|
A - I n f o s
|
|
a multi-lingual news service by, for, and about anarchists
**
News in all languages
Last 30 posts (Homepage)
Last two
weeks' posts
Our
archives of old posts
The last 100 posts, according
to language
Greek_
中文 Chinese_
Castellano_
Catalan_
Deutsch_
Nederlands_
English_
Francais_
Italiano_
Polski_
Português_
Russkyi_
Suomi_
Svenska_
Türkurkish_
The.Supplement
The First Few Lines of The Last 10 posts in:
Castellano_
Deutsch_
Nederlands_
English_
Français_
Italiano_
Polski_
Português_
Russkyi_
Suomi_
Svenska_
Türkçe_
First few lines of all posts of last 24 hours
Links to indexes of first few lines of all posts
of past 30 days |
of 2002 |
of 2003 |
of 2004 |
of 2005 |
of 2006 |
of 2007 |
of 2008 |
of 2009 |
of 2010 |
of 2011 |
of 2012 |
of 2013 |
of 2014 |
of 2015 |
of 2016 |
of 2017 |
of 2018 |
of 2019 |
of 2020 |
of 2021 |
of 2022 |
of 2023 |
of 2024
Syndication Of A-Infos - including
RDF - How to Syndicate A-Infos
Subscribe to the a-infos newsgroups
(en) Russia AIT: Vadim Damier: Economics of Freedo (ca, de, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]
Date
Thu, 25 Jan 2024 10:50:51 +0200
The collapse of state-capitalist dictatorships in Eastern Europe and the
former Soviet Union proved that any attempts to combine a just social
ideal with the preservation of the state and commodity-money (market)
relations are doomed to inevitable failure. Communist anarchism has
always predicted just such an end for Marxist utopias; it is in no way
discredited by the experience of social democracy and party-state
"communism", and therefore there is no need to "supplement" it with
borrowings from these teachings, which have suffered a complete collapse.
The idea of "market socialism" refers specifically to such borrowings.
It was born in the minds of social democratic theorists and was adopted
by party reformers, which, however, did not save the "communist camp",
but accelerated the economic catastrophe. However, many on the left -
including some anarchists - have embraced the idea of combining
socialism and the market, considering it an alternative to centralized
"planning".
Meanwhile, attempts by anti-state, anti-authoritarian socialists to
combine a fair social system with market relations have always failed.
They either led to a kind of "collective capitalism" (this happened,
according to the description of G. Leval and D. Abad de Santillan, with
some collectivized enterprises during the Spanish revolution: they
retained money and the wage system and continued to run the economy
selfishly, at their own peril and risk), or to limit self-government by
expanding the powers of managers (with the goal of more prompt and
"effective" decision-making in the market, as was the case in
kibbutzim). Market relations - even the most "free" ones - are
completely incompatible with either solidarity, morality, or freedom
itself. The French environmental philosopher A. Gorz showed in his book
"Critique of Economic Reason" that both under centralized bureaucratic
and market systems, a person's will is fettered, and his activities and
the entire life of society escape from his conscious control. Thus, when
people are subject to faceless and independent market laws that cannot
be controlled, the results of the uncoordinated activities of
individuals do not correspond to their will and desire. These results
are random, as in thermodynamics. Meanwhile, freedom is the ability to
consciously manage one's own life (self-government). Sociopsychologist
E. Fromm ("To Have or to Be") gave a brilliant analysis of the so-called
"market character," showing how market relations decompose and deform
the human personality: it turns into an object of purchase and sale,
into a commodity that itself seeks to sell itself more profitably and
develops in itself only those qualities that can be "bought." All
relationships between people are subject to selfish, utilitarian
principles of profitability, any activity becomes prostitution, and
mutual assistance and solidarity disappear, replaced by a mutual war of
"all against all," a war between embittered and envious individuals.
Market relations cannot exist in a truly free and solidary society -
they will inevitably and inevitably destroy it.
Some propose maintaining the market ("socialist") model only for the
"transitional" period to anarcho-communism, with payment "according to
the quantity and quality of labor." They repeat Marxist arguments about
the difference between "socialism" and "communism", about the
"outgrowing" of the former into the latter, and about the conditions for
such outgrowing (higher labor productivity, abundance, higher
consciousness, etc.)
These purely productivist arguments could have been seriously discussed
thirty years ago, before the onset of the environmental crisis. Today it
is absolutely clear: a just society can only be built on environmental
harmony. If humanity wants to survive, then not only growth, but in a
number of industries even maintaining the level of labor productivity of
developed capitalism is out of the question. And those who associate
communism with "abundance" in the traditional sense of the word risk
never seeing it at all: unlimited economic growth in the limited system
of planet Earth is impossible.
It is also difficult to agree with the idea that "payment according to
the quantity and quality of labor invested" is the most effective and
acceptable if we want to avoid disinterest and passivity on the part of
workers. People's indifference to their own work arises when they
themselves cannot control its progress and results, do not feel its
social significance, and do not imagine the meaning and purpose of the
labor process as a whole. This is natural in the presence of alienation
and a detailed ("Taylorist") division of labor in modern industrial
production, and no "material incentive" can change anything here.
But in the agricultural communes of revolutionary Spain and in the
kibbutzim with the communist distribution system, people understood why
and for whom they worked, and they worked no worse and no less
effectively than in capitalist enterprises.
Only those who, following the Marxists, believe that these investments
can be measured at all can seriously talk about payment according to the
quantity and quality of labor invested. In reality this is impossible.
Any socially necessary labor is of equal value; It is not possible to
determine what amount of labor, for example, an engineer is equal to
what amount of labor of a peasant or a bus driver. Labor productivity
can be random and depend on many factors that cannot be taken into
account at all. Finally, with modern production, any product contains
the labor of thousands and thousands of people, even several
generations. And who will determine and establish this "quantity and
quality" of labor? New government?
Attempts to establish a new social hierarchy "based on labor" will only
lead to a violation of equality and solidarity, to the emergence of a
new privileged elite of the "able-bodied," "qualified," and successful,
to the establishment of the power of new "Stakhanovites" and shock
workers of "socialist labor." And to protect their power and privileges,
the state will again be needed.
Of course, in a free anarcho-communist society, even at first,
individual farms are preserved that do not exploit the labor of others -
small peasants, artisans, handicraftsmen. They will not be subject to
forced expropriation, but will be subject to voluntary gradual
cooperation. But it would be a grave mistake to build relations in an
already socialized economy on the same basis as in the individual
"sector," otherwise the latter will inevitably subjugate the economy as
a whole. Until complete socialization, we will be dealing with two
completely different, albeit interacting, economic systems, and in the
larger of them - the socialized one - communist principles of
distribution should be established from the very beginning: free
consumption of what is available in excess and social distribution of
everything else in proportion individual needs (Kropotkin), from each
according to his individual different abilities, to each according to
his individually different needs (the principle of the kibbutz).
Relations with individual farms can be built on the basis of direct
product exchange, contractual access of these farms to socialized goods
and services, transport, etc. In this case, preference should be given
to cooperatives. Relations in the socialized (communist) "sector" from
the very beginning will not be market-based, but focused on the needs of
real people. The economy of a free society will be planned in the true
sense of the word. Under the state-capitalist dictatorship, "planning"
was false, since it was carried out not from below, "from the consumer,"
but from above, from the center. Now, associated producers and consumers
will be able to jointly and jointly determine what, where and how will
be produced and consumed, and on the basis of a free contract "from the
bottom up", mutual coordination of needs and production capabilities can
be ensured. The ways of such "planning from below" are suggested by the
practical experience of actually existing communes and consumer
cooperatives: consumers will summarize their needs at regular general
meetings of local associations and then coordinate these decisions with
production capabilities in the economic bodies of the communes or at
their general meetings with delegates from associated producers.
Communes united in regional and interregional federations,
self-governing producers and consumers will be able, jointly and
solidarily summing up and coordinating needs and opportunities with the
help of statistics, through delegates to commune congresses and economic
councils at various levels, to develop larger economic entities that
serve everyone or several communes.
The "planning" of the economy of an anarchist society should not be
centralized. Not everything needs to be coordinated at the regional,
continental or planetary level. A different principle is appropriate
here. The region should not take upon itself what one commune is able to
do itself, without affecting the interests of others. And the region can
cope on its own with most of its problems, which it is able to resolve
on its own. Therefore, the economy of anarchism is focused on the
maximum possible (though, of course, not complete) self-sufficiency.
This will, among other things, mitigate environmental, raw material and
transport problems and bring production closer to the consumer.
Many economic and environmental problems of modern society are generated
precisely by the fact that what is produced is not what specific
consumers really need, but what they might need from the point of view
of isolated producers. That is, no one knows in advance whether people
need this or that product being manufactured , this is then determined
by the market or the bureaucrat.
In a free ecological society, everything should be different. In a free
society, the economy begins with the consumer. Consumer associations,
associations of residents, together with syndicates of employees of
distribution centers in urban areas and in rural areas, identify the
current and future needs of residents (something like an order system)
and transmit statistical materials to the economic council of the
commune, which, together with delegates from the syndicates and from
consumer associations , based on statistics, determines what the commune
can produce on its own, what products or participation from outside are
required, and what products or services the commune can provide to
residents of other communes. What the commune is able to do for itself
on its own is done locally and does not require coordination with
others. Everything else is coordinated with other communes at the level
required. Coordination is carried out through statistics at economic
congresses of commune delegates and then ratified by the communes
themselves (no one can force a commune to participate in a particular
common project, but then no one can force other communes to continue to
deal with it). That is, what should be produced is exactly what is
really needed by specific people or groups of people. Distribution will
be carried out through the same distribution centers that collect
consumer information, free of charge, but upon presentation by consumers
of an individual card indicating that they have worked the working hours
agreed upon by the members of the commune, or a child's card, or a
pension card (for the unemployed and sick).
As new social relations develop, it will be possible to carry out the
disaggregation of giant cities, the greening of public and individual
life, the redistribution of labor in society (including between the
sexes), so that gradually the strict specialization of labor becomes a
thing of history, and labor turns into creative and enjoyable
constructive work. game.
The economic system of a new society can only be an economy of general
self-government, an economy of freedom. It is not professional managers,
bureaucrats and directors who should regulate production, but the
workers themselves. General economic decisions will have to be made by
everyone - at general meetings of consumer associations and communes or
(through delegates with an imperative mandate) at their congresses, and
the direct management of production will be concentrated in the hands of
self-governing labor collectives, technical councils and syndicates
created by them, united in a double (industrial and territorial) federation.
All this, of course, is just general and fundamental considerations.
There are many details that cannot be predicted, much less reflected in
a short article. The answer will be provided by the practice of a free
society. For now, it is important to realize one thing: people who want
to survive in decent conditions will be forced to give up dominion over
nature and over their own kind. But this means precisely a radical
change in the processes and ways of making social and economic
decisions, the replacement of external regulation (from the bureaucracy
or spontaneous market laws) with self-government and federal contractual
"planning" from below.
In other words, an anarchist society will be a society without
bureaucracy, without money and without a market, or there will be no
market at all.
https://aitrus.info/node/6187
_________________________________________
A - I N F O S N E W S S E R V I C E
By, For, and About Anarchists
Send news reports to A-infos-en mailing list
A-infos-en@ainfos.ca
Subscribe/Unsubscribe https://ainfos.ca/mailman/listinfo/a-infos-en
Archive: http://ainfos.ca/en
A-Infos Information Center