gabriel Ducoeur, a "communist" and head of the Federation of Railway Workers, known for his rampant violence during the First World War. In 1929, two libertarian and trade union activists from the CGT, Julien Le Pen and Albert Guigui, victims of intrigues by the "communists", revealed his name.

In anarchist memory, the death of Clos and Ponce joined the deaths of other libertarians who fell under the blows of Leninists - from the disappeared Baltic sailors to those killed in the May days in Barcelona.

After these murders, the newspaper Le Libertaire published the headline: "Let's break with the murderers." Anarchists, as well as non-communist syndicalists (but not revolutionary syndicalists) left the UVKT to temporarily regroup into the Federal Union of Autonomous Trade Unions (UFSA). However, this emotionally motivated departure could not hide the ideological differences between those who retained hope in the revolutionary project and those who were resigned to abandoning any prospect of a break with capitalism. Following two years of debate, the latter joined the ranks of the reformist and social democratic CGT. The anarchists decided, on a proposal presented by Budu, among others, at the UFSA congress in June 1926, to create the Revolutionary-Syndicalist CGT (CGT-SR), which became the French section of the M.A.T.

MAT. still exists today, more than 100 years later, and the current CNT-AIT has taken up the baton of the CGT-SR as a section in France committed to the same values of renouncing political parties and fighting for workers' autonomy...

Is this a story from the past? Don't be so sure...

In 1924, the newspaper Le Libertaire concluded its article "The Killers" with these words: "There is now blood between the criminals of Grange-aux-Belles and us. We will keep this in mind and know how to act accordingly." However, a hundred years later, many anarchists seem to have forgotten this and do not hesitate to join the same trade unions as the ideological successors of the Grange-au-Belle murderers, sign joint leaflets with them, or even organize common events with them.

We could say that, after all, these are stories of the past, that much water has passed under the bridge since then, and now those times and those sectarian practices of the "communists" are gone. But is it?

Since 1924, "communists" (whether in their guise as orthodox Leninists, Stalinists, Trotskyists or Maoists) have repeatedly demonstrated their desire for dominance and their refusal to tolerate methods or strategies different from their own. Let's remember the Spanish resistance fighters killed by "communist" guerrillas, or the resistance fighters whom the "communists" refused to help escape from Pétain's dungeons simply because they had the misfortune of being anarchists.

If we are closer to our times, we can remember the unemployed Isabelle Ferron, who was killed by activists of the organization "Act Together Against Unemployment!" (AC!) and the SUD trade union in 1998. We will also not forget the reaction of many "left" organizations, be it in the Tarnak case or during the riots of 2005 ("Those responsible for the violence and damage must be punished," the press said -release of the French Communist Party on November 3, 2005), about the expulsion by members of the CGT of a group of illegal immigrants from the labor exchange they seized in 2009, or even more recently about accusations of every conceivable evil against the "yellow vests" - accusations to come which was led by Martinet from the CGT ("The yellow vests are supported by certain big bosses").

Throughout history, the authoritarian tendencies of the labor movement have condemned as "provocateurs" all those who dared to act autonomously. They reported them to the state and its police, which is why they were beaten and repressed uncontrollably, but, if necessary, they did this dirty work themselves.

Even today, as we have seen with pension reform, political parties and trade unions are obstacles to self-organization and the struggle for liberation. They are merely pacifiers of a social situation that is nonetheless explosive. (Didn't Sophie Binet say that we shouldn't do anything that could interfere with future Olympic Games?).

Anyone who does not remember his past is doomed to relive it.

As dark clouds loom over the horizon, it is important to remember who our friends are and who are not.

Do not forget. Don't forgive.

Nicolas Clos and Adrien Ponce, you are with us!

Anarcho-syndicalist activists of the French Ministry of Health

http://cnt-ait.info/2024/01/11/11-janvier-1924/

https://aitrus.info/node/6188
_________________________________________
A - I N F O S N E W S S E R V I C E
By, For, and About Anarchists
Send news reports to A-infos-en mailing list
A-infos-en@ainfos.ca
Subscribe/Unsubscribe https://ainfos.ca/mailman/listinfo/a-infos-en
Archive: http://ainfos.ca/en
A-Infos Information Center