A - I n f o s

a multi-lingual news service by, for, and about anarchists **
News in all languages
Last 30 posts (Homepage) Last two weeks' posts Our archives of old posts

The last 100 posts, according to language
Greek_ 中文 Chinese_ Castellano_ Catalan_ Deutsch_ Nederlands_ English_ Francais_ Italiano_ Polski_ Português_ Russkyi_ Suomi_ Svenska_ Türkurkish_ The.Supplement

The First Few Lines of The Last 10 posts in:
Castellano_ Deutsch_ Nederlands_ English_ Français_ Italiano_ Polski_ Português_ Russkyi_ Suomi_ Svenska_ Türkçe_
First few lines of all posts of last 24 hours

Links to indexes of first few lines of all posts of past 30 days | of 2002 | of 2003 | of 2004 | of 2005 | of 2006 | of 2007 | of 2008 | of 2009 | of 2010 | of 2011 | of 2012 | of 2013 | of 2014 | of 2015 | of 2016 | of 2017 | of 2018 | of 2019 | of 2020 | of 2021 | of 2022 | of 2023 | of 2024

Syndication Of A-Infos - including RDF - How to Syndicate A-Infos
Subscribe to the a-infos newsgroups

(en) Italy, UCADI FA #180 - The Netherlands between tradition, the Islamic question and inflation (ca, de, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]

Date Sun, 21 Jan 2024 08:36:28 +0200


The Dutch vote which saw the surprising victory of the Freedom Party (PVV) which obtained 37 seats and was accompanied by the success that was certainly not as sensational, but important, of two other populist-oriented parties, that of the New Social Contract ( NSC), led by Pieter Omtzigt, who obtained 20 deputies and the Peasants' Civic Movement (BBB) who obtained 8. Overall, the three parties have 65 seats, while 76 are needed for a government majority. it means that to be formed a government needs an alliance with the old right-wing liberals (VVD) who had the majority in the government before the elections and who today have 24 seats in Parliament. If such a solution were adopted it would mean that the ad exclusion clause which until now has acted as a barrier to the entry into the government of the far right with which all the parties had declared, before the vote, that they would not build alliances, has disappeared. However, the success of the Freedom Party was so sensational and unexpected, and above all accompanied by that of other populist movements, that it cannot be ruled out that an extreme right-wing government could be established in the Netherlands. But, before the contingent alchemy of government, what is of interest is which country photographs the vote, since it gives us the measure of the profound crisis of Dutch democracy and requires us to understand whether it is a crisis limited to the country or more general problems that will soon others who are part of the EU will also invest.
Like all crises, the Dutch one presents internal and external elements, which however are intertwined in an inextricable way, to the point of influencing the entire community policy. The Dutch case in fact represents an important indicator of the possible crisis of the Union in the face of its enlargement problems, conditioned by the war in Ukraine, by the international economic situation, by the disappearance of the energy policy based on the Russian-German axis, by the adoption of a green policy by the EU, all factors that had ensured the Union the stability of its economy.
Added to these external elements are internal factors relating to the crisis of the integration model adopted by the country, which deserves careful examination which we will try to develop taking into account the economic and structural data of the country, as well as elements of a sociological nature which constitute the characterizing traits of the Dutch society decidedly little known and studied within the other countries of the union.

The crisis of the Dutch model of integration

The Netherlands is a country of 17.53 million (2021) inhabitants with substantially stable population growth. During the elections, approximately 10.3 million voters went to the polls out of an estimated total of 13.3 million eligible voters. This corresponds to 91% of the population aged 18 and over. More than half of this group is 50 years old or older. (Statistics Netherlands, based on provisional population data from 1 October 2023). Emigration has a strong impact on this situation, proof of which is that if we look at the age group between 18 and 35, a relatively high number of residents cannot vote because they were not born in the Netherlands and do not (yet) have the Dutch nationality. Almost all over 65s can vote (98%) and 85% between 18 and 35. More than half of adults not born in the Netherlands are unable to vote because they have Dutch nationality. The largest group (57%) has lived in the Netherlands for 25 years or more. Another group, more than a quarter, have lived in the Netherlands for at least ten years. Of these, almost 15% have one or two parents born in the Netherlands.
To better frame the problem of the immigrant population's participation in the vote, it is necessary to take into account the legislation on the acquisition of citizenship which has changed its physiognomy since 2000, as since then the attribution of citizenship to foreigners has no longer been conceived as a means to facilitate the participation of immigrants in the life of the State, according to the original approach of the 1950s, but it was configured as a goal, placed as the culmination of a path of integration. The matter is regulated by the Rijkswet op het Nederlanderschap of 19 December 1984, amended several times, most recently by the law of 21 December 2000, in force since 1 April 2003, which introduced the naturalization test for the first time, as well as the Wet Inburgering civic integration law of 30 November 2006, in force since 1 April 2007.
The Netherlands currently has a mixed system of ius sanguinis and ius soli . Second generation immigrants are granted Dutch citizenship by birthright. The first generation born in the Netherlands to foreign parents retains their parents' citizenship, but for those who have spent most of their lives in the Netherlands, once they reach the age of majority, it is rather easy to obtain Dutch citizenship because they know the language and culture of the country. For the latter, two possibilities open up: using the option procedure ( optieprocedure ) or the naturalization procedure ( naturalisatie). Unlike what happened in other countries, the Dutch approach to naturalization was instrumental, mainly aimed at guaranteeing equal rights to both Dutch citizens and immigrants, without forcing the latter to possess a Dutch passport.
Such an imposition, in fact, would not have been in conformity with the originally dominant ideas of multiculturalism and respect for cultural identity. Consequently, many parts of the legislation were changed to allow foreign residents to participate more actively in Dutch society.
For immigrants, obtaining citizenship is conditional on passing a test on knowledge of the language and society of the Netherlands. In fact, on 1 April 2007 the civic integration law came into force, approved on 30 November 2006, which introduced the new civic integration exam (replacing the previous test), making it mandatory both in order to obtain a permanent residence permit, and to acquire Dutch citizenship: this has meant that a growing number of resident migrants are excluded from voting, because they are not citizens, but nevertheless have access to public and social services as residents.
It follows that especially in cities and suburbs there are more and more people who are part of the population in all respects, but without political and voting rights. The result of this structural situation is that PVV is the most voted party in around 250 of the 342 Dutch municipalities, including cities such as Apeldoorn, The Hague, Rotterdam and Zoetermeer: more than 2.4 million Dutch voted for the PVV, while GroenLinks-PVDA, the party of the left managed to convince the largest number of people in Amsterdam and in most of the big cities.

The failure of integration by membership

In the 70s of the last century, Holland considered itself, and in fact was, the European country that managed to welcome and integrate those who decided to settle there and was the country for the young people of Europe in which they were able to live, in a climate of almost absolute freedom, one's life. Over the years, a different type of emigration has poured into the country, also because the growing needs for the search for well-being, the exponential growth of wars and inequalities in the world, the growing pressure of climate change, have made the migratory phenomenon structural .
This combination of factors meant that a massive migration, with a strong Islamic component, was also concentrated on Dutch territory among those who sought and found refuge in the country.
This new type of migrants introduced something new in Dutch society because the 16 existing cults were joined by another, the Muslim one, completely different from the previous ones, since it had not been subjected to the scrutiny of secularization and had not been subjected to that process of "washing " to which the 16 cults present and recognized in Holland have been subjected over the course of centuries. In fact, during repeated wars, political and cultural battles, the cults present in Holland had had to tone down their fundamentalist needs and accept a necessary coexistence, in the name of tolerance and mutual recognition, giving life to a multi-confessional consociational government system which had expressed the different political parties. The result was an institutional system that was completely peculiar and characterized the country. Strengthened by this experience, the Dutch mistakenly believed that, to solve the problem, it was enough to add one more cult to the others, leaving the developed rules unchanged, and decided to operate by adhesion, placing the Muslim cult alongside the pre-existing cults.
They had spent one hundred and thirty years of reflection to resolve the problem of relations between the State and religious confessions, finally deciding to liquidate every economic relationship between the State and the cults once and for all precisely in those years (1989): well they decided, a posteriori, that the Muslim cult would also have been part of the Interkerkelijk Contact in Overheidszaken (ICO) and would have been somehow associated with the agreements, but they soon realized that things weren't working.
In fact, immediately and without imposing conditions, para-confessional consociativism ends up being of great advantage to the cults, without allowing any of their secularization and does not contribute to the creation of a democratic circuit aimed at the civil education of future citizens. For this to happen it must be "filtered" by a system of values, culturally governed by a secularism shared by all the groups that participate in the consociational pact and this certainly has not been and is not the case for Muslims. All this is even more true if seen in light of the particular financing structure
that characterizes Islam in Europe today and its links with the countries of origin, which is why we are witnessing the increasingly consolidated presence of a network of Salafist mosques directly financed by Saudi Arabia and the Gonfo countries, which compete with two equally dangerous networks of mosques and places of worship financed by Turkey (through Diyanet, an association founded by Atatürk in 1924 with the initial aim of modernizing Islam, but now radicalized) which seeks together with the Ministry of Waqf of Morocco to influence Islam which is taking root in European territory.
These networks remain dependent, not only through funding, on the countries that created them: the Muslims who are part of them are induced to live with their ears and hearts in their country of origin, reproduced by the mass media, they give life to communities closed and cohesive on the territory, Imams come from their countries of origin to lead the cult and in fact act as a point of reference for the communities, as political-religious guarantors of these bonds. These components of the population tend to operate like a State within the State, to create ghettos, to manage the territory by imposing behaviors, customs, food habits, cultural practices foreign to the tradition and customs of other citizens: the hypothesized and hoped for melting pot does not happen by producing rather an identity segmentation of the population, which tends to be conflictual because it exacerbates differences.
Muslim emigration has concentrated in large cities and suburban areas, disrupting the housing market, the provision of social services, the job market, with the growth of black and precarious work.
However, at least essential services must be guaranteed to residents and above all the school service which should act as a vehicle for integration. Well, having chosen not to have a public school, taking advantage of the almost exclusive state funding provided for denominational schools, schools have grown significantly
Muslim schools, ghettoizing the children of migrants, in a particular situation of greater public funding for Muslim confessional schools, produced by the general mechanisms through which the confessional school is nourished. This element has also contributed to generating forms of hostility towards Muslims, seen as a group that uses their condition within a permissive welfare state, to carve out situations of better treatment, while there is a general degradation of public structures . both in terms of health care, the availability of housing, and access to social services, and above all aid and subsidies to deal with the increase in the cost of living, the growth of inflation, in the face of a substantial stagnation of wages and pensions.
All this is happening while, due to environmentalist policies, the incomes of a not insignificant part of the population, made up of rural workers and those who live from livestock farming and agriculture, are reduced as a result of the restrictive measures adopted regarding the use of fertilizers and phosphates, the reduction of arable land imposed to create environmental protection areas, the increased cost of energy, the growth in prices and inflation which has significantly impoverished the standard of living in the once most prosperous part of the country, dedicated to agriculture and livestock, Frissland, today subjected to a concentric attack on its economy and which, not surprisingly, strongly supported the parties that won the last electoral round.

The errors of the left

The left pays the price for having ignored the problems, for having simplistically underestimated the difficulties of integrating migrants, for having forgotten the deep country, and above all for having erased from its own experience all the cultural effort that civil society has made over the centuries and the same components of the social left have done to subdue the Dutch religious communities that threatened to transform the country into a field of eternal religious war in a peaceful and tolerant cultural environment, capable of accepting what is different from itself, in the name of respect for the individual on the one hand and on the other in the superior interest of social cohesion, which alone could guarantee the country the possibility of well-being, development and peaceful coexistence. In proposing themselves as managers of the advanced stage of development of capitalism, all this has been replaced by permissive legislation on multinationals that profit and make profits on low taxation of those companies, of those multinational companies that place their registered office in the country, thus doing a dumping operation on other countries belonging to the European Union, which focus on startups and advanced production processes, neglecting and belittling the production base, made up of agricultural production, which neglect the territory after it has been the objective of maximum care for which the country was famous and proud; who have no hesitation in filling the landscapes with wind turbines that disfigure the landscape, just to make up for the lack of low-cost energy, due to wicked choices in international relations, pretending to ignore that it would not have been necessary to promote research into gas and oil in the North Sea and even in the lands stolen from the sea, with the risk of producing subsidence and the return of the waters, if there had not been the break with Russia, and the support for Ukraine (it is no coincidence that the Freedom Party is against support for Ukraine and does not want its migrants!).
The left has done all this while saying that it wants to pursue an environmentalist policy, of reducing fuel and carbon emissions, that it wants to stimulate the production of alternative energy, without paying attention, for example, to the production of biogas, without reflecting on the economies of possible scale compared to the economic model that characterizes the country, prisoner of a criminal community policy regarding relations with foreign countries and expansion of the community which puts the common agricultural policy and with it the production base of the country at risk.
It is no coincidence that all the parties, winners of the last elections, are against the intervention in Ukraine, the support for this war, the breaking of economic relations with Russia and the use, to please the Americans and the English, of energy coming from the United States and the Gulf Emirates, upon Ukraine's entry into the Union. It is to be believed that if the Netherlands gives itself a right-wing government, it will be difficult for the future European Parliament to ratify Ukraine's entry into the European Union without a blow.

The role of the Farmers' Party (BBB)

Indispensable for the establishment of a right-wing government is the BoerBurgerBeweging Farmers' Party (BBB) which has 8 seats and comes from the Christian Democratic centre. The party is led by Caroline van der Plas. and won the 2023 Dutch provincial elections, winning the most seats in all twelve provinces. Since the provincial councils elect the Dutch Senate the party holds 16 seats in the Upper House. The BBB is a right-wing agrarian and populist political party aligned on Eurosceptic positions and limits itself to supporting Dutch membership of the European Union for exclusively commercial purposes, while but wants to reduce the power of the EU "to the level of how it was once understood the EEC". It therefore opposes the federalisation of the EU arguing that each country and region within the Union should be allowed to maintain its own identity and culture without interference. In foreign policy, however, the party has Atlanticist positions, as it supports the Netherlands' membership in NATO and has called for supplying Ukraine with F-16s.
Regarding immigration and asylum, BBB supports the reception of refugees fleeing wars, but prefers that they be helped close to the region from which they come rather than encouraging migration to the Netherlands and requires that most refugees return home once the conflict is over. In the case of
economic migrants, it demands that immigrants are already employed and financially self-sufficient before moving to the Netherlands, and that they must learn Dutch, work and pay taxes in the Netherlands for at least five years before being entitled to permanent residency; illegal immigrants must be deported.
The party pays a lot of attention to food policy and rural development, strongly opposes the green policy of the European Union and the proposals to mitigate the human impact on the nitrogen cycle in response to the nitrogen crisis in the Netherlands, considers the Party for the Animals and the animal rights organization is one of its main enemies as it opposes intensive farming. He promises to establish a "countryside ministry" located at least 100 kilometers from The Hague and the removal of the ban on neonicotinoids and proposes to pass a right to farm law, which would allow farmers to have a greater say on agricultural extensions .

The Omtzigt anomaly affects the coalition

A sensational success, which was also announced, was achieved by the New Social Contract (NSC) party, a "personal party" led by Omtzigt which elected 20 deputies. This party, which comes from a split of D66, a centrist, Catholic-oriented political formation, owes its success mainly to its leader's management of the scandal consisting of the unjust request for reimbursement of family allowances made by migrant families since 2013 to 2019 who would have unduly enjoyed tax benefits.
The parliamentary investigation has shown that in reality Mark Rutte's government, in its inability to develop a policy to combat immigration, has established forms of bureaucratic persecution of migrants, to illicitly affect their chances of living and settling in the country, through an excessive burden of taxation, in clear violation of current legislation. The investigation demonstrated that the finance officials acted on the basis of precise indications from the bureaucratic leaders, profiling taxpayers on an ethnic basis, who, based on their surnames, were reached with requests for the repayment of family allowances received. Victims of embezzlement were, unjustly, thousands of Dutch citizens, many of them immigrants. The scandal, which involved more than 10,000 Dutch families, was the basis for the early resignation of the Rutte government and Omtzigt was able to demonstrate that innocent people were criminalized and thousands of families were deprived of the necessary subsidies intended for child care for amount of tens of thousands of euros. There have been many full-blown cases of bankruptcy and even divorce, fueling general indignation.
It must be said that in presenting the resignation of the entire executive, Rutte then called a press conference in which he assumed, together with his ministers, the "political responsibility" for the scandal. Stating that "Innocent people have been criminalised, their lives have been destroyed and the House has been informed incorrectly and incompletely. Political responsibility - he declared - lies with the government in office and no one else" and promised compensation to the families involved in the affair and a reform of the bureaucratic mechanisms that gave rise to it, which did not take place due to the elections.
This was one of the reasons for the many consensuses that reached Omtzigt who was very skilled in taking vague and generic positions on many problems, to the point that it cannot be said whether his positions are right or left, but he presents and above all, offers his party, as good for all sides, if the declared aim is to proceed with the moralization of the country. What distances him from the positions of the Freedom Party (PVV) and the BBB is the position towards the European Union, he is pro-European, and the Ukrainian war: Omtzigt wants to have weight in Brussels and supports the Atlanticist choices and the BORN.
In light of these considerations, it is clear that the meeting between the three parties we have dealt with will certainly be a common policy in defending the interests of Dutch agriculture and the reasons of the farmers who are affected by environmentalist politics, the flower of the 'buttonhole of the left and the previous liberal government, which do not share the restrictions on Dutch agriculture that Ukraine's entry into the union would entail, which suggests a different foreign and community policy position of the future Dutch government on this delicate issue.
However, significant points of divergence with the farmers' party would remain the policy on intensive farming that farmers support, the opposition to the expansion of natural parks that farmers oppose, and many other issues that require necessary mediation and quite a few compromises also for satisfy the positions in this regard supported by the freedom party.
Since the government coalition requires the necessary presence of the liberal party, it is not clear when the compromise necessary for the formation of the executive which also involves this last political formation, which finds moments of convergence with the others in immigration policy, can hold, and this is undoubtedly an element of cohesion of the future majority, but it records very marked differences in orientation in foreign policy and economic policy, while a battleground is certainly constituted by the measures to be undertaken and supported to satisfy the demands of the agricultural world Dutch who had so much political weight in the recent electoral confrontation. Therefore the negotiations will be long, with an uncertain outcome and everything to be verified.

Gianni Cimbalo

https://www.ucadi.org/2023/12/20/lolanda-tra-tradizione-questione-islamica-e-inflazione/
_________________________________________
A - I N F O S N E W S S E R V I C E
By, For, and About Anarchists
Send news reports to A-infos-en mailing list
A-infos-en@ainfos.ca
Subscribe/Unsubscribe https://ainfos.ca/mailman/listinfo/a-infos-en
Archive: http://ainfos.ca/en
A-Infos Information Center