A - I n f o s

a multi-lingual news service by, for, and about anarchists **
News in all languages
Last 30 posts (Homepage) Last two weeks' posts Our archives of old posts

The last 100 posts, according to language
Greek_ 中文 Chinese_ Castellano_ Catalan_ Deutsch_ Nederlands_ English_ Francais_ Italiano_ Polski_ Português_ Russkyi_ Suomi_ Svenska_ Türkurkish_ The.Supplement

The First Few Lines of The Last 10 posts in:
Castellano_ Deutsch_ Nederlands_ English_ Français_ Italiano_ Polski_ Português_ Russkyi_ Suomi_ Svenska_ Türkçe_
First few lines of all posts of last 24 hours

Links to indexes of first few lines of all posts of past 30 days | of 2002 | of 2003 | of 2004 | of 2005 | of 2006 | of 2007 | of 2008 | of 2009 | of 2010 | of 2011 | of 2012 | of 2013 | of 2014 | of 2015 | of 2016 | of 2017 | of 2018 | of 2019 | of 2020 | of 2021 | of 2022 | of 2023 | of 2024

Syndication Of A-Infos - including RDF - How to Syndicate A-Infos
Subscribe to the a-infos newsgroups

(en) Italy, UCADI FA #180 - The Argentina enigma (ca, de, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]

Date Tue, 23 Jan 2024 10:27:47 +0200


The election of the ultra-liberal and populist Milei is the result of the tiredness of Argentine society towards the country's political class, a prisoner of Argentine bipartisanship, the result of the right and left degeneration of Peronism, of its ambiguities, of the contradictory choices that accompany this particular political ideology in economic and social matters. The country's inflation is running at 150%, poverty and inequalities are rampant, despite the fact that the country enjoys great wealth and variety of natural resources, a population with a high level of literacy, has a well-developed agricultural system and a solid industrial base which makes it one of the most developed countries in Latin America (after Brazil and Mexico).

However, the fragility of its economic structure meant that the country was the victim of repeated speculative phenomena at the hands of international finance, in particular in 2001, 2014, 2019, which plundered its economic resources, bringing its economy to its knees. and enormously reducing the terror of the population's life.
To give an idea of how much inflation has affected and continues to affect the economic situation of the country, it is enough to remember, for example, that at the beginning of 2014, with inflation of 28%. The Argentine Peso suffered a 14% devaluation in a single session which brought it to a minimum of 834 pesos per dollar, which represents the lowest value since the crisis in 2001-2002. With consumer price inflation growing at a rate of 30% per year, the country is perpetually on the brink of a new financial crisis, so much so that in 2018 it asked the International Monetary Fund for a bridge loan of 30 billion dollars to settle the interest of short-term public debt securities. This maneuver resulted in the increase in the cost of money, which rose to 33%, in an attempt to revalue the peso and stop international speculation.
This situation is largely due to the fact that the Argentine economy is characterized by an oligopoly that manages the national distribution of goods, for which the country's market is controlled by the French Carrefour, the Chilean Disco and the Coto agenda, which determine the prices without any real possible competition. The result is, as we said, inflation running at 150%.
This situation is the basis of Milei's proposal for thedollarization of the Argentine economy. Using demagogic images and paradoxical proposals such as that of the abolition of the Argentine Central Bank, Milei managed to create the illusion that it is possible to adopt the dollar as the national currency, so that producers of goods and services see their work paid in a currency solid, not subject to such devastating inflation.

An astonished and disconcerted country

What is incomprehensible to the Argentines and that in them is one of the countries in the world that enjoys the greatest agricultural production and thriving breeding, in particular of cattle, to the point that Argentina is one of the largest exporters of beef and sheep meat in the world. The country produces soya, corn and wheat in the Pampas (an endless flat and irrigated territory), in such quantities as to be able to support livestock farming and export a large part of the product and manages to allocate a substantial part of the product to a thriving food industry. Cereals, milk and beef represent the basis of the population's diet but it is difficult to access them due to low wages and unstoppable inflation.
The country possesses a considerable quantity of oil and gas and a fairly developed petrochemical industry which, together with the production of soy and the metalworking industry, constitutes the economic-productive base of the country; oil exports, which have deposits concentrated in the provinces of Néquén and Bahia Blanca, are equal to 20% of the total and only a part is reserved for the petrochemical industry.
Argentina's manufacturing production contributes 17.5% of the gross domestic product and, together with commerce and the public sector, is the sector with the highest employment, followed by construction. Argentine industry is divided into the agricultural industry, dominated by the food and meat processing industries, while, moving on to other sectors, the most important industry is the automotive industry, followed by the chemical, metallurgical and finally paper industries. The most important industrial area of the country extends from Gran Buenos Aires to Córdoba, passing through Rosario. Other relevant centers are Tucumán, San Luis and Tierra del Fuego. Due to privatisation, the naval industry has lost considerable importance and jobs. The tourism industry is quite developed but suffers from the communication difficulties that characterize the country and which will be discussed later.
This production system is not supported by adequate infrastructures that allow its efficiency. Argentina was once one of the countries on the American continent with the largest railway network which over time has reduced its distances to 37,740 km by disposing of 12,000 km. The public transport system has been integrated by a network of buses that travel across the country , managed by private companies that have handed over the country to road transport, also with regards to the movement of goods.
In a pre-election climate in September 2023, Parliament approved a bill proposed by candidate Massa which provides for total exemption from public taxes for income from employment for the majority of the population, leaving the tax only for incomes exceeding 15 times the federal minimum wage, i.e. incomes exceeding 1.77 million pesos per month. But if the measure earned the proponent support among public employees and those on fixed incomes, it was not enough to earn him the favor of the most voters, convinced by Milei's proposals for total deregulation. This imbalance, this constant disruption of the country, the unequal distribution of wealth, generate a sense of total frustration in Argentines, which has its origins and causes in a political proposal incapable of addressing the problems of the population whose deficiencies come from distant.

A country fascinated by Peronism

The colonization of the country was until the 1920s by an oligarchy made up of large breeders and meat traders and large landowners, who managed a rural proletariat dependent on breeding and agriculture, which was soon joined by a workers employed mainly in the food industry and an urban middle class made up of public employees, fueled by massive emigration from Europe, while the economy was controlled by British and American capital, owners of around 50% of the companies. The composition of the peasant and urban proletariat was nourished through the emigration, often political, of workers exiled from Europe of socialist orientation, anarchist anarchist syndicalist and communist who brought their experiences of struggle to the country. This particular class composition gave birth to solid workers' organizations, including the FORA Federation of Obrera Regional Argentina which led radical struggles and managed to organize as many as half a million workers. Subsequently, the Confederacion General de Tabajo (CGT) was formed. The Argentine trade union movement led intense struggles which were only contained through the use of dictatorial governments such as that of José Felix Uriburu who took power in 1930.
The response of the trade union movement was not long in coming, so much so that we witnessed harsh struggles which lasted until 1942 when, as a result of the Ribbentrop-Molotov pact, a split occurred in the trade union movement. Juan Domingo Peron, a colonel exponent of the Grupo de Oficiales Unidos (GOU), took advantage of this to give life to the justicialist movement which developed its program during his first presidency of the Republic (1945-1955) with the ideological and image contribution of his wife Evita Peron. His followers were called descamisados, symbolically indicating their origin from the sub-proletarian and popular strata of society. Peron gave life to a syncretic and populist political movement that combines socialist principles with patriotism, identifying fascist corporatism as a third economic way, giving life to a form of "nationalist socialism" with a conservative orientation from an ethical and ideal point of view.
In economics, Peronism uses Keynesian and dirigiste theories, establishing an economic system with a strong presence of the State that operates the mixed private-public economy regime, not disdaining the use of five-year economic planning plans to govern accumulation. Thus, public companies were born which, through a welfare policy, supported the union activity of workers and private employees. In foreign policy, Peronism was characterized by distancing itself from United States policy in the South American subcontinent, promoting third world positions, neutralism and non-alignment towards the two Soviet and American blocs. The success of Peronism was favored by the economic growth due to a very strong demand for agricultural and livestock products from all the belligerent countries and the shift of industrial production to areas that were not theaters of war. In the years from 1943 to 1945, Peron, allying himself with the unions, achieved what had not been done in the previous decades of class struggle: compulsory insurance for accidents at work and occupational diseases, the eight-hour working day, the statute of daily workers, the thirteenth month's salary, paid holidays, the extension of the pension system, the official recognition of the legal status of trade unions, etc. This policy of his meant that when his opponents tried to remove him by incarcerating him but he managed to reverse the situation. In 1946 Perón won the elections, with a list supported by both nationalist and socialist trade union sectors. His Government can enjoy a favorable economic situation, thanks to the abundant reserves of gold and foreign currency, a positive trade balance and an expanding internal market and thus proceed with a redistribution of wealth, which gives his regime consensus which allows him to free himself from the support of the left-wing and trade union forces that had supported him.
With the first five-year plan, the Central Bank and the public service companies (railways, water, gas, telephones) were nationalized, removing them from the control of the Anglo-American groups and boost was given to public housing and the literacy of the poorer classes. All this, while the 1949 Constitution recognizes the right to strike, health and education, entrusts the State with a monopoly on foreign trade.
Peronism began its crisis with the death of Evita Duarte, Perón's wife, who was a skilled propagandist of her husband and the movement, personifying the regime's bond with the people. Thus in 1955 a military coup, sponsored by the Catholic Church which did not accept the introduction of divorce by law, deposed Perón who had to flee abroad. From then on, a succession of coups d'état began that would lead Argentina towards civil war: the Peronist party was outlawed together with the parties of the left and the communists.
In 1962 the guerrilla movement of the Montoneros, the Ejército Guerrillero del Pueblo (of Guevarist inspiration), the Fuerzas Armadas Peronistas and other groups were born, which in 1967 gave life to OLAS (Organizacion Latonoamericano de Solidaridad) which encompassed all the anti- Latin American imperialists belonging to the most diverse political backgrounds. The economic and social decline of the governments that followed one another in the sixties, also pressured by the guerrilla activity of the Montoneros, paved the way for the return of Perón in 1973 who died on 1 July 1974.

Between post-Peronism and dictatorship

This summary reconstruction of the Peronist parable makes us understand how composite and multifaceted the Peronist influence and legacy is in Argentine political life. The death of Perón, who was succeeded by his second wife Isabelita, left a balkanized political system in which the military soon entered, establishing a dictatorship and ferocious repression. The Argentine Anti-Communist Alliance (AAA) was created which in the period 1973-75 killed more than 400 people and " Operation Condor " began , wanted by Kissinger, financed, planned and organized by the United States in concert with the secret services of the States South Americans and especially Chile where the 1973 coup had brought colonels to power. In 1976 a coup organized by the armed forces brought to government a triumvirate of generals, presided over by Videla and a ferocious dictatorship began which led to the disappearance of more than 30,000 people. Those who were even simply suspected of being leftists were seized and arrested and taken to clandestine detention centers, tortured and often killed, the corpses hidden or dumped into the sea with the so-called death flights of Hercules planes of the Argentine army that unloaded people still lives in the ocean. Pregnant women were given birth and their children were taken away and given up for clandestine adoption to military families. The military personnel who conducted the operation were trained in the US-funded School of the Americas. The regime collapsed in 1982 only following the Argentine defeat in the Falklands War which discredited the military regime.
In 1983, a democratic government was restored to the country and Raul Alfonsin was elected president. The new government committed itself to accounting for the disappeared , placed the armed forces under civilian control and consolidated democratic institutions. Members of the military juntas were put on trial. The failure to resolve the endemic economic problems and the inability to maintain the trust of public opinion led to Alfonsín's early abandonment, six months before his mandate expired and effectively started a crisis in the economic management of the country which has since remains. In 1991, to stop the penetration of hyperinflation, the Peso-Dollar exchange rate was imposed, the market was used, dismantling the protectionist barriers and regulations that protected the national industry, and a privatization program was developed. If it is true that these measures led to a significant increase in international private investments, it must be said that they contributed to causing the country's recession because its economic activities were no longer protected. foreign debt skyrocketed and unemployment, corruption and social discontent reached their highest levels.
In 2001 Argentina was overwhelmed by a deep economic crisis caused by the recession triggered by the Asian financial crisis of 1998 which also led to an institutional crisis. The country was forced to admit that it was impossible for it to meet economic commitments made with other states and we therefore witnessed the default of its international obligations. The pegging of the peso to the dollar was abandoned and this encouraged the return of goods to real values, producing a large depreciation of the peso and a frightening growth in inflation, with consequent blockage of the economy, increase in the unemployed and the new poor, crisis of liquidity from the system, increase in crime and spread of acts of vandalism against banks and commercial establishments, social instability.

Argentina's attempted economic recovery

In 2002 the Argentine economy began to stabilize coinciding with the election of Nestor Kirchner as President, the defaulted debt was restructured and the debt with the IMF was repaid and some public interest companies were nationalized. Fundamental for the recovery economic was the so-called "soy boom": the conversion of many vast agricultural areas to the production of soy and the consequent strong exports (heavily taxed since 2008), led to economic growth and a flow of foreign currency, however the debt towards the foreign exchange remained high.
For two subsequent mandates, Argentina was presided over by Cristina Kirchner, the president's wife, who committed herself to the recovery of the country's economy but the drop in the prices of agricultural products on international markets led to the worsening of the crisis; in 2014 the dramatic growth in inflation exploded to the point that in July of that year the country's second default was announced. With the presidential elections of 2015, Mauricio Macrì was elected and adopted liberalist-inspired policies, starting with the liberalization of the exchange rate of the Argentine peso, whose exchange value with the dollar was established by government decree and heavy limits were placed on the possibility for citizens to purchase foreign currency. This led to the disappearance of the black market of currencies, together with a nominal devaluation of the peso of over 40%.

The BRICS alternative

The election in 2019 of Alberto Fernàndez as president, accompanied by Cristina Fernàndez de Kirchner. It confirmed the political choices of previous administrations which identified a possible solution to Argentina's problems within the context of a "regional" solution, common to other countries on the continent, also taking advantage of President Lula's return to power in Brazil.
The left-wing component of Peronism, led by Kirchner, identified regional ties and Argentina's entry into the Brics on 1 January 2994 as the solution to the country's major economic problems.
Through closer ties with Brazil, with which there is a large volume of economic and commercial exchanges, the Argentine government thought of creating a blockade, also using the Brics' aspiration to replace the dollar as the reference currency. This project worried the United States a lot and they poured their support into Milei. However, to understand how the president-elect has conquered growing sectors of society, breaking the bipartisan logic between right-wing and left-wing Peronism, we must start from the complex procedure that regulates the identification of presidential candidacies.
After an initial phase of open, simultaneous and mandatory primaries, through a hybrid system, the candidates are selected, placing a limit on the proliferation of small minority forces (it being necessary to reach a threshold of at least 1.5% of valid votes ). This is how we proceed with the organization of the first round: to be elected President, the candidate with the most votes must obtain 45% of the votes or 40% and there must be a difference of 10 points with the second candidate. Otherwise, the two candidates with the most votes advance to the second round. Milei, in both the first and second rounds, obtained approximately 30% of the votes (29.86% and 29.99% respectively). winning in the heart of Argentina's agrarian region, where social and economic opposition to centre-left Peronism arose during the 2008 mass protests against a change in the tax regime on grain exports, and where a new centre-right majority, which managed to offset the weight of Peronism in the popular and populous suburbs of the city of Buenos Aires (the so-called 'conurbano').
In the provinces of Córdoba, Santa Fe and southern Entre Ríos, La Libertad Avanza won against the candidate supported by the Peronist right and managed to win over a part of the Peronist electorate, as demonstrated by its victories in the traditionally Peronist provinces of the north- west, such as Salta, Tucumán and La Rioja - in the latter two it won the primaries and obtained a good result in the first round (34.9% and 37.6% respectively). This means that Peronism lost power in the face of discontent, which Milei instead knew how to capitalize on. Only in the province and autonomous city of Buenos Aires did the old two-party structure maintain some relevance, with around 70% of the votes divided between Peronism and the right-wing coalition.
This means that Milei represents a renewal of the right in Argentina who managed to undermine the electoral organization divided into two coalitions, one dominated by Kirchner's terrorism, interrupting a cycle that lasted 12 years, and the other center-right led by the Republican Proposal party ( PRO) by Mauricio Macrì. A far-right leader, who harshly criticized the leaders of both coalitions as a "political caste", managed to represent discontent and take power in a context of deep economic crisis and open conflict between the various factions that make up the main electoral coalitions.
The new President is a true outsider who came to power thanks to a weak electoral machine, the La Libertad Avanza movement, created in 2021 to support his candidacy in the legislative elections in the city of Buenos Aires. he managed to establish a relatively close relationship with a depoliticized electorate. Convinced of the power of direct contact, he relied on a small group made up of his sister, a handful of young social media specialists and some minor political laborers who negotiated with local conservative leaders or leaders marginalized by the parties traditional, in order to guarantee a national extension to La Libertad Avanza. The weakness of this structure was demonstrated by the party's mediocre results in the provincial elections in which it failed to win a single governorship. In other words Milei is an individualistic leader without organization, without militant structure and without political cadres.
His electoral campaign was based entirely on rhetoric on an offensive form and content of his infectious words towards his opponents defined with trivial language from time to time as shits, shitty thieves, bastards and so on and so forth.
put. Behind these invectives, his vice president, Victoria Villarruel, acts more effectively, against the protection of human rights and democracy, and who claims the legacy of the coup generals and the "dirty war".
Milei is the President with the most ambitious reform program in the history of Argentina, but he does not have the resources and strength to carry it out. To achieve this he will need to create a coalition with the right-wing Peronists of the (PRO) who openly supported him in the second round, compensating for the weakness of his La Libertà Avanz movement by providing manpower to monitor the polls and accompanying the transfer of votes from the right classic to the new one of Milei, proof is that in the second round 92% of voters from the traditional right voted for Him. Those who voted for him represent both the productive and medium-high sectors disappointed by Juntos por el Cambio, and the «small" lower economic sectors with informal jobs. These sectors have a negative view of the public sector, of the job stability of public employees. However, a large percentage of its voters do not support the austerity policies that are necessary but would hit the working class. For example, according to some studies, a large majority believes that the state should provide good retirement pensions, which are one of the main expenditure items in the Argentine public budget. Even if the geographical and social diffusion of the vote covers the whole country, Milei arrived at the presidency without any control over the provincials and with a bloc of only 38 deputies out of 257 and 7 senators out of 72. His institutional weakness makes him dependent on agreements with other political forces, in particular with the PRO and its allies and with the dissident Peronist sectors of official Peronism.
What resources will he have available to manage the social protest that will likely emerge in the face of public budget cuts and other reforms that affect the power of the unions? Milei won in all but three provinces with more than 11 points ahead of the Peronist candidate (55.7% to 44.3%). His victory extended to 352 of the country's more than 500 electoral districts, including departments, municipalities and parties (territorial entities halfway between municipalities and provinces).
The games are on.

The Editorial Team

https://www.ucadi.org/2023/12/20/lenigma-argentina/
_________________________________________
A - I N F O S N E W S S E R V I C E
By, For, and About Anarchists
Send news reports to A-infos-en mailing list
A-infos-en@ainfos.ca
Subscribe/Unsubscribe https://ainfos.ca/mailman/listinfo/a-infos-en
Archive: http://ainfos.ca/en
A-Infos Information Center