|
A - I n f o s
|
|
a multi-lingual news service by, for, and about anarchists
**
News in all languages
Last 30 posts (Homepage)
Last two
weeks' posts
Our
archives of old posts
The last 100 posts, according
to language
Greek_
中文 Chinese_
Castellano_
Catalan_
Deutsch_
Nederlands_
English_
Francais_
Italiano_
Polski_
Português_
Russkyi_
Suomi_
Svenska_
Türkurkish_
The.Supplement
The First Few Lines of The Last 10 posts in:
Castellano_
Deutsch_
Nederlands_
English_
Français_
Italiano_
Polski_
Português_
Russkyi_
Suomi_
Svenska_
Türkçe_
First few lines of all posts of last 24 hours
Links to indexes of first few lines of all posts
of past 30 days |
of 2002 |
of 2003 |
of 2004 |
of 2005 |
of 2006 |
of 2007 |
of 2008 |
of 2009 |
of 2010 |
of 2011 |
of 2012 |
of 2013 |
of 2014 |
of 2015 |
of 2016 |
of 2017 |
of 2018 |
of 2019 |
of 2020 |
of 2021 |
of 2022 |
of 2023 |
of 2024
Syndication Of A-Infos - including
RDF - How to Syndicate A-Infos
Subscribe to the a-infos newsgroups
(en) France, 2nd UCL Congress (Angers, November 3-5, 2023) Revolutionary trade unionist reflection (ca, de, fr, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]
Date
Thu, 18 Jan 2024 08:30:30 +0200
The UCL Manifesto defined the revolutionary trade unionist practice of
our political movement. But there remains an important question: in
which organizations to register it? What logic of libertarian
intervention should we develop? An analysis of the French union
landscape is necessary, as well as a reflection on the breakup of
militant unionism and the paths to possible unification. ---- A
REVOLUTIONARY AND LIBERTY ANALYSIS GRID ---- Our reading must start from
the anti-capitalist and self-managing purpose that we wish to see the
trade union movement endorse. We must therefore cross:
The capacity for action. Does the union have sufficient space, in terms
of numbers, locations and representativeness, to put employees into action ?
Orientation. Does the union articulate immediate demands and an
anti-capitalist project, in continuity with the " double task " set
out by the Amiens Charter ? Is it democratic ? Does it favor direct
action by workers, or a delegated atmosphere ? Does it push for
interprofessional solidarity, and therefore class consciousness ? Does
it articulate specific demands (anti-racist, feminist, LGBTI,
anti-validist) with general demands concerning the entire proletariat,
in an intersectional logic ? Does he use legal representation to
co-manage or to fight ? Is he using union unity as a pretext for
inaction, or as a lever to drive action ?
By combining these two approaches, both " quantitative " and "
qualitative ", we will not be fooled either by the large numbers
claimed, nor by pure declarations of intent.
Militant forces without equal but at low water...
While, from 1955 to 1980, the unionization rate in France oscillated
between 15% and 20% of employees , it has plateaued, since 1990, at
around 10%. This average figure actually hides strong disparities, since
in 2019 the public service was 18% unionized, compared to 8% in the
private sector, at very variable rates (16.5% in transport and
logistics, 11% in industry, 3.4% in construction). The gender difference
was less dramatic: 11% of workers were unionized in 2019, compared to
9.5% of female workers [1].
This numerical weakness must be put into perspective by the specific
nature of French trade unionism. In countries where unions are very
institutionalized, employees join them primarily to access services or
mutual insurance. In France, where joining a union does not " return
anything ", and is more of a commitment (sometimes risky), the numbers
are significantly lower.
From the point of view of commitment, precisely, the situation is
worrying, since in 2019, only 40 % of union members participated in the
activity of their union, compared to 49% in 2013 [2].
...but which remain essential
Despite this weakening, trade unionism remains an essential player in
France, to the extent that no " non-company " social movement has so
far outclassed it, neither in terms of rooting in the proletariat, nor
in terms of mass action. It remains the first place where workers,
precarious workers, the unemployed, in all their diversity (racialized,
gender minorities, etc.) spontaneously organize to defend their
interests. It remains the only force capable of putting millions of
people on strike and on the streets.
From this point of view, combative unionism remains an essential
vehicle for a libertarian revolutionary strategy, based on the direct
action of workers, outside institutions and governments.
THREE POLES IN THE UNION LANDSCAPE IN FRANCE
In view of the developments of the last five years, we can discern three
poles in the union landscape in France [3]: a combative pole, a
co-management pole , and a pole which we would describe as " ambivalent
" .
1/ A combative union center, focusing on the balance of power
The CGT, at the crossroads
Since the 1980s, the CGT has experienced a slow but continuous erosion
of its membership and audience, despite increases during periods of
struggle. With 605,000 members in 2020, 23% audience in the private
sector and 21% in the public sector, it nevertheless remains a central
organization in the class struggle.
The weakening of the organizational culture is worrying, with many union
teams reduced to a core of elected officials at the CSE, without field
practice, with the decline of local unions, with the increase in the
number of union members · are isolated · es (15% of the confederal
workforce), and with growing antagonism between certain federations.
Since the 1990s, the Stalinist imprint on the CGT has continued to
decline. On the negative side, in most sectors, it has only been
replaced by reformism, corporatism, or even the most flat
depoliticization, or clientelism. On the positive side, pluralism has
increased in the organization, where for example we come across more and
more libertarians, ecologists, feminists, or non-Stalinist communists.
Among the achievements: anti-racist issues and support for undocumented
immigrants are well integrated... On the other hand, the visibility of
racialized minorities in coordination and representation positions
remains very out of step with the unionized base.
Among the questions that are progressing: feminism is on the rise, and
is shaking up the Stalinist-conservatives, but has not yet made them
bend. Women make up 39% of the workforce, and are called to federal and
confederal responsibilities by a proactive parity policy. At the March
2023 congress, the election of Sophie Binet as general secretary
obviously had a strong symbolic significance.
At the confederal congress in March 2023, distancing itself from the
Ecological and Social Alliance-PJC sent a very negative signal. This
does not prevent environmental issues from becoming more and more
present due to the climate crisis.
The Stalinist-conservatives, especially present in the management of
certain federations, today constitute the heavy rearguard of the CGT,
putting the brakes on all the stops on environmentalist, feminist issues
or on union unity. Their demand for a " return to the World Federation
of Trade Unions ", a bureaucratic and anti-class struggle body led by
dictatorial states, was fortunately swept aside by the confederal
congress of March 2023.
The potential of the CGT lies in its anti-establishment image, which
instinctively makes it the union of choice for many angry employees ;
when they politicize themselves via the CGT, it is mainly on an
illiberal, sometimes anti-capitalist basis.
Solidarity, assets to go further
After strong development in the 2000s, the Solidaires trade union has
stabilized at a level of 110,000 members , 6% audience in the public
service and 4% in the private sector.
The common culture which has long been lacking in Solidaires is
progressing at the national level, due to the good will of most
federations to converge points of view within Solidaires, rather than
playing the balance of power. On the other hand, the development of
local unions is stalling, with unions operating in a too often
compartmentalized manner.
Struggling unionism and the reference to the general strike are
constitutive of the identity of Solidaires. But the extraordinary
congress of 2020 saw a major qualitative advance by explicitly adopting
socialization and self-management as an " alternative to the capitalist
system ".
The appropriation of this orientation, and even the combativeness in the
federations and in the union base, are obviously unequal. As with the
CGT, the ambient depoliticization is causing damage, and the militant
culture of the founding generation has been poorly transmitted.
However, when it is based on solid sectoral establishments (rail,
education, PTT, health and social, public finances, etc.), this
anti-capitalist, self-managing, internationalist, feminist,
environmentalist, anti-colonialist and anti-racist line can constitute a
point of support for the revolutionaries and libertarians who want to
bring it to life.
Regionalist and overseas unions
In their respective regions, the Corsican STC, the Basque LAB, the
Guadeloupe UGTG, the Martinique CGTM, the Guyanese UTG and the
Caledonian USTKE are well established, and sometimes even the strongest
union organizations.
These unions, which try to combine national emancipation and social
emancipation, can have combative and direct action practices from which
the French combat unions could draw inspiration. This does not prevent
possible contradictions, as in Kanaky where the USTKE finds itself
co-directing companies with French capitalists in the name of national "
rebalancing ".
The CNT-F fails to change its nature
The CNT-F, anarcho-syndicalist and revolutionary syndicalist, has
between 500 and 1000 members , and boycotts most professional elections.
In certain sectors (education, construction, labor and social affairs),
CNT teams carry out real union work. However, the vast majority of CNT
groups are called " interco ", which means that their real nature is
political. These are far-left groups involved in struggles, but not
unions, nor trade unions, nor trade unions, nor business unions.
The paid work of the CNT-SO
The CNT-SO, a revolutionary trade unionist, has around 1,000 members ,
with a very localized electoral audience. With a methodical strategy, it
established itself in industrial cleaning, the hotel industry, even
construction, where it led notable struggles with chambermaids,
undocumented immigrants... However, it did not manage to establish
itself in other sectors, where the space for combative unionism is
already occupied by SUD or the CGT.
2/ A co-management pole, attached to the ideology of " social dialogue "
The CFDT put to the test of reality
After the departure of its left wing in 1988-2003, the CFDT was rebuilt.
It now has more than 600,000 members , with an audience of 18.5% in the
public sector and 27% in the private sector ; its presence in SMEs is
quite significant and it has 50% women in its workforce.
The CFDT is committed to liberal ideology, but its primary motivation is
to be recognized as an institutional interlocutor (" I negotiate
therefore I exist "), even without any results. A centralized
organization, it is capable of providing leadership and bringing
dissident federations and unions into line.
Its non-betrayal of the 2023 fight for the defense of pensions - a first
in thirty years - is due to cyclical factors (the pressure from part of
its base, government intransigence, the absence of excesses and strikes
hard) and will not change its deep nature.
The timeless CFTC
Claiming 140,000 members, the CFTC has an audience of 2.7% in the public
sector and 9.5% in the private sector.
Inspired by the social doctrine of the Catholic Church, it practices
class collaboration in the interest of the company, which is " first
and foremost a community of people ". But it sometimes happens to CFTC
sections to rebel when the employers trample too much on " the sacred
dimension of the human being ".
The CFE-CGC, the faithful " social partner "
Claiming 100,000 members among engineers, executives and technicians,
the CFE-CGC has an audience of 4% in the public service and 12% in the
private sector.
The CGC defends the corporate interests of executives, while deeming
them non-antagonistic to those of employers. In recent years, the
defense of social protection has nevertheless sometimes positioned it
further to the left than the CFDT.
3/ An ambivalent pole, oscillating between co-management and struggle
The FSU, attempts to escape corporatism
Essentially based in the teaching profession, the FSU has, since the
2010s, affiliated a few unions in local authorities and with Pôle
emploi. It has 160,000 members , is non-existent in the private sector,
but represents 9% in the public service (90% in National Education).
Structured by profession, its priority remains the defense of public
service and civil servant status. Opposed to neoliberalism, it has
officially considered unification within the CGT since its beginnings in
1993. Service to members is its strength, but also explains its lack of
dynamism, showing it to be more capable of supporting struggles than of
leading them. impulse. A trade union organization that is often in the
majority where it is present, its activist bases are heterogeneous and
can sometimes contain allies .
Its functioning in " trends ", presented as a guarantee of pluralism,
maintains a perpetual division and results de facto in a
disproportionate weight of certain political fractions internally.
Working force, principled isolationism
FO claims 350,000 members , has a 15% audience in the private sector and
19% in the public sector. At the national level, FO makes the big
difference between a co-management pole, around metallurgy, and a more
combative pole led by POI and POID activists, but above all focused on
the defense of what exists, without demands transformative, without an
alternative social project, and a perfect indifference to feminism or
ecology. Assuming a party/union division of labor which subverts the
Amiens Charter, the organization aims to be " apolitical ", which
explains why FO is the confederation most permeable to the extreme right.
Unsa, the surprises of unionism without a compass
Unsa brings together 200,000 members , with 6% of audience in the
private sector and 12% in the public sector. Ideologically invertebrate,
Unsa is a conglomeration of federations with little in common. Depending
on the atmosphere of the moment, some are capable of moving from the
flattest co-management to the harshest conflict, as we saw during the
strikes at the SNCF and the RATP in 2019-2020.
THE SAME LOGIC OF LIBERTY INTERVENTION
We claim to have a revolutionary trade unionist practice and strategy,
as explained in the UCL Manifesto. During the period, libertarian trade
unionists must share as a priority, whatever their union organization
and their level of intervention (local, federal, confederal/national),
this same logic of action:
build, as a priority, broad combative unions, promote grassroots
democracy and promote socialist and self-management ideas ;
promote union training for members to have the maximum number of
activists and allow maximum self-management in the union ;
encourage direct collective action by workers ;
promote interprofessional action by boosting local and departmental
unions ; instigate regular union tours in union deserts and launch
organizing campaigns.
favor branch unions, rather than the scattering of skeletal company unions ;
promote and support the struggles of undocumented immigrants, push for
unionization in sectors concentrating racialized workers ;
push for the unionization of feminized sectors, strategic for organizing
the proletariat and blocking the economy ;
fight the obstacles to women and gender minorities taking responsibility
in our unions.
push for clear protocols to combat gender-based and sexual violence.
demand the socialization of the means of production by relying in
particular on the questions raised by the ecological crisis ;
fight against the extreme right in the unions ;
promote unity of action beyond sectarianism and push the debate on the
interest of unifying militant unionism ;
promote internationalist solidarity: responding to the same employer
across borders ; develop union networks, solidarity in our professional
branches and our federations in connection with unions in other
countries, support for peoples fighting against imperialism (Kurdistan,
Palestine, Ukraine, etc.).
develop the policy of employing comrades that we started.
FOR A UNIFICATION OF STRUGGLE UNIONISM
It is within the CGT-FSU-Solidaires trio, often united in action in
recent years, that this perspective has found the beginnings of
reflection and some openings [4].
Libertarian trade unionists are in favor of it. Not to hammer out an
unrealistic slogan for immediate unification, but to disseminate
reflection on possible scenarios, if the circumstances were favorable.
A scenario of simple absorption into " the great CGT ", which would
crush the militant cultures of Solidaires and the FSU, is illusory: it
would be swept away into the union teams.
A scenario of unification from the top, at the end of staff
negotiations, is fortunately impossible due to the confederalist
functioning of the CGT and Solidaires. Agreements at all levels of the
federations, congresses well appropriated by the base, would be
essential, and that is so much the better.
Offensive unification in a new confederation is the most desirable
scenario. It can proceed from voluntarism at the confederal and national
level, with slow construction, reinforced unity, and including common
coordination tools.
But nothing could be done without the will of the intermediate levels
and the base, where unity could emerge as a result of common practices,
unitary campaigns, joint resistance to a possible far-right government,
a large-scale social movement. It is only by gaining mutual trust, at
the grassroots level, that an agreement could be reached on the sharing
of positions and resources, an inevitable factor in local tensions.
To go beyond this, we would also need a vision of unification as a step
towards massification, of which three strong axes could be:
a real priority for local inter-professional unions ;
openness to all social movements ;
a process of conquering union deserts and workers on the fringes of wage
employment.
a reduction in tensions between trade union organizations, which
libertarians will encourage by promoting joint work and camaraderie when
possible (union tours, moments of sociability, reports and leaflets,
meetings, protest notebooks, etc.).
A unification of militant unionism would create a dynamic and create a
key player in the class struggle in France. It would help the
proletariat to regain confidence in its collective strength. And in
this, it would promote a resurgence of revolutionary trade unionism.
To validate
[1] Ministry of Labor, Dares Analyzes n°6, February 2023.
[2] Ministry of Labor, Dares Analyzes n°6, February 2023.
[3] To measure their respective weights, we use here, with a critical
distance, the claimed numbers ; the results of the 2022 civil service
elections ; the 2021 measure of representativeness in the private
sector, based on the results of the CSE elections (2017-2020), the TPE
elections (2021) and the elections to the chambers of agriculture (2019).
[4] " Union unification, for what purpose ? » , Libertarian
Alternative, May 2022
https://www.unioncommunistelibertaire.org/?Reflexion-syndicaliste-revolutionnaire
_________________________________________
A - I N F O S N E W S S E R V I C E
By, For, and About Anarchists
Send news reports to A-infos-en mailing list
A-infos-en@ainfos.ca
Subscribe/Unsubscribe https://ainfos.ca/mailman/listinfo/a-infos-en
Archive: http://ainfos.ca/en
- Prev by Date:
(en) France, UCL AL #344 - Anti-validism, Telethon: Humiliation and good feelings in prime time (ca, de, fr, it, pt, tr)[machine translation]
- Next by Date:
(en) Greece, espiv anarchism: Pola Rupa: STATE VERSUS COMMUNITY - Book presentations (ca, de, it, pt, tr) [machine translation]
A-Infos Information Center